Heinous gun violence in Pittsburgh and across the country raises the question: Is there an antidote for a disintegrating society?
No, of course not. There are never simple answers to complex problems.
But that doesn’t mean that individuals are powerless to effect the many changes needed to make America a livable and healthy place for all. In fact, it’s precisely the despair about each person’s power to make a difference — both to those closest to us and in our wider society — that has brought us to this point.
First of all, there are necessary political responses to gun violence, and especially to school shootings by young men. The single best way to rid ourselves of gun violence is to extinguish access to the guns that are their cause. Certainly, assault rifles should never be sold to civilians and the age to purchase a gun should be raised to 25. There should be requirements that gun owners undergo training and have locked storage facilities. Buyback programs to get guns off the streets should be frequent occurrences and purchasers of all ages should need a thorough mental and physical health screening. These are just a few of the commonsense fixes that have been recommended by experts backed by research.
However, there are avenues of change beyond policy and politics that will also promote a healthier society, one in which individuals can truly thrive rather than feeling alienated from those around them.
After the Parkland, Fla., high school shooting in Feb. 2018, National Public Radio summed up a detailed report about preventing gun violence like this: “Don’t harden schools. Make them softer, by improving social and emotional health.” The report suggested taking a cue from preventative medicine.
Read More
Here’s what that might look like. Odis Johnson, Jr., of Johns Hopkins University’s Center for Safe and Healthy Schools recently told a reporter, “Our first preventative strategy should be to make sure kids are respected, that they feel connected and belong in schools.” This softer approach relies on creating a team to identify students who are having social and emotional difficulties and giving them the necessary support before they reach a crisis point.
This “softer” approach to building up individuals and society doesn’t have to be limited to schools. Imagine a society where all members feel seen and appreciated — by those around them as well as by those in authority — and where individuals care about and are truly invested in the well-being of others, in every sense. This isn’t just about feelings; it’s about action.
Every person can make an effort to greet neighbors by name and ask about their welfare, and that of their family. Pittsburghers are nebby: It’s not hard to accompany this interest in others with actual expressions of care. For instance, if you know someone who’s sick, bring them a container of soup, homemade or not, enabling you to take stock of their situation as you deliver, figuring out what other kinds of support they might need.
Less intensive but still powerful, you might give extra belongings away on a “Buy Nothing” group on Facebook or elsewhere. My older children decided to finally go through all their old toys in the basement and give them to those who could enjoy them now. While filling my trunk, we saw a young child walking home from school with her mother and offered them the pick of the lot. The look of delight as this young girl received two curly haired clown wigs and a clown suit, a sparkly gymnastics uniform and other goodies was priceless. More than new toys, she received the knowledge that other people she never met care about her and her family’s well-being.
I was the recipient of great kindness after my life was upended by gun violence at my husband’s workplace. New Light Congregation, which rented space at Tree of Life, was attacked by an antisemitic gunman on October 27, 2018. My husband was fortunate to have time to hide himself and others, but eleven Jews were killed.
In the weeks after, there was a steady stream of visitors bringing us meals, which helped us at a time when we were not able to focus on much beyond getting to the funerals and shiva prayers for our three slain congregants — and just getting through the days. At the same time that evil was allowed to have so much power, those who wanted to display their ability to be kind also came forward with their own powers.
Jewish literary tradition includes the Biblical book of Ruth, which is read in honor of the holiday of Shavuot, celebrated today. This book posits an orderly society, one which culminates in the birth of King David, the ancestor to the Messiah; it functions as an antidote to the book of Judges, which describes a lawless, violent and uncaring society. What is the specific ingredient that enables positive change in Ruth’s character and in her society as a whole? Kindness. In fact, Ruth Rabba 2:14 says the book was written only to teach the reward for those who do kindness.
The lesson of kindness — that is, of true loving care for our neighbors and all members of society — in tandem with legal and political solutions, can make all the difference. This is how we reintegrate young people, and all people, into a society where none feel the alienation that can lead to malice, the acquisition of weapons and deadly violence. In order to truly solve the gun violence problem we need to remove both the weapons themselves and the desire to do harm — a desire that so often comes from feeling disconnected, ignored and uncared for.
Beth Kissileff is co-editor of “Bound in the Bond of Life: Pittsburgh Writers Respond to the Tree of Life Tragedy” and the author of the novel “Questioning Return.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.