How many units of affordable housing have been created or preserved in Pittsburgh on Ed Gainey’s watch? It’s a surprisingly difficult question to answer, but it’s become a flashpoint in the primary campaign between Mr. Gainey and Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor.
One thing is clear, however: Mr. Gainey’s claims have been wildly inconsistent, and every figure he’s thrown out has seriously inflated the provable data.
This reflects the fact that creating and preserving deeply affordable housing — for the purposes of this argument, “affordable housing” primarily means rentals available to households making less than 50% area median income (AMI) — is a bureaucratically and logistically difficult task. It is not, as Mr. Gainey argued in his 2021 campaign against then-Mayor Bill Peduto, purely a matter of will. It’s a matter of competence.
Unfortunately, the Gainey administration has not proven adept at navigating existing housing systems, nor has it innovated new systems. And Mr. Gainey’s campaign bluster can’t change that.
Mr. Gainey has regularly claimed to have created more affordable housing than any previous mayor, citing figures from as high as 2,000 new affordable units to as low as about 1,000. None of these claims are true. And we can tell this from the Gainey administration’s own data.
In order to bolster Mr. Gainey’s campaign claims, the Gainey administration — yes, that’s the city government using public workers’ time and taxpayer dollars to help the mayor’s re-election campaign — produced an “affordable housing tracker,” which list affordable developments and plots them on a map. It’s a good tool, which should have been created long ago.
But it doesn’t say what Mr. Gainey wants it to say.
Since taking office, according to the city’s own data, 201 new units of affordable housing have been fully built and are ready to be occupied in Pittsburgh. Another 299 have been preserved, and while preservation of affordability doesn’t have the same political resonance, it’s a difficult task that helps people stay in their homes. So it’s fair to credit the Gainey administration with 500 units, ready to go.
That’s not 2,000, 1,600, 1,000 or any of the other claims Mr. Gainey has made on the campaign trail. And it’s not at all a historic record. Unfortunately, however, it’s difficult to compare, because in recent months the Urban Redevelopment Authority has conveniently deleted 20 years of annual reports from its website.
The one way you can get to 1,600 is to add up all new and preserved units that are completed, under construction or “in process,” which means financing is secured but shovels aren’t yet in the ground. This is obviously a much weaker claim. And within it, there are data points that argue against Mr. Gainey’s approach.
First, of those 1,600 units, only 32, or 2%, are due to the city’s inclusionary zoning policy, which Mr. Gainey would like to extend citywide. This is solid evidence against that move.
Second, of those 1,600 units, only 58, or about 4%, are for-sale — the kind of housing that builds generational wealth and doesn’t serve as an income trap. And even that success is due to OwnPGH, a program Mr. Gainey takes credit for but was created by Mr. Peduto, who proposed $21 million in federal COVID relief funds for the initiative. Mr. Gainey reduced that to $15 million.
No one can doubt the Gainey administration has desired to make affordable housing a priority. The lack of success, however, shows that desire is not enough: It requires sophisticated policymaking and complex execution. Those have not been hallmarks of Mr. Gainey’s tenure.
Nor has honesty with the people of Pittsburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.