On June 21, a month after she was declared the winner of the Democratic primary for the 12th Congressional District, state representative Summer Lee tweeted a photo of herself with U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib in Ms. Tlaib’s home city of Detroit. She is a member of “the squad,” a group of progressive members of Congress that Ms. Lee has long aspired to join.

The Twitter account for Detroit Action for a New Economy, which hosted the event with Ms. Lee and Ms. Tlaib, retweeted Ms. Lee’s post and added: “Congresswoman Elect @SummerForPA blessed us all with critical insight, analysis & timely motivation to continue building a working class movement for a Detroit we deserve and are owed.”

But Summer Lee had not yet been elected to Congress. And now there’s some doubt she will be.

The United Democracy Project, a PAC affiliated with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) that pummeled Ms. Lee in the primary, is now spending a million dollars on television ads branding her a police-defunding, prison-abolishing radical. And the National Republican Congressional Committee is also investing in the 12th district, which includes all of Pittsburgh, no part of which has had GOP congressional representation since 1953.

Advertise with us

Running in a district Joe Biden won by nearly 20%, it looked like a sure thing for Ms. Lee — and she acted like it. Her fundraising slowed after her bruising primary against the local Democratic establishment’s pick, Steve Irwin, and she didn’t undertake the usual post-primary fence-mending with the party factions that had opposed her. She didn’t think she had to. The primary was the election that counted, and she had won.

But, as I wrote back in May, her results were strikingly divided along geographic lines. She won the vast majority of city precincts, many by wide margins. But Mr. Irwin won huge swathes of the suburbs, including populous municipalities like Bethel Park and Jefferson Hills, sometimes three- or four-to-one. I wondered then if Ms. Lee would be able to consolidate Democratic support in the majority of the district — Pittsburgh only accounts for 40% of the 12th — that had rejected her.

Five months later, you’ll see numerous Josh Shapiro and John Fetterman signs in front yards south of the Monongahela River, but very few for Summer Lee. Yard signs don’t win elections, but in this case it’s notable. That’s because the Democratic Party tradition is for local committee members to place signs in known Democrats’ yards: If a candidate’s signs aren’t appearing, that means the campaign isn’t coordinating with the local committees.

For instance, on the Facebook page of the Whitehall Borough Democratic Committee, photos of a mid-August picnic include Shapiro, Fetterman and even Biden signs for pick-up. Summer Lee signs are nowhere to be seen.

Dave Buchewicz, a member of the South Park Township Democratic Committee, pushed back when I observed this deficit, pointing out that Ms. Lee had appeared at his community’s Democratic picnic and generated a good deal of enthusiasm. But other South Hills Democrats described her campaign’s outreach as at best satisfactory and at worst non-existent, while admitting that Ms. Lee’s unapologetically left-wing politics posed a difficulty among their more moderate voters.

Advertise with us

Despite the campaign’s lack of visibility in the South Hills neighborhoods I frequent, the race seemed typically quiet for a Pittsburgh-based district, and the Lee campaign’s tone of breezy self-assurance convinced me she would win nearly as easily as Democrats usually do.

But something changed in October. The tone of Ms. Lee’s social media presence, and that of her cadre of progressive supporters, shifted markedly from triumphalism to anxiety. Progressive activists suddenly seemed agitated that the establishment figures whom Ms. Lee had so delighted in spurning were not endorsing her campaign. Dark innuendos of a racist conspiracy within the Democratic Party began to spread.

Most of all, the name coincidence — Ms. Lee’s Republican opponent shares the same name, Mike Doyle, as the popular Democrat she’s running to replace — went from a humorous annoyance to a serious crisis. Her campaign and other supporting PACs released ads lambasting the “Fake Mike Doyle” as a fraud. The primary message of the campaign became an extended complaint that running against Mike Doyle 2.0 just wasn’t fair.

Summer Lee, it became clear, was no longer “Congresswoman Elect.” The campaign looked whiny and panicky.

Then the AIPAC money dropped on Halloween weekend. Mike Mikus, a Democratic strategist who has worked with (the original) Mike Doyle, averred that the ad buy was more about “sending a message” to Ms. Lee and other progressive legislators who have spoken approvingly of the Palestinian cause. That may well be. But a million dollars is a lot to spend on an ultimatum. The PAC’s leaders must think there’s at least a chance of winning.

Advertise with us

And some polling data suggests they might be right. The Intercept reports that an internal Lee campaign poll shows her up only 4% on Mr. Doyle. I’ve been told about internal polls on both sides that show it closer. The Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) tried to reset the narrative by releasing a poll Tuesday showing Ms. Lee with a 14-point advantage, but no one I’ve talked to with knowledge of the race, in either party, thinks there’s a double-digit deficit.

Meanwhile, Ms. Lee’s camp is said to have begged the DCCC for help in a race that was never supposed to be close, and for which she didn’t raise enough money to defend herself effectively. The committee has been compelled to invest six figures. And in the final week of the campaign, Mr. Irwin and the outgoing Mr. Doyle have formally endorsed Ms. Lee, after holding each other at arm’s length for several months.

Even the observers most bullish on the new Mr. Doyle’s chances don’t give him better than a coin flip, and his odds are almost certainly worse than that. But if Ms. Lee holds onto this deep blue seat, she won’t swagger into Washington as a mighty progressive champion, as she and her supporters had assumed. Rather, she’ll stumble into Congress indebted to an establishment she has scorned, and vulnerable to challenges from both parties two years hence.

And it won’t be AIPAC’s fault or either Mike Doyles’ fault or anyone else’s fault, but Summer Lee’s.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.