I went to an old friend’s opera last weekend.
Plenty of guys in 1780s Vienna or 1890s Turin could probably say that, but to say that in 2019 Pittsburgh is the definition of a long shot.
Tommy Cipullo — excuse me, we’re not in Mr. Mitchell’s third-grade class, he’s “Tom” Cipullo now — was down from New York for The Pittsburgh Opera performance of his “Glory Denied.’’ That’s the story of Col. Jim Thompson, held prisoner in Vietnam from 1964 to 1973. Col. Thompson came home to discover his wife, family and country had moved on and pretty much left all he had known behind.
It’s powerful. It took Tom five years to write the words and music. A four-person cast of characters — the young prisoner Jim Thompson, the returned prisoner of war Jim Thompson, the young idealistic wife Alyce and the older, world-weary wife Alyce — bounce a woeful tale back and forth in times and places half a world away.
When it ended, I rose with about everyone else for a standing ovation March 1 at Pittsburgh Opera Headquarters in the Strip District, and had to bite my lip to keep from shouting, “My buddy did that!’’
It was the third of four performances here, and “Glory Denied’’ has had more than 20 professional productions in the past dozen years, from New York to Houston to Anchorage and points in between. There’s a YouTube video of the late U.S. senator and prisoner of war John McCain plugging the opera.
Read More
Opera is surreal enough when you don’t know the composer. But this was coming to me from the same guy who tipped me in 8th-grade shop class that I really ought to see the Marx Brothers on “The 4:30 Movie.” I now owe him for two revelations.
Tom’s libretto, based on the 2001 oral history of the same name by Tom Philpott, is nothing if not the language of 20th-century America, in all its anger, slang and charm. Baritone Benjamin Taylor delivered a catalog of all that changed in our country between 1964 and 1973, an operatic rap sheet that transfixed the small, packed theater of roughly 200 souls.
“Wasn’t that brilliant?” Mr. Philpott asked, drawing applause in a post-opera question-and-answer session with the two Toms after the performance.
My friend recalled reading The New York Times book review of “Glory Denied.” “Something said to me, ‘This is an opera’,’’ and he immediately contacted Mr. Philpott.
“I didn’t hear too much from him for the next three years,’’ Mr. Philpott said, but my friend was hard at his task.
Mr. Cipullo and I were born in a lucky year. The Vietnam War raged when we were growing up, but the draft ended our junior year in high school as American involvement waned. That era shaped us nonetheless, and the oral histories of the Thompson family that Mr. Philpott collected and shared gave Mr. Cipullo all the words he needed.
“I’m not the librettist,’’ Tom insisted. “I just use the words that [Mr. Philpott] got people to say.”
My friend can wear his heart on his sleeve, and anyone could see he was moved by the production and the performances from resident artists Mr. Taylor, Terrence Chin-Loy (Younger Thompson), Ashley Fabian (Younger Alyce) and Caitlin Gotimore (Older Alyce).
“When you write an opera, you sit by yourself at a little table every night for years,’’ Tom said. “For years. And you work on it. And then, sometimes if you’re really lucky, you get to come see a production like tonight.’’
Mr. Philpott told the crowd there is something about the choices Tom made, in the words and music, that intensifies the emotion of the stories he thought he knew fully.
“I wrote the book,’’ Mr. Philpott said, “I interviewed all these people. But I learn more about them every time I see it.’’
That’s the power of art.
The afternoon after the show, I had lunch with Tom, his wife, Hedwig Brouckaert, and their 7-year-old daughter, Lois, in Oakland. They’d just toured the Carnegie Museum. Lois was hardly touching her green beans, but when Tom and I persuaded her to give us a Bugs Bunny “What’s Up, Doc’’ impression with a bean, she complied ably, and a few more beans disappeared.
That’s the power of art, too.
I can’t honestly remember if that first Marx Brothers movie Tommy recommended circa 1969 was “A Night at the Opera,’’ but I’m not going to forget the night at the opera Tom provided a half-century later.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.