In March 2023, the City of Pittsburgh asked Matrix Consulting Group to submit a plan to perform a study of the city’s Fire and EMS bureaus, according to a proposal obtained by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board. However, the city never publicized the legally required request for proposals for such a study, raising further questions about the propriety of the city’s relationship with Matrix.

City Council and the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office are currently scrutinizing the process by which Matrix was given a no-bid contract to perform the staffing and utilization study of the Pittsburgh police, which recommended drastic and unrealistic cuts of one-third of the bureau’s patrol force.

A Waiver of Competitive Process that allowed the city to bypass legally required bidding included one false statement, and another that revealed a potentially illicit pre-existing relationship between Matrix and the city. Gainey administration officials’ attempts to defend the waiver have been unconvincing at best, and self-incriminating at worst.

Besides being questionable in itself, the new proposal sheds light on the timeline of Matrix’s controversial study of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, enhancing concerns that the final document represented collusion between the city, specifically the Mayor’s Office and the Department of Public Safety, and the consultant.

Advertise with us

An unusual relationship

The earliest we can be certain of a relationship between Matrix Consulting Group and the City of Pittsburgh — besides a 2017 study of the Department of Public Works — is March 2022, a few months into Mayor Ed Gainey’s tenure. That’s when Matrix says it began its study of the Pittsburgh police. But the Department of Public Safety only brought the contract to City Council, along with the suspicious Waiver of Competitive Process, in June, and the Mayor only signed the contract in July.

The 24-week study should have been completed around the beginning of 2023, but apparently went well beyond that. While some preliminary work circulated in city offices as soon as January, and new police chief Larry Scirotto referred to data from the study in public remarks in May, Mr. Gainey’s office did not announce the final report until July 19.

But the Fire and EMS proposal is dated March 31, 2023, and refers to the “just completed” police study. What happened between March and July? There’s a clue in the proposal itself: Matrix promises that it will submit a draft to the city and the relevant bureaus for “revisions” before releasing the final report. As a matter of transparency, the Gainey administration should release the March report so the public can see for itself what those “revisions” were.

In the meantime, however, the city and Matrix seem to have been planning an encore, again without the required public process. The Fire and EMS proposal clearly states that “Pittsburgh has requested a study of its Bureaus of Fire and EMS,” indicating that this was not an unsolicited proposal. The quoted price tag of $184,000 also far exceeds the maximum of $30,000 to skip the competitive process. And yet there is no public record of a request for proposals for a Fire and EMS study. Did the administration plan to bring another Matrix contract to City Council as essentially a fait accompli?

Advertise with us

A weak defense

After district attorney Stephen Zappala announced his inquiry into the police study last Friday, Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt and Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak held a press conference in which they defended their offices’ actions in procuring the Matrix study. Their arguments suggest a misunderstanding of their own duties under the law.

First, Mr. Pawlak admitted that he and Mr. Schmidt knew that Matrix is not the only firm to perform such public safety studies, as Mr. Schmidt had claimed on the waiver that Mr. Pawlak’s office approved. He argued that they preferred Matrix over the International Association of Chiefs of Police because Matrix is not affiliated with law enforcement. But having a preference is not good reason to falsely claim that one firm is the “sole supplier” of the requested services — it’s a reason to make an informed choice after the bidding.

Second, Mr. Pawlak claimed that the Matrix proposal fell under the “consultants ... associated with anticipated, pending, or potential litigation” exception to the competitive bidding process. The “litigation” in question was the expected collective bargaining and arbitration process with the police union. But negotiations are not litigation, and arbitration is defined in law in contrast with litigation.

Further, if any consultants’ work that could be useful in union negotiations is exempt from bidding, then all consultants’ work would be exempt: Any expert analysis of city operations can conceivably be used in collective bargaining. What Mr. Pawlak is arguing for isn’t just a one-time exception, but the end of competitive bidding for professional services.

Advertise with us

In fact, Pittsburgh is currently in negotiations with its Fire and EMS unions, so it’s likely the administration was eyeing up that loophole once again.

Further questions

Mr. Pawlak’s frank assertion that the study was meant to support the Gainey administration in union negotiations raises further questions: Did the administration use preliminary Matrix analyses without sharing them with the union, which could be bad-faith bargaining? And if the point of the study was to be negotiating leverage, then why should the public take its recommendations seriously?

From beginning to end, this episode has exposed an administration acting brazenly on, or beyond, the edge of legality, while trying to block out all scrutiny. But suddenly, it seems sunlight is beginning to filter in.