The traveling exhibition “Treasured Ornament,” which almost opened at the Frick museum today, would have offered us a chance to see important Islamic art from the year 1000 through the 1800s. The museum has postponed the opening until August of next year and its first reason was not a good one, while its second one is.
The problem was the coincidence of the conflict in Israel and Gaza and the opening of the exhibit. The Frick’s director, Elizabeth Barker, told WESA that the museum was concerned that the exhibit might be hurtful to the Jewish community and others. The decision “was never intended to be a political statement.”
In a statement on the museum’s homepage, since removed, the museum first said that the conflict in the Middle East could turn “an intended educational opportunity into a divisive political touchstone, a source of unintended insensitivity or offense, and a distraction from our important service to the entire community.”
It has since revised the explanation on the homepage, which no longer mentions the conflict in Israel and Gaza. “As we looked more deeply at the show, we became concerned by the light historical context and our lack of engagement with the regional Muslim community. ... To proceed without the participation of the Muslim community risked trivializing and objectifying Islamic culture as merely decorative.”
That makes sense. The museum would not have sponsored a major exhibition of Jewish art or Catholic art without consulting their institutional leaders. By their own admission, they did not consult the Muslim community, and felt they needed to rectify that failure. The result will almost certainly be a better exhibit and a richer experience for people who see it.
But still, there’s the museum’s first reason. It was not a good reason. A cultural institution should be sensitive to international matters, but postponing an exhibit of historic Islamic art conflates pre-19th century Islamic culture with contemporary terrorist organizations like Hamas. What relation between the two did the museum think justified stopping the much-anticipated exhibit? We can think of none.
Pittsburgh’s Muslim community felt the implied connection between their tradition’s art and some extremists in another country. Christine Mohamed, the executive director of the Pittsburgh chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), said “It’s disheartening to witness such insensitivity when blanket statements are made about an entire religion, particularly when they have the potential to incite harm in the Pittsburgh Muslim community.”
Pittsburghers can tell the difference between art and terrorism. As a spokesman for the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh told WESA, “I believe that few people in the Jewish community would have been concerned about an exhibit on Islamic art, because we understand that has nothing to do with Hamas, which is a terrorist organization.”
If a show is worth doing, it’s worth doing whatever happens elsewhere. Of all cultural institutions, museums should stand for our common humanity and not let current events divide us.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.