The Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh (HACP) recently updated City Council at a post-agenda meeting on its improvements to the Housing Choice Voucher program, previously known as Section 8, which subsidizes rent payments for low-income tenants. The office highlighted their new, often above market-rate payment tiers meant to draw more landlords into the program.

While the new voucher rates will certainly be an upgrade, the agency's inability to properly coordinate the flow of information between the city, landlords, and tenants remain the biggest barrier to participation — and an issue that the HACP has been unable to fix despite years of promises, causing waitlists to balloon.

This is important because some housing advocates believe these vouchers, which compensate landlords for offering below-market-rate units, could help property owners absorb the costs of affordable housing mandates, such as inclusionary zoning. The problem is that HACP is so hard to work with that the it’s not worth it for landlords.

During the meeting between HACP and City Council in late October, landlords discussed how the complex set of inspections and approvals required for the smooth running of the program often breaks down. Worse, the opacity of the agency’s procedures mean those partners aren’t able to see where the process has failed. While HACP aims for a process of less than 60 days (itself still a burden for landlords), one landlord reported waiting over four months — costing a third of a year’s rent in unpredictable and unaccountable downtime. Others mentioned having open units and repeatedly requesting tenants, with none ultimately referred — despite an apparent backlog of thousands of voucher applications.

Advertise with us

HACP officials seemed unwilling to grant landlords a peek into the process, citing the federal privacy act that limits what information the government may collect and share. But a simple, automatic notification when tenants submit any information to the HACP would be enough to speed the process. The newly overhauled HCV Partner Portal, made to store information like rent payment history and inspection dates, is the obvious place for this feature.

Over the years, HACP executive director Caster Binion — who appears to be on his way out, as the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has reported that the agency is seeking to contract with an executive search firm — has blamed everything from high staff turnover at HACP to private landlords refusing to participate in the HCV program, as well as the lack of overall affordable housing in the city, for the program’s continuing issues.

While these certainly remain complex pressure points, they do not explain his office’s years-long failure to communicate with willing landlord partners. Landlords have a vested interest in completing the inspections and approvals as quickly as possible, without any of the limitations of the overburdened HACP office and its staff-in-training.

Mr. Binion’s suggestion to improve service were unsatisfactory. He offered to personally address communication breakdowns with landlords, which is unreasonable given the sheer number of landlords the agency works with, and suggested landlords arrange meetings between all three involved parties, which undermines the entire point of having an automated system. Simply letting landlords know whose turn it is to submit information — theirs, the city’s or the tenant’s — would make coordination much easier.

Unfortunately, the only thing that’s currently being communicated is that the process is still flawed, and Mr. Binion’s excuses remain the same.