Nearly 20 Pittsburgh police officers who originally failed their psychological assessments have nonetheless landed among the ranks of Pittsburgh police academy recruits after retaking those evaluations. Police Chief Larry Scirotto insists that standards have not been lowered — but with the same evaluators the city has used for years administering a decades-old standardized test, what else could have led to such backtracking?

There are two plausible explanations for why the percent of police candidates weeded out by the psychological screenings has skyrocketed in recent classes, from about one to three out of five. First, something might have changed in the assessments themselves, or in the people performing those assessments. Second, something might have changed in the candidates being screened.

But as the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has previously reported, six of the seven psychologists with whom the city contracted to perform evaluations in 2022 and 2023 have performed these duties for the city for several years. One has been on the roster as far back as 2000.

Further, it’s impossible for a single evaluator to nix a recruit’s career. It takes two assessors to disqualify a candidate. If they disagree, a third psychologist breaks the tie.

Advertise with us

Since there’s no reason to believe the evaluations have become arbitrarily strict or unfair, that leaves the other explanation: The city’s lack of active recruitment to the police force, amid a national decline in interest in joining law enforcement, has resulted in fewer quality recruits signing up. In fact, some recruits were rejected in multiple recruitment cycles by different evaluators, but are now in the academy.

Policing is an emotionally and physically demanding job, and police officers suffer from higher rates of post-traumatic stress disorder and commit suicide more often than the general population. Allowing candidates who have been rejected as psychologically unfit by multiple professionals is unfair to the people of Pittsburgh — but also to the recruits themselves, who are being sent into a profession and a way of life for which they are not prepared.

Meanwhile, in his remarks on the matter Mr. Scirotto has subtly shifted the goalposts. Rather than describing complete psychological readiness for the job, he has focused on disqualifying people with “cognitive disorders.” He is also shifting evaluations from psychologists with behavioral health specialties to those who focus on cognitive disorders.

This is insufficient. The mental factors of policing go beyond mere cognitive functioning to emotional regulation and behavioral discipline.

Lowering these standards can have serious long-term consequences for the bureau, and for the city: Two years ago, California’s Alameda County Sheriff’s department stripped nearly 50 deputies of their responsibilities after an internal audit found they had been hired in spite of failed psychological evaluations. The audit was prompted because a 24-year-old Alameda deputy had allegedly murdered a couple “execution style.”

The way to draw more quality candidates to policing isn’t to lower standards, but to raise them. Whatever short-term benefit Pittsburgh police receive from having a few new recruits will be more than surpassed by the long-term costs.