Jason Aldean’s country hit, “Try That In a Small Town” has been criticized for its lyrics and video, with critics calling it racist and violent, a coded message against Black protest encased in a package of rural pride. But the song’s lyrics have taken on a new meaning after a massive altercation in Alabama turned it into an anthem of Black resistance.

They tried it in a small town — a group of tough guys beat up a lone dockworker. But as Mr. Aldean sings, “Yeah, ya think you're tough. … See how far ya make it down the road.” These guys, they didn’t even make it off the dock.

They didn’t realize

The owners of a pontoon boat docked along a waterway in Montgomery, Alabama. What they did not realize is that the Harriott II, a riverboat carrying 227 mostly Black passengers on a historical cruise, needed to unload in that exact same spot.

Advertise with us

The co-captain of the boat was ferried to shore in a smaller boat after attempting to contact the owners of the pontoon for 45 minutes. As he tried to argue with the owners, or at least move the pontoon himself, its owners took umbrage. Words were exchanged.

And then, in a moment that has been watched millions of times all over the world, the very white owners of the boat decided to attack the very Black co-captain. Passengers on the riverboat came to their captain’s aid, one even swimming across the river, another wielding a folding chair as a weapon — and the Alabama Riverboat Brawl was born.

Videos of the incident spread quickly all over social media. Black Twitter had a field day. Pictures of Harriet Tubman holding a white folding chair have circulated widely online as every angle of the incident has been dissected.

Mockery and joy

Overwhelmingly, the reaction has been one of merciless mockery — of joy, even. The laughter belies the shock of the whole incident, how a calm day at the river quickly descended into what can initially appear to be racialized violence.

Advertise with us

Some witnesses said slurs were exchanged. Others said it was simply a combination of alcohol, heat and entitlement. Some pointed out that this all took place footsteps away from a location where enslaved people were sold.

Media coverage and commentary has been extensive. But something to note: No one has come out in favor of the Pontoon People. Everyone seems clearly on the side of the riverboat’s co-captain.

The fact that the Pontoon People are clearly at fault, and their lack of defenders, made it easier to laugh. The sheer delight of watching some jerks get their comeuppance cannot be minimized.

We live in an unfair world. People get away with bad behavior all the time. Or we ascribe a certain badness to those who cannot help their circumstances. Most of the time, when a white man attacks a Black man, or vice versa, there is little humor to be found.

Many people have been killed for less. We live in a country where less than a century ago, a Black man could be murdered for smiling at, or being in the vicinity of, the wrong person.

Advertise with us

Luxury Laughter

Laughter is a luxury. Laughter is an undoing of tension. Laughter is embracing the absurdity of it all.

We laugh because no one was ultimately hurt — outside of some black eyes, some bruised ribs and some bruised egos. Sure, some will argue that the Pontoon People got hurt, their businesses overwhelmed with bad reviews and their characters besmirched over one drunken moment of entitlement. But, with time and some humility, they’ll be fine.

But for the people of color I know online, watching some bad actors get their just desserts was tremendously sweet. Justice was delivered — and no trial or arrest will equal the satisfaction of seeing a group of Black men surround the Pontoon Punks ready to go, Avengers style.

Several versions of the brawl video use Mr. Aldean’s anthem as background music. It’s a beautifully ironic reclamation of a song that’s pretty much a dog-whistle for racialized vigilante justice. But the passengers of the Harriot II proved that it’s not just people who look like Mr. Aldean who “take care of [their] own.”

Advertise with us

I guess this is what happens in a small town.

Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous column was “Living with the contradictions of the death penalty.”