A thorough performance audit conducted by the office of Allegheny County Controller Corey O’Connor put facts and figures to what close observers of the county jail, not to mention those who work and live there, have known for some time: The facility is woefully understaffed. Fixing the problem, however, will prove much more difficult than diagnosing it.

The county is facing systemic headwinds in the corrections labor model that have stymied jails and prisons nationwide. State prison systems from Nevada to Texas to Florida are facing vacancy rates of 25% to 33%, or higher. In West Virginia, some jails are operating with up to 70% of budgeted positions unfilled, and Gov. Jim Justice has mobilized 300 National Guardsmen to step into the breach.

The staffing issues at the Allegheny County Jail aren’t yet that severe, but they are getting worse — quickly. In December 2020, 17 of 448 budgeted corrections officers positions were unfilled, a vacancy rate of under 5%. A year later, it was nearly 10%. And at the end of 2022, despite an increase in the budget to 486, the number of officers on staff declined, leaving 112 vacancies, or 23%.

The main result of the shortage is that corrections workers are forced to take a lot of overtime. The audit reports that nearly a third of COs performed 12 to 24 weeks of overtime, or 480 to 960 hours, in 2021. Another third did 4 to 12 weeks. More than a quarter of all wages paid to corrections officers is overtime pay. Much of this is forced overtime to fill shifts — but the audit revealed that on most days, even with forced overtime, essential posts go unfilled.

Advertise with us

The results aren’t good for corrections officers or the people they are meant to supervise. The unpredictable lifestyle, especially for first-year recruits making a base pay of under $50,000, chases many away: Of the 66 officers who resigned during the audit’s 21-month study period, about 60% did so in their first year on the job. And the stress and burnout can be reflected in the treatment of incarcerated people and the security of the facility.

The corrections labor system will always include significant overtime: Jails are 24/7 operations with inconsistent staffing requirements due to shifting inmate populations. Further, the promise of overtime pay is a perk that makes modest base pay tolerable. But the overreliance on overtime is a vicious cycle that makes it harder to recruit the new officers needed to alleviate it, and to improve the overall functioning of the jail.

The solution is simple: Substantially increase base pay. Corrections is a dangerous and low-status career, but money talks. Other states have seen significant increases in applications after pay bumps, or when signing bonuses are offered. Bringing in more recruits at higher base pay also saves money in overtime pay.

This won’t solve all the problems at ACJ: The audit also revealed dissatisfaction with management as a significant morale sink. Next week’s retirement of Warden Orlando Harper bodes well on that front. The new warden should bring in a new team and a strong focus not just on recruitment but on retention strategies, in order to enhance morale and bring stability to the jail.

None of this, however, will be cheap. If Allegheny County really wants a safe and efficient jail, it’s going to have to pay for it.