An unusual contract award approved at the May meeting of the board of the Housing Authority of the City of Pittsburgh (HACP) raises questions about the authority’s procurement process. Especially given the procurement irregularities that have plagued the Gainey administration, this matter deserves an independent investigation.
At issue are the private firms HACP uses to handle security at its campuses and high-rises. Despite a long-standing relationship with the firm OSA Global, in May the agency suddenly changed course and gave nearly half the security contract to a different firm that ranked second in every category in the competitive bidding evaluation, and did not even show up to the pre-bid meeting.
One thing the new firm, 3G Security Solutions, does have going for it? Its employees are members of the politically powerful SEIU 32BJ union of building service workers.
OSA Global has provided security at HACP sites since at least 2014, when it split the contract with another firm, Am-Gard, from which 3G Security Solutions had previously spun off. In 2018, security services were split between armed and unarmed services: OSA remained the unarmed contractor while the City of Pittsburgh police provided the remainder of services. Am-Gard was dropped.
Three years later, Pittsburgh police were no longer able to spare the manpower for HACP, so OSA received contracts for both armed and unarmed security services for two years, with a one-year extension option. Last year, HACP picked up that extension without controversy.
Given OSA’s success, when it came time to post a request for proposals (RFP) to procure a new contract, HACP asked for a single proposal for a single contract combining armed and unarmed security services. OSA and two out-of-town firms participated in a pre-bid meeting with the agency, putting the Pittsburgh-based company in the catbird seat.
But suddenly, the relationship between HACP and OSA soured. In January, the agency extended OSA’s contract for a few months in order to buy time to consider alternatives — despite the fact the RFP had been posted way back in July, and OSA had been ranked the top competitor in every category.
Then, according to a letter sent by OSA to HACP executive director Caster Binion obtained by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board, the firm began to suffer poor treatment from HACP Public Safety Director Joy Pekar. The letter alleges that Ms. Pekar began arbitrarily firing officers while refusing to participate in training sessions for new officers, hampering the firm’s ability to fulfill its responsibilities.
The process culminated in May, when without warning the single RFP was split into two contracts: OSA received the unarmed bid while, out of nowhere, 3G received the armed bid. The OSA contract includes the armed security responsibilities from the RFP crudely crossed out by hand, while the resolution approving the 3G contract says explicitly that it was the “second most responsive, responsible and qualified firm.” It is extremely uncommon for a firm ranked second in every category to be selected for what appears to have been modest savings.
3G Security Solutions is owned by Jennifer Dintini, whose grandparents founded Am-Gard. The firm’s website explains, remarkably candidly, that Ms. Dintini broke 3G out of Am-Gard in 2010 in part to “capitalize on the WBE [woman-owned business] certification.” Social media activity shows that she and Ms. Pekar were acquainted before HACP awarded 3G the contract.
But perhaps most importantly, 3G is an SEIU 32BJ shop. The local union’s president, Sam Williamson, sits on the board of the Urban Redevelopment Authority, which regularly works with HACP. The HACP contract will ensure more security guards are hired by 3G, and become dues-paying members of 32BJ.
Altogether, this story sketches a picture of a highly unusual procurement process that resulted in benefits flowing to politically connected people and organizations. In a moment when trust in local government is at a low ebb, we urge an independent investigation to reassure the public that, amid all this smoke, there isn’t a fire.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.