I am not, you might have guessed, a natural protester. Yet in the spring of 2020, I planned to attend a Black Lives Matter march on West Liberty Avenue. The timing ended up conflicting with a family commitment, so I volunteered to hang out at the staging area and tidy it up after the march left.

The McDonald’s parking lot was a festive atmosphere, and I was clearly not the only first-timer. It felt as if a real mass movement might be blossoming. After all, even I had responded to the sense that something had to be done by doing something.

In the days and weeks that followed, rioters ransacked Downtown businesses and burned police cars and a crowd clashed with officers in East Liberty. It placed our peaceful South Hills march in a different light.

Chasing the high

Were we pathetic and performative while others took real action and real risks? Or had we been duped into giving respectable cover to an uglier, more radical plan? Or did different people simply react in different ways to the greatest unleashing of popular political energies in decades?

Advertise with us

It was a little of everything. Perhaps above all, it was intoxicating. Because it was grounded in reality.

This week, however, Pittsburgh City Council endured a wave of outrage regarding a proposed public safety campus in Lincoln-Lemington, on the site of the former VA Hospital, that was detached from reality.

In these organized ambushes, whether about public safety or some other issue and often fueled by misinformation, we can see the long shadow of 2020 — attempts to recapture the energies of that spring and summer, and to feel again the excitement that comes with being part of a mass movement that’s effecting real change.

The trouble is that the events of 2020 were triggered by a single unpredictable event, the on-camera murder of George Floyd, the public response to which was at least mostly organic.

That horrible and indelible film illustrated a deeper truth about the place of Black people in American society: brutalized, marginalized, discarded. And the recognition of that truth kicked off a real outpouring of protest.

Advertise with us

Today’s activists, however, must create their own triggering events — often badly exaggerated, misconstrued or simply made up. Such is the case with Pittsburgh’s so-called “cop city.”

Invented ‘cop city’

In 2021, the City of Atlanta proposed to turn an old prison farm in the suburbs into a massive police training center, including a mock city. Activists — hyperbolically, but not completely unreasonably  — described the project as “cop city”: a place to militarize law enforcement.

Pittsburgh’s activist scene seized on the “cop city” moniker and applied it to a Peduto-era bid to replace the hilltop VA with a public safety training and administration campus. Because the Gainey administration gave the activists a de facto veto over city policy, it languished for three years.

Meanwhile, time ticked away: Under a 2021 deal with the federal government, the land would revert to Washington’s control if the city didn’t have a public safety-focused plan for it by June 2026. So now there’s a rush to develop a plan before time’s up.

It is the creation of this plan to which the Spirit-of-2020 activists objected at council this week. Apparently, they would rather these urban acres be under the control of the Trump administration than be used by Pittsburgh to construct a first-class training center for all its first responders.

Advertise with us

This is the problem with ginned-up activism: In trying to generate popular enthusiasm artificially, rather than on the basis of a true upwelling, it’s easy to lose the plot — and contact with reality altogether.

The potential for the VA site is tremendous. The police’s antiquated outdoor firing range, loathed by everyone within earshot (especially in Highland Park), can be moved inside. The fire bureau’s training facility, currently unusable in the Washington Boulevard flood zone — city firefighters have to train in North Park — can be moved to higher ground.

EMS can be brought together with its public-safety partners, and purpose-built facilities for the Freedom House training program can be constructed. The Office of Community Health and Safety can train its social workers in co-response with all three bureaus in one place.

It could even turn a profit: The campus would immediately become a top option for suburban public safety departments to train their professionals — for a fee. State and federal grants would further reduce the cost to the city.

Nothing but the truth

I don’t doubt that most of the people who told City Council that Pittsburgh’s project is incipient fascism were sincere — at least in part because they sincerely want to recreate the energy of a half-decade ago. During those months, and for some time after — including the 2021 mayoral primary — popular political action made many feel hope and meaning in a time of alienation and pessimism.

Advertise with us

For a moment, I even caught the bug.

Yet in Pittsburgh today, activism is increasingly unmoored from reality, and pursued for the sake of chasing the memory of a feeling that can’t be created out of slogans and lies.

Political action that generates meaning, purpose and hope must first and always be rooted in the truth.

Brandon McGinley’s previous column was “In praise of the ordinary life.”