The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has confirmed that the consultants hired by the City of Pittsburgh to study its police bureau only visited Pittsburgh once during what became a yearlong, $180,000 project. Further, a comparison of the organization’s proposed timeline and the several months it took the city to release the final study raises questions about what caused those substantial delays.
A decade ago in a different city, another study by the same firm was beset by allegations that delays were caused by a city official’s attempts to craft the final result to his liking.
These revelations call into question the credibility of a staffing and utilization study that is already the subject of a City Council inquiry over irregularities in the procurement process, as revealed by the Editorial Board. A Waiver of Competitive Process that allowed California-based Matrix Consulting Group to receive a no-bid contract included one false statement, and another that revealed a potentially illicit pre-existing relationship with the city.
Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala has now requested the city’s records in this matter.
A failing grade
The most striking recommendation in the Matrix study is that the Pittsburgh Police should reassign nearly 200 patrol officers, roughly one-third of the zone-based patrol force, to other specialized divisions. This was based on a crude analysis purporting to show that patrol officers have an exceptional amount of free time — more than 70% for “proactive” crime reduction, as opposed to responding to calls for assistance, compared to a 40% benchmark.
Read More
The report also claims the bureau responds to calls so unusually quickly that the bureau should cut back on its patrols to lengthen its response times.
Not one of several people with knowledge of PBP operations contacted by the Post-Gazette Editorial Board — both inside and outside the bureau — thought these results reflected reality. Why is the bureau forcing its officers to take hundreds of hours of overtime per week if patrols are seriously overstaffed?
The analysis itself is amateurish, involving averages, estimates and extrapolations to generate a total number of officer-hours spent on calls, which was divided by the total number of officer-hours available, which was also only estimated. The report suggests no familiarity whatsoever with the on-the-ground reality of policing in Pittsburgh or anywhere; it treats law enforcement as an abstract matter of data analysis.
This impression was confirmed when a Matrix vice president told a member of the Editorial Board that the team visited Pittsburgh only once in performing the study.
The consultants’ analysis is also flatly contradicted by the firm’s own survey of PBP officers: While Matrix claims patrol officers have an overabundance of proactive time, 83% of those officers responded that they don’t have enough. Matrix made no attempt to address or to resolve this glaring discrepancy.
A question of timing
Matrix’s proposal to the city was dated May 24, 2022 — two months after the firm had started work, according to both the final report and the Matrix executive. Only a week later, the Office of Management and Budget approved the deceptive Waiver of Competitive Process signed by Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt.
The proposal lays out a 24-week timeline for the completion of the study. If work actually began with the contract’s signing in early July, that would mean a delivery date in late December. On October 20, Matrix president Richard Brady indicated in an email to police union president Bob Swartzwelder that preliminary findings were only weeks away.
While sources confirm to the Post-Gazette that Matrix had delivered some work in January, beyond this point the study’s status becomes muddled. City Councilman Anthony Coghill asked for the report at a January 31 council meeting, and Gainey administration officials responded that it was not yet complete. Then there was a six-month delay until the July 19 rollout.
Meanwhile, the Matrix executive said that a draft was completed only in March, and the final report in July, just before the announcement.
These dates raise the question of why the study took twice as long as planned to complete. What happened between January or March and July?
One clue suggests that the “final” version of the report was being adjusted until the last minute: While there are no obvious discrepancies, the version given to Mr. Swartzwelder is dated July 10, while the version given to Mr. Coghill and shared with City Council is dated July 18.
Deja vu?
In 2011 and 2012, Matrix conducted a study of the city government of Hanford, Calif. According to the Hanford Sentinel newspaper, the city’s police chief reported that a Matrix employee said the report had been delayed due to repeated requests for edits from the city’s manager. The manager also falsely claimed not to have seen any works-in-progress. He was later fired by the city.
The Matrix study ended up being a flashpoint in Hanford politics, but ultimately faded away with little or no action taken on it.
The same thing should happen here. The project appears to have begun before it had been approved by City Council; the contract was granted on the basis of a deceptive competitive bid waiver; the study took twice as long as planned, including a suspiciously long delay between preliminary and final products; and the content of the report lacks credibility while showing minimal familiarity with Pittsburgh or its police.
At best, it’s a $180,000 waste of taxpayer money. And at worst, it’s a fraud perpetrated on the people of the city, and their elected representatives.
Update: This editorial has been updated to reflect the announcement of an inquiry by the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.