The Spanish Civil War is distinctive, even among other civil wars, for its barbarism, and in particular the personal nature of the cruelties inflicted.
Unlike the American Civil War, it was only accidentally defined by geography. Mostly, it was cultural and economic, pitting peasants against landowners, Catholics against secularists, traditionalists against radicals, neighbors against neighbors.
The testimony of a nationalist officer, Tomas Garicano Goñi, in a 1983 British television documentary on the conflict haunts me: “I was not a member of any political party, but we felt there was no way out,” he said.
He did not believe the nation could have peace. “And there’s something else, perhaps too embarrassing to recall, but one has to admit: At that time, we couldn’t stand each other. Divisions and tensions had reached such a point that seeing a Socialist, not to mention a Communist, was the same as seeing the Devil.”
We couldn’t stand each other. It’s such a simple phrase, but it goes straight to the heart of what it means to live in society. A democratic society only works if the overwhelming majority of people believe they can share a political community with different kinds of people with different views and beliefs — and, crucially, if they believe that those people believe the same.
After the assassination of Charlie Kirk, and the many who rejoiced and the many who saw this reaction as a declaration that the others wanted them dead too, American society seems to have reached the point described by the Spanish officer. The only question that remains: Is there a way out?
Thin peace and true peace
There is nothing more necessary to personal and social flourishing than peace. The enjoyment of every other human good depends on it. This is why peace is, in principle, the deepest human desire.
But what is peace? Typically, we identify peace with the absence of conflict, of strife, of suffering, or as something that just happens or not, like warm weather or enough rain.
This is a very thin idea of peace, too thin to sustain a society. Worse, it can mask conditions that aren’t peaceful at all. For instance, a community where there’s little visible conflict, but where some people are ruthlessly economically exploited to the point of poverty, is not at peace.
True peace isn’t an absence, but a presence: of justice, of order, of social harmony. It isn’t something that just happens. It requires the everyday choices of people to fulfill their social responsibilities, to act justly and generously and honestly, to treat others with love and respect.
At best, the United States in September 2025 experiences a thin peace. It certainly does not have true peace.
Friends and enemies
When it was said that “peace was not possible” in Spain in the 1930s, this meant the last remnants of a thin peace could no longer hold back the hatreds that were deepening day by day. (True peace had been lost long before.)
Can America at least hold onto its thin peace, even if the deeper peace is beyond our grasp? History teaches that this is unlikely, especially once a cycle of violent recriminations has begun.
Even if people of disparate backgrounds and beliefs no longer think of themselves as friends or at least potential friends, in the sense of sharing broad goals for a peaceful society, in a thin peace they still tolerate one another. They do this because they do not want the consequences of upending that thin peace — violence, chaos, suffering.
But there comes a time when people begin seeing their countrymen as enemies, whose continued existence in the same political community threatens not just their political goals but their personal security and well-being, and that of their loved ones. At this time, the thin peace comes to be seen as untenable, even dangerous, because it gives your enemies cover while they plot your demise.
Better to tear the veil away, people think. Better an honest war than a thin, dishonest peace.
Tribulations
In terms of the way we speak to each other, America has been in this condition for some time. Social media sites — and, increasingly, the halls of government — are full of people claiming their political opponents are enemies of the Republic, that they are dangerous to their fellow Americans, that they want you dead.
Now, a man really is dead, and his gory slaying was caught on film, and millions upon millions of people have watched it. The talk has become real.
It’s possible this moment will dissipate. The rage may dissolve in the acid bath of the internet, with no further bloodshed. Or the number of Americans who value the thin peace will still overcome all of those who feel there is “no way out” but through violence.
More likely, our thin peace is ending, or has ended. That doesn’t necessarily mean a descent into 1930s Spain. But it does mean explicit political violence becoming normalized.
At least for a time. There is one hopeful lesson from history, and from humans’ natural desire for peace.
There eventually comes a time when people decide that even a thin peace is better than a drawn-out war; that the security it offers is better than seeking a total victory that is always illusory and temporary; that the violence and the suffering, which once seemed necessary, is no longer worth it.
And from that thin peace, inspired by the raw memories of its absence, a true peace can be built once again.
Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “Pittsburgh’s anti-police activists have lost the plot.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.