The City of Pittsburgh’s hiring of medical pathologist Dr. Bennet Omalu to provide an expert opinion in the death of Jim Rogers raises serious questions about the propriety of the city’s record-smashing $8 million settlement with Mr. Rogers’ estate, and the competence with which the city has investigated this tragic incident.

It is the responsibility of city government, beginning with Mayor Ed Gainey, to ensure taxpayer money is only spent needfully. In the case of a wrongful death lawsuit like Mr. Rogers’, that means authoritatively determining that a city employee actually caused the person’s death. It is now clear the city never independently investigated this most basic question: Did a Pittsburgh police officer kill Jim Rogers?

The Post-Gazette Editorial Board can also reveal that this is not Dr. Omalu’s first involvement in the Rogers case: He had previously been hired by Todd Hollis, attorney for the Rogers estate, in the suit against the city. Altogether, the Gainey administration’s actions give the impression it had prejudged the case against its officers; paid out a lucrative settlement on the basis of that prejudgment; and is now desperately trying to justify that prejudgment.

Questionable cause of death

Advertise with us

On Oct. 13, 2021, Pittsburgh police tased 54-year-old Jim Rogers, an unhoused Black man, several times before roughly taking him to the ground. He had been reported, dubiously, for bike theft. While being transported to the Allegheny County Jail, Mr. Rogers experienced medical distress and was diverted to UPMC Mercy, where he died the next day.

Multiple police actions, including the aggressive use of the taser and the denial of an immediate medical evaluation, violated procedures. The city disciplined eight officers, four of whom were fired.

What actually caused Mr. Rogers’ death, however, has remained obscure. The Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office ruled the death “accidental” due to a disruption of oxygen flow to the brain. But an “accidental” death can still have been caused by someone else’s actions or negligence. For instance, the shocks from a taser might disrupt the heart, leading to a lack of oxygen in the brain, leading to death.

The uncertainty of legal responsibility for Mr. Rogers’ death, however, is underscored by the fact that a grand jury empaneled by District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. failed to return an indictment, and that two of the four fired officers have been reinstated with back pay. The other two officers’ cases are still pending.

An exorbitant payout

Advertise with us

And yet in May of this year, the city reached an unprecedented $8 million settlement with the Rogers estate, seemingly admitting police officers had caused the death. City Council approved the deal in October.

While it may seem crass to question a wrongful death payout, $8 million is radically inconsistent with recent precedent and standard calculations, such as lost wages and a family’s loss of support. Further, it establishes an arbitrary precedent for future cases that may cost taxpayers many more millions in years to come.

Settlement documents show that Lanesha Kennedy, said to be Mr. Rogers’ estranged daughter, received nearly $4 million, while Mr. Rogers’ personal estate received $1.3 million. Mr. Hollis, a very small donor to Mr. Gainey’s mayoral campaign, received a contingency fee plus expenses, amounting to $2.7 million.

Negotiation or collusion?

One of those expenses, which is recorded in public records of the settlement, was a $5,000 check to Dr. Bennet Omalu for his expert analysis as a medical pathologist. Then in late October, the Mayor’s Office proposed and City Council approved a $10,000 payment to the same pathologist, for the same case.

Advertise with us

Dr. Omalu, a former employee of the Allegheny County Coroner’s Office, is known for having discovered chronic traumatic encephalopathy, or CTE, the brain disease common in combat athletes. While his expertise is not in question, the intersection between parties who should have been adversaries is troubling.

The legislation authorizing the expense was vaguely labeled “labor arbitration,” and City Council passed it unanimously and without discussion. Its true purpose — bolstering the city’s case to keep one of the offending officers off the job — only came to light this week, when the Controller’s office cut the check and Dr. Omalu’s invoice became a public record.

But hiring an expert pathologist — especially the same pathologist as Mr. Rogers’ attorney — only now that the case has turned to defending an officer’s termination suggests the city never seriously investigated or contested the wrongful death claim.

Altogether, the $8 million settlement looks more like the result of collusion than of an appropriately adversarial negotiation — the kind of negotiation that seeks justice for both the victim and taxpayers.

Under scrutiny

Advertise with us

There is no question Pittsburgh police officers behaved abominably on that fall day in Bloomfield. Several officers deserved strict discipline for flagrant and cruel violations of procedure.

But whether they were legally responsible for Jim Rogers’ death is a completely separate question — one the city had a fiduciary duty to contest. Instead, the city apparently assumed their officers’ guilt and then meted out discipline and a lucrative settlement based on that assumption.

Thus far, that discipline has not held up under scrutiny. This, in turn, calls into question the propriety of, and motivations for, the settlement.

Which is why the Gainey administration is finally getting serious and hiring a real medical expert: If they don’t win a single arbitration dispute with their own officers, the case for the $8 million payout is destroyed, and the whole episode looks like a wasteful debacle — at the very best.