She sang “Amazing Grace,” though with no discernible melody. Then the Lord’s Prayer, then “Jesus Loves the Little Children,” that with something like the tune.
I was in New York City a few summers ago, on the C train going downtown, when a woman with curly black hair almost two feet across stood in the middle of the car and sang, loudly and with an operatic flourish on the high notes at the end. She wore an orange tunic with lots of frills, and black pants stuffed into almost knee high brown leather boots.
A few people watched her, but most people kept doing what they had been doing, looking at their phones, reading, talking or just staring into space. Some of the people watching her smiled.
“I’m not ashamed!” she yelled at one point. “I’m not ashamed! I turned 79 on June 21st!” Then she started singing “Sometimes I feel like a motherless child.”
A young man of about 30 faced her, about three feet away, with a narrow but bushy mustache, what looked like a seersucker jacket, and a silk scarf rather stylishly draped around his shoulders. He never stopped grinning at her, except when he sang along with her when she got to the flourished high notes at the end, which he sang in falsetto.
I thought he was making fun of her, until he said, with an accent, “I come from Russia. In Russia we sing!” and started singing, still in falsetto, what sounded like a hymn.
He and I both got off at Penn Station, so I never found out what would have happened if the old American woman and the young Russian man had kept singing together. I did notice he was wearing cowboy boots.
An American scene
It was a stereotypical American scene, especially for a city: an eccentric person allowed to be eccentric in a public space, appreciated by some and ignored by others, someone from another country, a brief connection, and then everyone going on with their lives.
At least one of them had a story to tell. I’m guessing the natives didn’t think the scene memorable. It was just one of those things you see on the subway.
It’s also an example of the way we typically negotiate life in our shared spaces, which requires some kindness and often considerable patience, and a mutual sense of roughly where the boundaries are, and also how flexible they need to be. Of course some people don’t see the line and and others see it but cross it and take what they want.
Not a perfect system, not even a very good system, but the only way our shared life in our shared spaces works. The only alternatives are to secure the public space by force or to abandon it to the selfish and the predatory.
We can’t secure it by force. No one can afford that many police officers. We need civic authorities to enforce the boundaries as they’ve been codified in law, but that only goes so far, partly because written laws can’t cover everything. As it fails, the authorities will apply more and more force, which will (among other problems) harm the public nature of the shared spaces.
We can’t abandon it, because our shared life depends on public spaces. People need to feel safe to go Downtown, to go to their job, the theater, the courthouse, the restaurants and shops. Give up that space and all those institutions begin to die. People need safe public transportation. Give up that space and many workers can’t get to their jobs, sick people can’t get to their doctor, families and friends can’t meet, people with challenges get stuck close to home.
Sharing shared spaces
As I walked into my local place a few nights ago, a younger friend called me over. He and his wife are about 40 and among my favorite people. “How ya doing, Mr. David?” he asked, sticking out his hand. “I gotta tell ya,” he said right away, “I was kind of bothered by your column on my man Charlie Kirk.”
I explained what I’d said, or tried to say, and what I hadn’t said. He told me what he thought and why he agreed with so much Kirk said. He is also more approving of Donald Trump than I am. (His wife is not.)
We can each see why the other thinks what he thinks, given his experiences and beliefs. We went back and forth for a while and then talked about a couple other things, before we shook hands and I went down the bar to get a seat.
That’s the way life should work in a shared space. I don’t discount his approval of many things I strongly reject, but that’s not the most important thing about him and it’s not the thing that should dominate relations in a shared space like a townie bar. I also don’t discount the fact that there are limits, but I think they’re broader than we tend to feel, and that they include someone, like my friend, with a genuine desire for the good who rejects inhumanity.
We treat other people better when they’re friends, not just people with very different views. In public spaces, I think we should try to relate to others as if they were friends. Assuming the best of them would help sustain the imperfect system we all depend upon. In America, we talk.
David Mills is the deputy editorial page editor and a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His column previous column was “Donald Trump’s radical, dangerous, destructive story.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.