Pope Benedict XVI, whose funeral was celebrated in Rome this morning, will be remembered as the pope who resigned. That momentous decision paved the way for the Argentinian cardinal Jorge Bergoglio to ascend to the Chair of St. Peter as Pope Francis — a pontiff whose engagement with modernity has been much different from his predecessor’s.
But Joseph Ratzinger, as he was born on April 16, 1927, in the German state of Bavaria, shouldn’t just be remembered as the pope before Francis. For much of the second half of the twentieth century, he had been one of the most important people in the Catholic Church, and in world affairs generally. His legacy will be among the most complicated of the great figures of the last century.
He had, for example, been seen as unusually aggressive in cracking down on clerical abuse, insisting as a cardinal that his department strictly handle offending priests and as pope that local churches follow the norms of civil law when dealing with sexual abuse. However, recent lawsuits and investigations have suggested that in his handling of cases as Archbishop of Munich from 1977 to 1982, he acted similarly to other bishops by hiding, rather than confronting, sexual abuse.
While he later came to be seen as a theological conservative, his early reputation in the church was as a liberal reformer. He was one of the last remaining theological consultants, or periti, to have served at the Second Vatican Council (1962-1965), where he accompanied the celebrated anti-Nazi Cardinal Josef Frings of Cologne.
In the years after the council, Ratzinger’s emphasis shifted toward attempting to synthesize reformist theology with the church’s ancient teachings. This often meant reining in perceived excesses of reform, which he did several times in his nearly 25 years as head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith — tasked with interpreting and preserving Church teaching — by condemning the ideas of some of the church’s most progressive theologians.
It also meant his working out, intellectually and practically, the Catholic Church’s relation with other religions and points of view. In this he combined a firm commitment to Catholic teaching with liberality towards others. He reached out to Jews, including giving a major address at Auschwitz. He engaged in dialogues with atheists and others far from Catholicism, most famously with the philosopher Jürgen Habermas. This upset the church’s traditionalists.
Joseph Ratzinger, later Benedict XVI, had came to be known either as “God’s Rottweiler” or as a faithful “German Shepherd” — a symbol of everything holding the Catholic Church back, or a symbol of its commitment and integrity. The difference represents a deep division among Catholics as to what the Catholic Church is and should be. The pope who resigned made his contribution to that debate, serious, learned and influential, whatever side a person is on.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.