The Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office has requested records relating to Pittsburgh’s recent police staffing study after concerns about the procurement process were raised. 

District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. submitted a right-to-know request on Thursday for all records involving the city and the Matrix Consulting Group, who conducted the study, according to a Friday news release. The study found that the city budgets for the correct number of cops, but that patrol officers should be redeployed into other roles. 

Mr. Zappala’s request for information comes exactly one week after Pittsburgh City Council indicated that they would also be looking further into the procurement of the contract authorizing Matrix to conduct the study.

In the request, records are defined broadly as any “letters, memorandum, emails, text messages, faxes, sound recordings and any other types of written, electronic or recorded communication.” 

Advertise with us

The request asks for all contracts between the two entities dating back to Jan. 1, 2019, through the present.

During the bidding process for the study last year, a so-called Waiver of Competitive Process, which eliminates a requirement for other contractors to bid competitively on a project, had been filed for the Matrix study. In the waiver, the city claimed that Matrix already had a relationship with the city as a consultant on “police-related litigation.”

Mr. Zappala has also requested to see all records relating to Matrix being a consultant on police-litigation matters.

The waiver also claimed that this company was the “only known company” to provide this type of services. In 2005, a similar study was done for Pittsburgh by the International Association of Chiefs of Police. Its findings differed from that of the Matrix study. 

“A number of concerns have been brought to my attention from public and private officials pertaining to the city’s public safety,” Mr. Zappala said in a statement. “Our office intends to thoroughly look into this to the best of our abilities.”

Advertise with us

Early Friday evening, the city held a news conference to address concerns that have been raised about the study.

The Office of Management and Budget Director Jake Pawlak said that he has “no idea what the concerns are” that Mr. Zappala mentioned, he only knew what information the District Attorney had requested.

“We’ve received similar inquiries from City Council, not through an RTK, but through legislation and I’m happy to provide it because we have nothing to hide,” Mr. Pawlak said. “That study was procured in a legal, ethical and transparent fashion. The questions now arising around that process I believe are frivolous and are either misguided or politically motivated.”

As the city was preparing to start the contract with Matrix, they knew that in the near future there would be contract negotiations with the police union and the staffing report “might provide guidance” for negotiations, Mr. Pawlak said.

The report was ultimately not released before the contract with the police union was settled.

Advertise with us

“We did not need the report to inform that negotiation, but at the outset, we thought that that might be necessary and engaged in those services on that basis,” Mr. Pawlak said.

He said that it was “not unusual” to not have a bidding process for something like this.

“If we’re pursuing something that is now or may soon be in court — and union arbitration agreement meets that definition — it's not at all unusual for us to apply this exemption in cases like that,” Mr. Pawlak said.

The director also acknowledged that the city had previously received a similar study from the IACP, but because they believed the report may have to guide future negotiations, they wanted it to be from an “independent voice.”

Because everyone on the executive board and in leadership positions with the IACP lead police agencies, most of which negotiate union contracts, the city wanted a consultant that would not be influenced by “their own potential current or future union negotiations,” Mr. Pawlak said.

Advertise with us

In what appears to be an effort to vet the personnel who conducted the study, the DA has also requested the resumes or experience summaries for any Matrix representative who worked with the city between Jan. 1, 2019, and the present.

He has also asked to see the records that were reviewed by the Equal Opportunity Review Commission that determined Matrix is “comprised of highly experienced management consultants, specializing in law enforcement services.” 

The DA’s right-to-know request also asks to see records relating to any payments made by the city to Matrix Consulting dating back to Jan. 1, 2019. 

In addition to the request, the DA’s office has also directed the city to preserve all records referenced in the request and any other records that “relate to or concern the Matrix Consulting Group.” 

It could be up to 30 days before the records are received by the District Attorney’s office. The information had to be petitioned through a right-to-know request because the District Attorney’s office can only subpoena information if there is a case before the court. 

Advertise with us

Earlier this week, City Council requested a legal opinion regarding the contract.

“This is simply looking at the procurement process, making sure that everything was done properly,” Councilman Anthony Coghill said at the time. “It’s nothing more than that. We’re not throwing out any allegations that the mayor’s office deceived us, simply doing a review of the process because there’s some questions around it.”

The legal review is due back to council on Sept. 6.

Mr. Pawlak said that he looks forward “addressing this matter” with Council and to “addressing any questions” Mr. Zappala has. 

Council has also proposed legislation that would require the city controller to sign-off on any competitive bid waivers. That legislation will not be considered until council returns from their summer recess at the end of August. 

Advertise with us

Mr. Zappala, who has been the DA since 1998, is running for re-election this fall. After losing the Democratic primary in May, Mr. Zappala will be running as a Republican in November against former Chief Public Defender Matt Dugan.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com