The last week has been one of the most tumultuous in modern American political history, from the attempt on former president Donald Trump’s life to the vice-presidential nomination of Ohio Sen. JD Vance to President Joe Biden’s COVID diagnosis and (as of this writing) ongoing speculation about his electoral viability.

Americans remain sharply divided but there seemed, for a moment, to be hope for a new turn, when our deep political differences wouldn’t inevitably turn into deep personal divisions.

The week culminated in an abortive attempt by Mr. Trump to strike a unifying tone in his acceptance speech at the Republican National Convention in Milwaukee. In 35 minutes of off-the-cuff additions to a more magnanimous written speech, he meandered and misled, blamed and criticized, undercutting his own efforts to open a new chapter in his, and the country’s, political life.

Indeed, less than a week after gunshots rang out in a Butler County field, partisans of all kinds are already nearly back to normal, raising the stakes of the coming election beyond what is reasonable or realistic.

Advertise with us

But we have a contrast, or a counter-example, from one of our own neighbors: Corey Comperatore, and the sacrifice he made.

A complicated hero

By now the story is well-known. Mr. Comperatore was a husband, a father of two daughters and the former fire chief in Buffalo Township, Butler County. Family and friends describe an archetypical son of rural Western Pennsylvania: playing hooky to go hunting and fishing; attending church services every Sunday; actively helping others in his community; doting on his daughters.

And typical, too, in being an enthusiastic supporter of Mr. Trump, whom he believed had been, and would again be, the president America needed.

On the X platform, some users — always looking for the bad rather than the good — identified posts Mr. Comperatore made that were insensitive or mean-spirited, though sadly in keeping with the rhetoric of this divisive political moment. Some users even insinuated or said outright that the death of the person who made the posts benefited America. Tens of thousands of others approved.

These are vile sentiments and all the more hateful knowing that Mr. Comperatore was not a passive bystander when the bullet struck him: He had draped himself over his family to protect them from the gunfire.

Advertise with us

More than politics

In this is an important point: Mr. Comperatore did not always behave well on the internet, and he certainly believed things that many people not only find distasteful but morally tarnishing. And yet he possessed leonine physical courage, honed in years of firefighting and tested to the fullest measure at his final moment.

We can say — as Gov. Josh Shapiro said in his deeply humane remarks after the shooting — without throat-clearing or hesitation or qualification that Mr. Comperatore was a hero. “The best of us,” Mr. Shapiro said. He meant it, and he was right.

We are more than what we believe about politics. Every single candidate and cause is supported by people who believe in them because they want the best for America and other Americans. Each is supported by people who are selfless and kind, generous and wise, prudent and steadfast. Many of them also say and write things they should not.

It would be wrong to judge even the people who said horrible things about Mr. Comperatore based on one anonymous remark made in an environment that encourages and rewards that kind of cruelty.

Spirit of sacrifice

In the scripted portion of Mr. Trump’s convention speech, the former president paraphrased Scripture, John 15:13 to be precise: “Greater love has no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends.”

Advertise with us

What can each American sacrifice out of love for our fellow citizens? Few of us will be asked to “give the last full measure of devotion,” as Lincoln so perfectly expressed it in Gettysburg. We don’t expect every American to do for each other what Mr. Comperatore did for his family. But we can imitate him in our speech.

What about laying down our desire to have the last word? Laying down the feeling of superiority that comes with having contempt for others? Laying down our suspicion of others as the first step toward a renewal of trust?

The problem, of course, is that rebuilding relationships and even friendships across the country’s political divide requires both sides to sacrifice together: Like a wartime ceasefire, it’s only possible if you trust the other side to abide by the terms of the deal. So many people in recent days have said, in so many words, “Why should we stop speaking cruelly of them when they delight in speaking cruelly of us?”

And so on it goes. Until, once again, blood is shed.

But in Corey Comperatore’s example of risking his life, knowing he might lose it, as he did, there is hope: Sacrifice is universal; sacrifice is essential; sacrifice is human; sacrifice always earns respect.

If we all share nothing else, we certainly share admiration for the man who lays down his life for the ones he loves. Admiration should lead to imitation. The spirit of sacrifice, in big things and small, will always have the power to bring people together.