A rabbi, a priest, and a minister walk in. And another rabbi, and a bishop, and another rabbi, and a Muslim, a Hindu, and a Buddhist, and two men from the Salvation Army, and an ecumenical officer, and another bishop, and another rabbi, and others. It’s not the beginning of a joke, but the opening procession of a rare gathering of Pittsburghers from different faiths to pray.

“Healing, Solidarity, and Prayers for Peace,” an interfaith service, was hosted on Sunday afternoon at St. Paul Cathedral in Oakland, in observance of the fifth anniversary, coming up on Friday, of the Tree of Life killings. The gathering was occasioned by a tragedy, but the people came in the hope of stopping another one.

Never the same

“What happened that day made sure that we could never be the same, and we never should be the same,” Bishop David Zubik said in beginning the service. The events “call us to be people who come together to seek peace from the one who is the author of peace, our God in heaven.”

Advertise with us

Bishop Zubik created the service in collaboration with Rabbi Hazzan Jeffrey Myers of the Tree of Life congregation, a survivor of the day. It was arranged by Fr. David Poecking, a priest long concerned with Jewish-Catholic dialogue.

I admire people like Rabbi Myers and his peers who join in such services as this one. If I were Jewish, I’d keep my distance from Christians. And not just because of the horrific history of Christian anti-semitism and the number of Christian anti-semites still around. Catholicism, especially in its most conservative expressions, has a distressing number.

We’ve got horrors to answer for. And a great deal of petty contempt and cruelty to answer for as well. Part of the prayers for peace for us should be a prayer that we will be better than we have been.

Religious people believe that prayer changes things, and changes us, who then change things. Even if you believe that prayer is just words said to Someone who doesn’t exist, the gathering of people of good will and shared hope will change them and through them the world, at least a little bit. That’s not nothing.

It can get us to act. The human tendency is to demand that someone do something. This tends to be someone else and often something greater than us, like the government. To adapt the old joke, in response to real need, we say, “Let’s you and him do good.”

Advertise with us

The religions tend to demand that the someone be you and that you do something specific, and do more than you want to do. The religions at their best, that is. Not the religious, necessarily, of course. But the religion represented by Rabbi Myers, yes.

How do we hope?

The central part of the service was Rabbi Myers’ forceful address. He spoke with the authority of a man who’d gone through a hell most of us can’t imagine. I can’t do the address credit here — he put a lot into his 14 minutes — and urge you to watch it. You can find it here.

I found most moving and convicting what he said about hope and duty. He didn’t just speak about working to make the world better, which is the easy thing to say. What else do you say? He talked about the deeper and necessary attitude to our life in the world that makes such work possible, which is harder to promote, because hope seems irrational.

He began by asking, “How does one follow the news of the world and not fall into despair?” and then explained how we can have hope even when the world seems hopeless. He emphasized our duty. We hope because we act in hope.

Advertise with us

“Hope cannot arrive at your doorstep by special courier, as if you are deserving of it,” he said. “Hope comes when you roll up your sleeves and engage in a project or cause that resonates with you, and find a pathway that helps others.”

That doesn’t require great actions and “global solutions,” which few of us could manage. But it does require a constant supplying of small ones. “If you have a positive difference in the life of one person, or one family, then you have moved the virtual goodness needle a pinch in the right direction.” That pinch changes lives and may prove over time to change many lives a lot.

Prayer is not enough

He did not let the religious off. “Prayer can be a very powerful motivator,” he said. “But that is not enough. The transformation of hope from a prayer to a reality requires us to partner with God. For God has gifted humanity with intellect, the ability to problem-solve, find like-minded people, and strive to be a better society. ... And that includes fixing all that we broke. As we say in Hebrew, tikkun olam.”

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “The House Republican clown car isn’t funny, though it should be.”

The service may be watched here. Rabbi Myers’ address begins at 21:04. Here is a Post-Gazette profile of him.