If you want to screw up a kid, raise him to be king. Especially when as king he'll spend his days having to act like a king without a king's power and authority — wearing the funny outfits, enduring the rituals, giving speeches written by others even when he disagrees with them, talking to politicians only pretending to care what he thinks, and always, always, always remembering the public is watching.

If you want to screw up a kid, make the poor boy look forward to life as a tourist attraction.

I don’t envy King Charles the life he has led and will lead, presumably till he dies. It’s what happens when, through no fault of your own, you’re born the queen’s first son. I admire the way he’s done his duty as he saw it. He must have known how much pain and confusion his refusing would have caused his family and nation.

The most difficult part may be that the poor man had to live with a divide between what he had to do because he was the Prince of Wales and what he wanted to do. We all live with that divide, but very few of us have so all-encompassing an identity imposed on us.

Advertise with us

We chose much of what we have to do. Our future was ours to create. We made our bed and now we have to sleep in it, but we had the chance to buy our own mattress. Charles was given the bed, told he would never get another, so suck it up and deal, and of course the bed turned out to be partly a bed of nails.

In which he did not sleep well. As the English historian Rosemary Hill put it, Charles’s has been “a life spent trapped in a role he didn’t choose doing things he doesn’t like for people who don’t much appreciate them.” Or, more to the point, him.

Most famously, the prince had to marry well, as the monarchy defined well. He had to marry a young woman to look good in public and pop out adorable heirs, even if he loved someone else. He tried to have his cake and keep it too, by having an affair.

He didn’t do his duty to his wife and their children, to be faithful to his wedding vows, but even that is something royalty winks at. He did do his duty to his family, to keep the show going and keep the people happy.

That’s the role poor Charles was raised to play. Though “an awkward boy who didn’t take after either his bluff father or his pragmatic, dutiful but distant mother,” his parents made Charles “the guinea pig for a modernising monarchy.” They knew they had to change with the times, to keep people from wondering why they were paying so much for an institution that didn’t actually do anything for them.

Advertise with us

Queen Elizabeth and Prince Philip started their experiment in updating the monarchy by sending Charles to prep school, instead of educating him with tutors at home. As Hill notes, he got beaten up even though he had a personal bodyguard. You can imagine the little thugs bragging to their friends at home that they pounded the Prince of Wales.

But at least he was showing the world the monarchy was catching up with the times. Guinea pigs suffer, but someone has to suffer to ensure the institution survives. To be fair to Elizabeth and Philip, in the past, kings married off their young daughters to creepy older men to secure political alliances. Careful attention to the needs of children isn’t part of European royal tradition.

Hill describes the formative years of the new king’s life in poignant terms: “Throughout his uneasy adolescence Charles was subjected, on the one hand, to stinging criticism, from his father and at times from the press, and on the other to the lies and flattery of courtiers and social climbers. Alternately puffed up and slapped down, his temperament developed into a mixture of self-doubt and ambivalence interlaced with short-lived bursts of enthusiasm and fits of petulance.”

As anyone’s would have. You grow up wanting friends and keep finding that the people who say they want to be your friend don’t want to be your friend. They want to be the friend of the Prince of Wales. You’re never just Charley. Who can you trust? How do you know what people really want?

Charles did his duty, and we should admire him for that. Of course, he never had to worry about paying the bills. Outside his official work, and keeping up the image his position required, he could do almost anything he wanted. We can’t feel too sorry for him.

Advertise with us

But a little sorry.

David Mills is the associate editorial page editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: dmills@post-gazette.com. His previous column was “Don't insult the woman who runs the soup kitchen.”