What makes a man into Robert Bow­ers? What choices did he have to make, what sto­ries did he choose to be­lieve, how many cru­el­ties had he in­flicted on oth­ers, how much plea­sure had he taken in evil, to have so killed his con­science? What life did he live to be­come the man who walked into a syn­a­gogue while peo­ple were wor­ship­ing to kill them?

That’s the ques­tion last week’s Erad­i­cate Hate Global Sum­mit raised for me. Other peo­ple will be oc­cu­pied with other ques­tions, and im­por­tant ones like how to keep so­cial me­dia from en­cour­ag­ing hate. The dis­cus­sion be­tween peo­ple who’d lost loved ones at the Tree of Life shoot­ing was pain­ful to hear, though the peo­ple shar­ing their sto­ries were he­roic in do­ing so. It made me ask what sort of man does that to peo­ple.

My col­league Gene Col­lier wrote about the Sum­mit and the hope it pro­claimed on Sun­day, in “After the trial, hope.” We’re for­tu­nate — re­li­gious peo­ple would say blessed — that our city has the peo­ple to think up and the re­sources to cre­ate such an en­ter­prise.

The mys­tery of in­iq­uity

Advertise with us

Theo­lo­gians talk about the mys­tery of in­iq­uity, es­pe­cially when try­ing to ex­plain some­one like Robert Bow­ers. He stands out in a way very hard to ex­plain.

Look­ing at the typ­i­cal hu­man be­ing, we have our good points and our bad points. We can be self­ish and un­kind and de­ceit­ful, and very good at ra­tio­nal­iz­ing hurt­ing oth­ers to get what we want or hurt­ing them just be­cause we dis­like them. But we can be kind to strang­ers and sac­ri­fice our­selves for peo­ple we don’t know.

Still, we’re me­di­oc­ri­ties at be­ing bad. We couldn’t be a mon­ster like Robert Bow­ers. Why is he the way he is? He didn’t have to be. Psy­chol­o­gists and so­ciol­o­gists and other peo­ple will have some ideas.

Va­clav Havel, the great Czech dis­si­dent leader who be­came the first pres­i­dent of post-com­mu­nist Czecho­slo­va­kia, for ex­am­ple. In his ad­dress to a 1990 con­fer­ence on “The anat­omy of hate,” he de­scribed how shar­ing a ha­tred at­tracts a cer­tain kind of per­son.

“Col­lec­tive ha­tred elim­i­nates lone­li­ness, weak­ness, pow­er­less­ness, a sense of be­ing ig­nored or aban­doned,” he said. “This, of course, helps peo­ple deal with lack of rec­og­ni­tion, lack of suc­cess, be­cause it of­fers them a sense of to­geth­er­ness. It cre­ates a strange broth­er­hood, founded on a sim­ple form of mu­tual un­der­stand­ing that makes no de­mands what­so­ever. ... The con­di­tions of mem­ber­ship are eas­ily met, and no one need fear that he will not pass mus­ter. What could be sim­pler than shar­ing a com­mon ob­ject of aver­sion?”

Advertise with us

It’s a “yes, ob­vi­ously” ob­ser­va­tion, that some peo­ple join hate groups to try to cure their so­cial or per­sonal in­ad­e­quacy — like the young men de­scribed in the old joke as still liv­ing in their mother’s base­ment. Ha­tred can pro­vide a ha­ven in a heart­less world.

The ca­pac­ity for hate

But Havel’s de­scrib­ing a lot more peo­ple than the mon­sters. He says at the be­gin­ning of his talk that he does not have “the ca­pac­ity to hate.” That seems to have been true. It helped him sur­vive the re­gime’s per­se­cu­tion, which was al­ter­nately bru­tal and cru­elly petty. It made him an ef­fec­tive leader and the one ma­jor dis­si­dent trusted enough to unite all the fac­tions when the com­mu­nist gov­ern­ment fell.

But most of us me­di­oc­ri­ties-not-mon­sters have some ca­pac­ity for hate, es­pe­cially in the stepped-down modes like con­tempt, dis­dain, and scorn. Let’s call it hate­ful­ness. If we don’t hate in the all-en­com­pass­ing way Robert Bow­ers did, we can en­joy be­ing hate­ful. And col­lec­tively hate­ful. We can en­joy it es­pe­cially when we can feel righ­teous in do­ing so.

But hate ex­ists on a spec­trum and peo­ple can move down it the wrong way. I think the spectrum’s often tilted with deep hate at the bottom, and some people slide down naturally. Hate­ful­ness en­cour­ages hate in those in­clined to it, and helps cre­ate a world in which peo­ple feel hate is nor­mal and ad­mi­ra­ble, and even nec­es­sary. It makes the lonely per­son Havel speaks of feel even lone­lier and even hap­pier to find a band of peo­ple as hate­ful as he.

Advertise with us

Our own part

We can do our own part in erad­i­cat­ing hate by speak­ing less hate­fully. By speak­ing to peo­ple we think wrong po­litely, re­spect­fully, gen­er­ously, as­sum­ing they’re open to rea­son, as we would wish peo­ple who think we’re wrong would speak to us. It’s a small act, and prob­a­bly not of­ten suc­cess­ful in get­ting peo­ple to see what we see, but at least it would re­duce the amount of hate­ful­ness in the world. That’s something.

We can do some­thing also to try to stop peo­ple from be­com­ing the kind of peo­ple Havel de­scribes. The lonely drawn to elim­i­nate their lone­li­ness in a shared hate need friends and a com­mu­nity that would give them what they find in hate groups. They must be reach­able at some point be­fore they go too far.

That means try­ing to like peo­ple, to spend time with them as friends, that may not be very likable. I find this hard. But it’s some­thing we can do to pull someone away from the hate that attracts him, that may change the per­son just enough that we change the world with­out know­ing it.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “Children aren't culture war foot soldiers.” He wrote about Havel here.