On Oct. 8 of last year, hundreds of people gathered at the Jewish Community Center in Squirrel Hill in support of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community, and in mourning for the lives lost in the Hamas massacres the day before. Elected officials and candidates from both parties and around the county attended, including Mayor Ed Gainey, U.S. Rep. Chris Deluzio, City Councilwoman Barb Warwick and several state legislators.
Notably missing, though she had been invited, was Pittsburgh’s own member of Congress, Summer Lee.
At last month’s debate in the Democratic primary for Ms. Lee’s seat, she was challenged about her visibility to the Jewish community in the days after the attacks. “I have a job in Washington, D.C.,” Ms. Lee replied. But Oct. 8 was a Sunday, and the next day wasn’t a session day on Capitol Hill.
Squirrel Hill was the place to be. But she wasn’t there.
Act respectable
Summer Lee is hated (I cannot stress this enough) by the erstwhile Democratic establishment for all the same reasons she is adored (I also cannot stress this enough) by Pittsburgh progressives: her unshakable certainty that she is right and that disagreement is malicious; her refusal to compromise on anything she considers a matter of principle; her deep suspicion of the restraints imposed by civility, collegiality and respectability.
“Respectability politics” is a term of art that originated on the left, referring to the way figures from marginalized communities are often required to conform themselves to the majority culture in order to achieve power — which, in turn, undercuts their ability to reform or destabilize that power structure. But the concept has since broadened to include the way all political establishments neuter challengers, from both the left and the right, by stigmatizing anything outside a very narrow range not just of opinions and policies, but of behaviors and habits of speech and dress.
Read More
Criticize John Fetterman’s Carhartt chic? Respectability politics. Turned off by Lauren Boebert’s liaisons? Respectability politics. Uncomfortable with politicians dropping f-bombs or deploying sandbox insults against colleagues? Respectability politics.
Summer Lee is a walking rebuke to respectability politics. She abides by no rules of politics but her own. She does or says nothing just because it’s expected of her.
That’s why she has never lost an election she’s contested. That’s also why she might lose this one.
Picking sides
Anti-respectability politics is in — see Trump, Donald J. — because the respectable middle is seen to have failed. Business as usual delivered foreign boondoggles, domestic gridlock, calcified injustice and cultural chaos. If that’s what respectability gets you, very many Americans believe, to hell with it.
The problem — and this is the case in every single anti-establishment movement, whether political or cultural or religious — is discerning the difference between respectability and, simply, respect.
This is where Summer Lee has disappointed so many people, including many who supported her 2022 campaign. Standing with a grieving community — more specifically, standing with a grieving community of constituents — is not an endorsement of anything or a compromise of any kind. It is respect. It is the job.
This isn’t about Ms. Lee’s views on the conflict in Gaza, or even how she expresses them. As a United States congresswoman, she has a right and a duty to try to influence the use of American funds and power overseas. And for historical and ideological reasons, she has picked a side: Israel is to her an oppressor and by definition an aggressor; Palestine is oppressed, and by definition acts in self-defense.
But while Ms. Lee may be free to pick sides in an international conflict, she isn’t free to pick sides in the community she’s meant to serve, by choosing whose pain matters more than others’.
CAIRless speech
The rift between Ms. Lee and the vast majority of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community widened this week when it came to light that, after stiffing Squirrel Hill, she had accepted an invitation to speak at a Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) event — outside Philadelphia.
CAIR’s reputation goes in and out in American life, but in the wake of the Hamas attacks it’s at a low ebb. The organization’s executive director, Nihad Awad, a donor to Ms. Lee’s campaign, spoke carelessly and seemingly approvingly of the massacre, and despite his attempts at clarification the Biden administration has broken with CAIR.
As for the Philadelphia gala, Ms. Lee was set to share the stage with a spoken-word poet who had only recently described Israelis as “demons” who “hide their horns,” evoking an ancient antisemitic trope. She only canceled after a massive pressure campaign that included Gov. Josh Shapiro and Squirrel Hill’s progressive state representative, Dan Frankel.
We could parse Ms. Lee’s statement on the cancelation, which emphasizes that she dropped out primarily out of concern for the potential negative effects of her appearance on Muslims, but the point is simpler than that: Her inclination was to say yes to Muslims in Philadelphia, and no to Jews in Pittsburgh.
Golden rule
Ms. Lee also attended a community session at the Islamic Center of Pittsburgh, previously run by her chief of staff, Wasi Mohamed. As she should have! As any representative should have.
Pittsburgh’s and Pennsylvania’s Muslim communities have traditionally been ignored by elected officials. And the Jewish community has traditionally been shown great solicitude. Flipping the script, for Ms. Lee, is justice.
On this account, anything else — including clutching pearls at the rhetorical excesses of passionate Palestinian sympathizers — is respectability politics.
She’s wrong. Justice does not mean ignoring and hurting people you believe to have been historically favored. This is particularly true in the case of Jewish people, where the idea that they have been historically favored is both historically inept and the kernel of antisemitism.
The solution, for everyone but especially for an elected representative, is to treat every community’s fears and grief as we’d like our own’s to be treated. That’s not respectability politics. That’s just respect.
Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.