Saturday, Oct. 14, marked two years since the death of Jim Rogers, an unhoused Black man, after an altercation with Pittsburgh police officers in Bloomfield. And yet the case remains open and raw — for Mr. Rogers’ family, for the wider community and for the Pittsburgh police themselves — in part because after 24 months, Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala has yet to announce a decision about whether to charge any or all of the officers involved.
Meanwhile, the secrecy surrounding the case also makes it difficult to scrutinize the city’s $8 million settlement with Mr. Rogers’ estate, the largest in Pittsburgh history. City Council held an executive session last Thursday to discuss its approval of this agreement, and will consider it further at its Wednesday Standing Committee meeting.
Mr. Zappala, for his part, has consistently refused to discuss the case on the grounds that it has been presented to a grand jury. But the grand jury was empaneled last February and had completed its work by last October at the latest. If the panel did not return an indictment, and Mr. Zappala has decided to follow that recommendation, he should inform the public.
A year ago, the Editorial Board wrote, “This delay serves no one — not the grieving members of Rogers family, not the officers who anxiously await their fate, and not the people of Pittsburgh who demand and deserve a just closure.” This applies with even greater force now.
On Oct. 13, 2021, 54-year-old Jim Rogers took a spin on a bike left on a Harriet Street sidewalk. A witness reported the action as a theft, and police converged on the block.
Mr. Rogers, who suffered from serious mental illness, struggled to cooperate with officers’ instructions. According to the family’s lawsuit, officers tased Mr. Rogers several times before placing him in a police cruiser.
Mr. Rogers went into medical distress on the way to Allegheny County Jail and was rerouted to UPMC Mercy, where he died the next day. The precise details of his final hours are as yet unknown, but the Allegheny County Medical Examiner determined the cause of death to have been a disruption of oxygen flow to the brain.
Still, details that would shed further light on this chaotic and tragic incident remain hidden from the public. Some of this information — such as the disposition of eight officers’ appeals of their discipline, as well as the internal Critical Incident Review Board report — is sealed due to the terms of the city’s contract with the police. Other items, such as police body cam footage, can be released by the police bureau in collaboration with the DA’s office. We renew our call for this to happen.
Delaying the administration of justice, even if that means a decision not to charge, only prolongs the pain for every person involved in this tragedy. Mr. Zappala must announce a decision so that this sad chapter in Pittsburgh’s story may eventually come to a close.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.