The Pennsylvania Turnpike Commission will spend $2 million it doesn’t have to study a scheme to transport people and freight in pods going more than 500 miles per hour between Pittsburgh and Philadelphia.

It’d be kind of like the pneumatic tubes banks use, proponents say. Almost everyone else is thinking this hyperloop is kind of like Maglev or Skybus. Its cutting-edge transportation technology ain’t gonna cut it here.

Joe Grata began covering transportation for The Pittsburgh Press in the early 1970s. That makes him one of the few who ever rode Skybus, an automated, rubber-tire people-mover on an elevated track that never got past its two-month demonstration project in South Park. Skeptical public officials successfully sued to kill it.

I called Mr. Grata to ask what was the dumbest high-tech transportation idea he’d encountered in the nearly half-century since.

Advertise with us

“I think it would be a tie,’’ he said, “between hyperloop and maglev.”

For those new in town, let me explain maglev. You likely missed all the Pittsburgh headlines about this high-speed magnetic-levitation train with cars “floating’’ 2 inches above a guideway. So check these:

“Japanese Give $250,000 to Maglev Group Here” (June 1990), “U.S. Gives $660,000 To Help Fund Maglev Study” (April 1991), [Gov. Robert P.] “Casey Seeks $2 Million in Funding for Design of Maglev Transit System” (June 1992), “$415,000 Granted for Maglev Study” (January 1995), “County Commissioners Approve Loan Guarantees for Maglev Line” (February 1997), “Will Airport Maglev Float or Flop?” (June 1998), and “Maglev, not War.”

OK, I made that last one up. The rest were all too real and I could go on. This newspaper has had almost 800 more stories or letters containing the word “maglev’’ since mid-1998, albeit some of them just dismissive slaps at the train that never arrived.

Maglev notions came in several flavors. The initial plan was to spend as much as $648 million for a high-speed train from the South Side to what was then Greater Pittsburgh International Airport. Then another group wangled money to study a train from the South Side to Oakland. That same group turned around the next year and said, now that we’ve thought about it, what Pittsburgh really needs is a $140 million high-speed train from a Civic Arena parking garage — to Grant Street. Wheeeee!

Advertise with us

Something called Maglev Inc. continued into this century with plans for a high-speed, high-cost and high-tech line from Greensburg to the airport. It filed for bankruptcy in 2011.

Henry Posner III, chairman of Railroad Development Corp. in Green Tree and an adjunct professor at Carnegie Mellon University, owns or manages freight and passenger lines from Iowa to Peru to Germany. His view of hyperloop?

“I think it’s the next maglev — without the job-creation component specific to Pittsburgh,’’ Mr. Posner said.

Maglev didn’t pan out because it couldn’t be integrated with existing transit systems, he believes. When the French built a high-speed network, they built it “from nowhere to nowhere, from a cornfield outside Paris to a cornfield outside Lyon,” he said, but that was its genius.

“You leave Paris on a railway line built 150 years ago, then you’re on a line from nowhere to nowhere, and then you’re back on 150-year-old rights of way.’’ You’ve never left the train. And when a train does stop in France, there are local transit options.

Advertise with us

“When you ride the train to Paris, you don’t then go to the Hertz counter. You take a metro.”

Here in Appalachia, we don’t think that way. “Appalachians don’t see mobility as an asset. It’s a liability,’’ he said. Our transit system is purposely primitive.

Buses to malls get shunted to the far reaches of parking lots. Edgewood successfully lobbied against a busway stop. And the only public transit from the airport is the 28X bus, which has no special features to accommodate luggage and stops at Robinson Town Center along the way.

“That every day people show up at the airport with luggage to ride the 28X is a complete surprise” to the Port Authority, Mr. Posner said.

For hyperloop to work here as a practical option for travelers, it would almost have to tunnel to Downtown, and that would mean extraordinary costs, Mr. Posner believes. So hyperloop isn’t coming. “It’s ‘big bang’ as opposed to evolution,’’ he said. “Things have to be done incrementally, as the French did.”

Advertise with us

I hope it’s not loopy to conclude with this note: Former Mayor Luke Ravenstahl, the fourth Pittsburgh mayor to reign during two decades of scattered maglev hallucinations, finally got to ride on a magnetic levitation train. That was in 2010, on a visit to Shanghai.

Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill