The Pennsylvania Department of Corrections should immediately reinstate a humane, efficient and cost-effective program, run by the Philadelphia-based Pennsylvania Prison Society, that provided transportation for family visits to state prisoners.
DOC data, covering inmates released between 2012 and 2016, showed receiving at least four visits per month cut recidivism rates by a third. A meta-analysis of 16 studies, published in the Journal of Criminal Justice in 2016, showed re-offense risk dropping by more than half for certain inmate populations due to visitation.
Many of Pennsylvania’s 36,000 state prisoners are in rural prisons, hundreds of miles from their homes, making visitation unaffordable for poor families. Buses arranged by the Prison Society were their only option. Transportation was offered to families at affordable rates — $15 to $40 — even though some round-trips took nearly 24 hours.
More than 80,000 children in Pennsylvania have an incarcerated parent.
Instead of promoting the Prison Society service as an effective re-entry program, the Pennsylvania Department of Corrections ended it in September of 2020. The contract was not renewed, even though COVID restrictions were lifted in the spring of 2022.
During a hearing before the House Appropriations Committee last week, Corrections Secretary Laurel Harry said the transportation program used money from the Inmate General Welfare Fund. That money — collected from the purchase of commissary goods, phone calls and other personal expenditures — should go to activities and programs directly related to inmates. The department wasn’t sure whether using the money for visitation was appropriate, she said.
Nonsense. Few activities could more directly support prisoners — and their families — than a visitation program. With an annual budget of $2.7 billion, the department could have funded the program itself as a re-entry initiative.
Further, Ms. Harry said, the visitation service, under state procurement rules, might need competitive bidding. But few, if any, organizations in the state or country offer the same expertise and service as the more than 200-year-old Pennsylvania Prison Society, with 300 volunteers statewide. If the transportation service had to be put out for bids, why wasn’t it done before?
In 2019, the last full year of operation, the visitation service reported 2,881 riders. That year’s contract renewal was for a price not to exceed $34,662 per month to cover the cost of about 10 buses per month, scheduled with a Philadelphia-area transit contractor. Some trips, such as those from Philadelphia to a state prison near Erie, took nearly 24 hours round-trip.
It cost Pennsylvania taxpayers more than $40,000 a year to incarcerate each prisoner. Re-establishing and maintaining family ties is an important motivator for personal change, and a chief reason for successful re-entries into society. Cutting a successful visitation program is penny-wise and pound-foolish.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.