The financial situation of the Pittsburgh Public School District is dire. For the second time in four years, the school board is considering a property tax increase to address the district’s structural deficit. This is despite the fact that PPS already receives more than its fair share of state education funding.

The district’s financial struggles are being compounded by the withholding of that state funding due to the budget impasse in Harrisburg. To conserve its reserve funds, PPS has suspended all “non-essential spending,” which includes even using copy paper to print elementary school homework assignments. Students as young as first and second grade are being asked to complete their assignments online.

This is all taking place in the context of a controversial and badly mismanaged right-sizing of the district’s footprint — that is, school closures.

And yet, despite the district’s deficit; despite its appetite for more Pittsburgh taxpayer dollars; and despite its willingness to burden families with draconian cost-savings measures, the PPS board just approved spending $115,000 on a deal to get Superintendent Wayne N. Walters facetime on a local television station.

Advertise with us

It’s a small expenditure compared to the district’s $700 million budget, but it’s a striking example of the lack of seriousness of PPS leadership, which refuses to take even the simplest of austerity measures — cutting back on marketing deals — to get public education in Pittsburgh on solid financial footing. It further indicates a continuing emphasis on managing the district’s reputation rather than actually improving the education it provides.

Indeed, in the context of so many other failures, it raises the question of whether the governance of the district by an elected board is even tenable.

Reputation over results

The expense line from the Oct. 22 PPS board meeting indicates the district is contracting with WPXI “to provide Pittsburgh Public Schools an integrated presence in relevant, hyper-local content related to Diversity, Equity and Inclusion issues the citizens of Pittsburgh are facing in their everyday lives. In addition, the partnership will expand to include 10 monthly long-form (2:40 minutes) segments with Superintendent Wayne N. Walters. The total contract amount shall not exceed $115,000.”

In practice, this means that PPS is the named sponsor of occasional stories (there are about a half dozen on the WPXI website from the last year) labeled “Pittsburgh Gets Real” on the television station. Additionally, Mr. Walters gets 160 seconds of paid airtime ten times a year.

Regardless of whether this is a good deal in isolation, in the context of the district’s financial situation it’s an almost absurd extravagance. And it’s particularly unjustifiable as the district has asked parents to tolerate so much, from school closures to canceled field trips to going paperless, in the name of financial necessity.

Advertise with us

And now they’re going back to the trough of property taxes, again.

Unsustainable finances

Pittsburgh Public Schools is the most overfunded school district in Pennsylvania. That’s because of a principle called “hold harmless” in the state’s previous school funding formula, which held funding stable for shrinking districts. This rule was meant to ensure that schools in economically and demographically struggling communities weren’t financially punished by the state, potentially leading to a death spiral.

According to figures released during the 2024 debates over state education funding, PPS benefited to the tune of $85 million a year from hold harmless. In other words, based purely on the district’s enrollment, it should have received $85 million less than it did from Harrisburg.

And yet in 2024 PPS still spent nearly $7 million more than it brought in. And this year, the projected loss is up to $21.5 million.

The proposed 2026 budget is $18.8 million in the red, and that’s assuming the 4% tax hike goes into effect and raises $6.9 million. Even the proposed “right-sizing” wouldn’t save enough to get the district in the black, according to this Thursday’s presentation by Mr. Walters. This is not sustainable.

Advertise with us

Kids’ best interests

It’s true the district has headwinds beyond its control. Of the three taxing bodies within city limits — county, city, schools — it has the highest millage and is by far the most reliant on property taxes, which means PPS has been the most exposed to declines in commercial property values due to the COVID pandemic and the county’s nonsensical real estate assessment system. The district has cut tens of millions in refund checks in the past few years, while its revenues have declined.

PPS leaders also continue to grouse about the one-quarter percent of earned income taxes it’s forced to send to the City of Pittsburgh, a legacy of a 90s-era spat between the two and the city’s desperation during its time under Act 47. Ending this roughly $25 million annual transfer would temporarily resolve the district’s deficit (and immiserate Pittsburgh) — but it would do nothing to resolve the underlying spending problem. In fact, it would only further enable it.

This brings us to PPS leadership — especially its board, in which financial responsibility is vested — which has shown neither the fiscal discipline nor the moral seriousness to justify being entrusted with any more taxpayer dollars. Spending $115 grand to put the superintendent on television for 27 minutes a year is a particularly egregious example of this unseriousness, but it’s surely only the tip of the iceberg.

Without a major course correction — and the shambolic school-closure scheme, which we support in principle but which has been badly mismanaged, doesn’t qualify — Pittsburgh Public Schools will eventually come under state supervision. That may be for the best.

Before that happens, though, city leaders should carefully study the district’s governance — specifically, whether an elected board remains in Pittsburgh’s children’s best interest.

Advertise with us

In Philadelphia, for instance, its nine school board members are appointed by the mayor and confirmed by City Council. This is hardly a panacea, but would likely result in a board more willing to make hard but necessary decisions, without having elections to worry about.

It could hardly be worse than the leadership Pittsburgh’s families must endure right now.