Yesterday was 25 Kislev in the Hebrew calendar, or the first day of Hanukkah. The opening celebrations occur the evening prior, which meant the Jewish community of Sydney, Australia, was undertaking happy preparations on the evening of 24 Kislev — that is, Dec. 14.
About one thousand people had gathered at the seaside Archer Park in the Bondi Beach neighborhood for a community celebration hosted by the Jewish group Chabad, which also hosts a popular menorah-lighting event in Pittsburgh’s Squirrel Hill neighborhood. In moments, the Pittsburgh and Sydney would share a terrible bond.
Two men opened fire on a community celebrating the triumph of light over darkness, and the resilience of the Jewish people through the millennia. They killed at least 15 people. One of the assailants was killed in a shootout, and the second is in custody.
The terrorist attack takes its place among a growing list of incidents of antisemitic violence, which include the United States’ most deadly such assault: the 2018 mass shooting at Squirrel Hill’s Tree of Life – Or L'Simcha Congregation synagogue, which hosted the New Light Congregation and Congregation Dor Hadash. That attack killed eleven members of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community.
A 2024 analysis by the FBI showed that 70% of all “religion-based hate crimes” in America target Jews, who comprise 2% of the population. The number of such incidents is at an all-time high, and is rising.
Each of these attacks victimizes particular individuals and particular communities, but also the Jewish people as a whole. In Pittsburgh, every Jewish community event, from worship services to baking classes to film screenings, is highly secured. The sense of living under threat is permanent. For this reason, in a very real sense Jews are not free to worship, as they have a right to in this country, in the way other faith communities are.
Yet it is in the spirit of Judaism and of Hanukkah in particular to seek and to embrace light within darkness. Specifically, in addition to the well-known story of the lamp-oil that lasted eight days instead of one, Hanukkah is a holiday about heroism.
The miracle of the light only occurred because one of the great heroes of Jewish history, Judas Maccabeus, defended his people against the depredations of the Seleucid Empire in the second century B.C. It was his courage that led to the rededication of the Second Temple, an eight-day ceremony commemorated in Hanukkah.
Bondi Beach also had a hero who saved Jewish lives due to physical courage. His name is Ahmed el Ahmed, an Australian citizen and Muslim native of Syria, and during the massacre he tackled and disarmed one of the two assailants. He was seriously injured in the process, but is recovering at a Sydney hospital.
It is impossible to know how many innocents are alive and unharmed today because of el Ahmed’s action. His heroism brings to mind the Talmudic phrase, which appears on the medal awarded to the “Righteous Among the Nations” and (in a different translation) in the film “Schindler’s List:” “Whoever saves one life, it is as if he saved an entire universe.”
The light of human goodness doesn’t burst into flame on its own. It requires individual people to make the hard choice to do the right thing, and sometimes the heroic thing. This is the only certain antidote to evil and hatred.
Tomorrow is 27 Kislev, when Jewish tradition holds that the rains of the 40-day great flood, on which Noah’s Ark floated, finally came to an end. Let us hope that the flood of hate may soon recede, and commit to building communities where it has no place.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.