You can see the little weasels plotting their next hit, back at the office after the expense account lunch in midtown Manhattan. Mix a romantic idea of “real” America with some in-your-face culture warring against the “elites,” give it to a star with MAGA fans, make a video with pictures of city people rioting — though not any of people rioting on January 6, 2021 — and Boom! a hit, and hits mean money.
And you can see, because the weasels are really good at what they do, and they’re as cynical as they are clever, them figuring out how they can trigger the left into outrage and give the pundits something to denounce. They know how many love to be outraged at the right and have a reason to attack them. Match meet kindling.
Outrage means publicity and that means more viewers and even more money. It would be easy to do. Maybe film the video in front of the site of a lynching, because someone’s going to spot that, and use clips from the riots after the police killings of George Floyd and other Black men, because someone’s going to spot that too. Use them so they seem like racist dogwhistles — and if they work as dogwhistles for racists, that’s okay.
They’re already using “city” as the bad place, and too many people take city to mean Black, and “small town” as the good place, and most Americans picture small towns as white. The song features racist images whatever the writers meant.
They might even, because they are so clever and so cynical, plan to have people pretend to be outraged leftists to get the controversy going. It’s like astroturfing, when they create the illusion of a popular movement when there is none, but from the other direction. It’s easy to do if you know how and don’t have any moral objections to lying.
Too big for sincerity
Read More
That may be unfair, and the song the heartfelt production of men who grew up in small towns and remember the good old days, and feel horrified by how wrong the modern city world has gone, but I doubt it. I realize that’s a dark view of the upper levels of the music industry, but country music’s a big business, too big to be left to sincerity. The weasels are always looking for work, and in industries where the profits are never high enough, people will hire them.
And the song itself? My main feeling when I first watched the video was that the song felt fake. After my decades editing writers and would-be writers, and learning the hard way how far a distance there often is between the writer’s reality and the reality he describes, it felt manufactured to me. A little too calculated, a little too slick and sentimental, a little too one-sided and simplistic. It felt like someone building on a stereotype. Genuinely sincere writers write with rougher edges and usually less certainty, and avoid stereotypes because they’re writing about real people who are more complicated.
The lines about the good ol’ boys who’ll beat you up if you engage in any of that big-city badness, for example. “Around here, we take care of our own,” Aldean sings. “You cross that line, it won't take long for you to find out. I recommend you don't try that in a small town full of good ol' boys, raised up right.”
You can see the weasels’ stereotype: Big guys just waitin’ to beat up one a’ them city folks who come out here to spit on our cops and burn the American flag. Into the song it goes, though they make the good ol’ boys look heroic, given the song’s target audience.
I haven’t known any southern good ol’ boys, but I grew up with the New England version. The southerners I’ve heard speak of them speak of them as I would of the ones I knew: good guys, who’ll help you out if they can, hard workers, but basically guys out for a good easy life, who just want to get by.
Almost always politically conservative, because they just want government to leave them alone, and often repositories of prejudices they fortunately usually don’t act on. Not incapable of violence, but also not guys looking for excuses to beat up people. Not Aldean’s good ol’ boys.
Look to Mayberry
As I said, I could be wrong about the song. I am not wrong about the way the calculating weasels think. They’re in an extraordinarily cynical business. And, alas, at that level, really good at it.
I think the problem is the writers’ attempt to use the classic American image of the small town for culture-warring, particularly to glorify violence against the left and the “elites,” but it doesn’t fit. What is the classic sentimental version of the American small town?
Mayberry, North Carolina, in “The Andy Griffith Show,” a hit tv show from 1960 to 1968. What would Sheriff Andy have said of Aldean’s good ol’ boys being there to beat up the bad city people? He would have said, “He's a bad 'un,” and looked for some other way to deal with the bad people. But that’s too nice to sell downloads.
David Mills is the associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous article was “What do you pay running backs, and why, and what about the rest of us?”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.