After more than three years of unsettled leadership for the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, what the force needs most is stability. City Council was right, therefore, to extend Acting Chief Martin Devine’s status through the New Year, when a new mayor will have taken office. This move gives officers certainty with regard to leadership through the end of Mayor Ed Gainey’s term, and makes it much more likely that the next full chief will be a long-term solution for the bureau.

One of the contributing factors to Mr. Gainey’s primary election defeat by Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor was the incumbent’s mishandling of police leadership. The result was an unprecedented five chiefs, acting and full, in three years.

The story began in May 2022, when a report from Mr. Gainey’s mayoral transition team declared that then-Chief Scott Schubert needed to be replaced so a new vision for public safety could be implemented. Later that month, Mr. Schubert announced his retirement, effective July 1 of that year. Mr. Gainey undertook a national search while Deputy Chief Thomas Stangrecki assumed acting chief duties.

That national search ended up taking about 10 months, and culminated in chaos. The names of three finalists were leaked: Ryan Lee, a former chief in Boise, Idaho, who was almost charged with a crime for injuring an officer during a training exercise; Jason Lando, a former Pittsburgh officer who served, and still serves, as chief in Frederick, Md.; and Larry Scirotto, another former Pittsburgh officer who moonlighted as an NCAA basketball referee and had been sued as chief in Ft. Lauderdale for allegedly preferring non-white officers for promotions.

Advertise with us

Rumors swirled at the time that Mr. Gainey had offered the job to Mr. Lee, and then reneged once his training mishap came to light. He ultimately settled on Mr. Scirotto, who took the helm in May 2023.

Chief Scirotto came to grief less than 18 months later when he began refereeing again, seemingly violating promises made when he appeared before City Council during his vetting. Mr. Gainey later said, and then denied saying, that he and Mr. Scirotto had a handshake deal about returning to the court after a year. But Mr. Scirotto’s credibility was not salvageable, and he resigned in late October 2024.

This led to Mr. Gainey naming Deputy Chief Christopher Ragland as acting chief, and later nominating him to be the new full chief. But conflict with City Council over the extent of the public process to vet Mr. Ragland stalled his nomination, and in early March of this year he withdrew his name and resigned from the bureau. Acting chief duties fell to Assistant Chief Martin Devine, who lives in Bethel Park and is therefore ineligible to be the permanent chief.

In this context, it makes no sense for the outgoing Mr. Gainey to appoint a sixth chief during his tenure, who is likely to be replaced by his successor — presumably Mr. O’Connor. For Mr. O’Connor’s part, he is correct to have sworn off performing another national search, which would delay a return to stability for the bureau for several more months. Mr. O’Connor should have a chief in mind, ready to go as soon as he takes office.

One person who should be under consideration is the former Pittsburgh commander passed over by Mr. Gainey two years ago: Jason Lando. He knows this city, and has cut his teeth as a small-city chief in Maryland. Local experience plus fresh eyes could be just what the bureau needs.

Whoever is selected, he or she must be committed for the long haul. The last thing Pittsburgh needs is another short-term police chief.