Two years ago, Carnegie Mellon University senior Anthony Cacciato attended a controversial speaking event at the University of Pittsburgh that quickly turned ugly.

During a debate between a gay libertarian journalist and a conservative commentator, protesters threw an explosive device at police. Roads and university buildings were closed. Oakland hospitals had to reroute ambulances. Two people were arrested following the tumultuous protest.

It was an example of how “political violence can hit close to home for conservatives on college campuses in Pittsburgh,” reflected Mr. Cacciato, who is president of CMU’s College Republicans.

The fatal shooting of conservative activist Charlie Kirk at a Utah university on Wednesday further amplifies the concerns Mr. Cacciato and other Pittsburgh-area students have regarding safety and free speech rights on campus.

Advertise with us

“I think a lot of us are concerned about what safety might look like going forward,” Mr. Cacciato said.

In the wake of Mr. Kirk’s death, colleges nationwide are grappling with safety and free speech concerns on their own campuses. And they are juggling these challenges as they manage student bodies with increasingly hostile and extreme views.

Rising numbers of students support censorship, according to a 2025 survey by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression, or FIRE. Of the more than 68,000 students surveyed, a third expressed some support for violence to stop a campus speech. That’s up from 20% of students three years ago.

Wednesday’s shooting is indicative of this growing approval of violence university students, said Nico Perrino, FIRE’s executive vice president.

“Unfortunately, since 2021, we've seen a steady rise in support for violence in response to speech on campus,” Mr. Perrino said in a statement. “... What happened [Wednesdsay] is indicative of a broader cancer in our body politic that we must address. But it must not be addressed with censorship.”

Advertise with us
University of Pittsburgh student Jesse Milston hugs a supporter after a College Republicans at Pitt-sponsored vigil in memory of conservative activist Charlie Kirk on the patio of the William Pitt Union on Friday, Sept. 12, 2025. Mr. Milston is vice president of the organization. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Safety and free speech on campuses

The delicate balance between free speech and safety has been at the forefront for many schools in recent years, with universities seeing a rise in protest, debate and discourse surrounding topics such as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, transgender issues and the 2024 presidential election.

Generally, at public universities such as the University of Pittsburgh and Penn State, registered student organizations are permitted to bring any speaker to campus, as long as these groups follow university policies.

When controversial speakers do arrive on campus, public universities cannot restrict their speech. But campus police also have the responsibility of ensuring that protesters don’t engage in violence.

When speakers come to Penn State, a team that includes event organizers, university police and Student Affairs works together to review event logistics, assess security needs and put measures in place to protect the rights and safety of the campus, speakers, attendees and protesters, spokeswoman Tyra McGarvie said in an email.

Mr. Kirk’s death stands “in direct opposition to the principles of civil discourse and respect that are fundamental to higher education,” she said.

Advertise with us

“Our thoughts are with all of those impacted. To be clear, threats of, or any violence, have no place at Penn State. The university fully supports the fundamental right of free expression. Exposure to different viewpoints, even those that may be difficult, is a critical part of higher education,” Ms. McGarvie wrote.

At Pitt, safety is the university’s “top priority and is embedded in everything we do,” spokesman Jared Stonesifer said.

Pitt conducts “extensive” risk assessments and works with experts and law enforcement agencies to foster a safe environment for campus discourse, he added. He said he could not speak further on specific safety measures.

“Free speech and civil discourse are foundational tenets of higher education institutions,” Mr. Stonesifer said in an email.

Private universities are able to limit campus speech, though many choose to guarantee First Amendment rights to some extent. CMU, for example, allows students to protest and make speeches on campus.

Advertise with us

In a statement Thursday, CMU spokeswoman Cassia Crogan reaffirmed that “free speech and civil discourse without the threat of violence is the hallmark of our American society and critical to our democracy.”

Kirk among those who’ve visited Pa. campuses

Mr. Kirk, 31, who was shot and killed Wednesday while speaking outdoors at Utah Valley University, often traveled to colleges to debate and engage with students in his role as co-founder and CEO of Turning Point USA.

He made an appearance at Pitt in September 2024, before the presidential election. He spoke to students in the Quad, an outdoor space in the center of several dormitories, alongside former Republican presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy.

Dozens of students — mostly young men — gathered around Mr. Kirk and Mr. Ramaswamy in the relatively small space to ask questions and debate Mr. Kirk.

University of Pittsburgh political science major Reuben Rochkind, 23, wrapped an American flag around his shoulders during a College Republicans at Pitt-sponsored vigil in memory of conservative activist Charlie Kirk on the patio of the William Pitt Union on Friday, Sept. 12, 2025. (Lucy Schaly / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

He also spoke at Penn State last year and visited the University Park campus alongside Donald Trump Jr. in 2019.

Advertise with us

His visits to colleges would often draw protests. Since 2021, FIRE documented more than a dozen incidents of students or colleges trying to prevent him from making campus appearances. Prior to Wednesday’s shooting, a Change.org petition attempted to pressure Utah Valley to cancel Mr. Kirk’s visit.

Though his appearances at Pitt and Penn State remained peaceful, some other controversial speakers at the campuses have faced backlash and violence.

The chaotic protest at Pitt in 2023 came in response to a debate between conservative Daily Wire commentator Michael Knowles and gay libertarian journalist Brad Polumbo. Three police officers were injured during the protest.

In 2022 at Penn State, the university shut down a student-hosted comedy show featuring Proud Boys founder Gavin McInnis and comedian Alex Stein after campus protests.

Mr. Cacciato, with the CMU College Republicans, said last week’s killing in Utah seemed to fit a pattern.

Advertise with us

“It strikes a special chord with us here at CMU and Pitt because of the history we have with people like [Mr. Kirk] on our campuses that have come to spread the message of conservatism and have been met with this sort of violent response,” he said.

In July, President Donald Trump attended an artificial intelligence summit hosted by CMU. His visit sparked protest, though all demonstrations remained peaceful.

At the time, CMU President Farnam Jahanian wrote that the opportunity to host the president and other leaders of differing political backgrounds was “consequential.”

“Since Carnegie Mellon’s founding, our university has hosted leaders for discussions that explore issues of significant national and societal importance,” Mr. Jahanian wrote. “Similarly, we have a history of constructively engaging with the federal government and administrations across the political spectrum.”

Students fearing for their safety

When Pitt junior Julia Cassidy learned that Mr. Kirk had died, she said she walked out of class and began shaking.

Advertise with us

At first, Ms. Cassidy, president of Pitt’s College Republicans, didn't understand why she was having such a reaction. She said she quickly realized it was because he was a “rallying force” behind the modern conservative movement on many campuses.

“He is one of us,” Ms. Cassidy said. “That is what we do on our campus. No matter what we thought about him personally or the way he went about doing what he did, the goal of the College Republicans is the same as his — to create a space for dialogue and have conversations.”

Ms. Cassidy said she and other students have feared for their safety on campus since the shooting.

During a pre-scheduled College Republicans meeting Wednesday evening, a police officer was present. The group is also working to meet with Chancellor Joan Gabel to discuss in-person and online incidents of some students celebrating Mr. Kirk’s death, Ms. Cassidy said.

The Carnegie Mellon Fence reads "Rest in peace Charlie Kirk" on Thursday, Sept. 11, 2025. (Lindsay Shachnow / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A group of Pitt students held a vigil for Mr. Kirk on Friday morning. On CMU’s campus, College Republicans painted the Fence — a campus landmark meant to promote free expression — to read “RIP Charlie Kirk” and “Say no to political violence.”

Advertise with us

Ally Aufman, a CMU junior and vice president of the College Republicans, said she was afraid to attend class after Mr. Kirk’s death. She was present at the Butler rally in July 2024  where Trump was shot and an attendee was killed.

“On a campus like CMU, I am fearful of putting my views out there,” she said. “I’ve lost friends and relationships with people … because of the views I have. It’s sad that this is reality, but I won’t stop being who I am.”

Student Democrat groups have also expressed concern over what the fatal shooting could mean for the future of campus political discourse and safety. Mr. Kirk’s death “will not lead us forward,” the College Democrats of Pennsylvania said in a statement.

“...Violence is not how we solve any problems,” the group wrote. “The foundation of democracy is the ability to resolve disputes with laws and elections.”

Ava Hickman, the outgoing president of the Duquesne College Republicans, said she has found her university to be “very pro-safety.”

Advertise with us

Though Ms. Hickman has vocally criticized the private university for being, in her view, too tough on free speech, she said she believes Duquesne “really takes care of their students.”

“It’s moments like this where, even though I disagree with some policy and I want more free speech, I am grateful to go to Duquesne,” she said. “I have never felt physically unsafe on campus.”

Carnegie Mellon freshman Luke Greenawalt said all of the students he has spoken to about the assassination are “on the same page” that college campuses should be a space for political debate.

While Mr. Greenawalt said he wasn’t a “particular fan” of Mr. Kirk’s, he is a fan of free speech.

“Your beliefs should never define whether you get to live or die,” he said.

Advertise with us

Gretchen Chapman, CMU’s department head of social and decision sciences, echoed that.

“It makes us worry about safety on campuses, for sure,” said Ms. Chapman, 60, of Squirrel Hill. “We all go to class and research labs expecting that we’re not going to be met with violence — certainly not gun violence.”

Moving forward

Looking ahead, Mr. Perrino of FIRE said he anticipates colleges and universities will put a greater emphasis on security when controversial speakers come to campus.

But that can’t come at the expense of free expression, he said.

“Administrators must not pass security costs along to speakers or use security concerns as pretext to cancel a speaker’s appearance. They have a moral and legal obligation to redouble their efforts to protect free speech,” Mr. Perrino said.

Advertise with us

“Rewarding threats of violence by taxing speech or silencing speakers will only invite more threats and more violence.”

Ms. Hickman worries that Mr. Kirk’s death will prompt more student groups to hold events virtually. The Duquesne junior — who said she met Mr. Kirk on several occasions, including at Pitt last fall — said in-person forums are important.

“Most of the time, you get a more genuine connection and understanding of other people and their position when you have to look them in the eye and talk to them and tell them about what you think and why you think it — rather than over a computer screen where people will say things that they would probably never say to someone's face,” she said.

In some ways, that keeps things more civil, she said.

“I'm worried that by cutting off this in-person, public forum type of communication, we're only going to get the more toxic online side, which is the angry, mean, radical versions.”

Advertise with us

Ms. Cassidy, at Pitt, said the country can no longer be tolerant of political violence.

“We've seen, over the past three or four years, these incidents keep happening. We saw it on our own campus, we saw the governor's house was [damaged by an arsonist], we've seen our president almost assassinated on live television,” she said.

“Every time, the response has been the same, that we condemn this and then we move on. We don't do anything to change the political climate and the temperature that's continually rising in this country.”

The shooting proves that won’t cut it, in her view.

“If someone like him can be taken down, we are in serious danger. [Mr. Kirk’s death] requires a change in how we respond to these things. We can no longer be tolerant of this behavior and be tolerant of people believing that political disagreement justifies violence.”

Staff writer Lindsay Shachnow contributed to this report.