In 2012, the campaign of former state representative Mark Mustio dropped one of the most infamous mailers in recent Pittsburgh political history. Running against businessman D. Raja in a state Senate primary, the Mustio campaign used Mr. Raja’s full given name — Dakshinamurthy — in a transparent attempt to make him seem foreign and un-American.

Mr. Raja prevailed in the primary, which also featured a television ad with the Indian flag superimposed on him, but lost in the general to then-state senator Matt Smith. It was the second of three defeats for Mr. Raja over the course of eight years.

Only in 2023, with the victory of Democrat Dr. Arvind Venkat for a North Hills State House seat, did Pittsburgh’s Indian-American community achieve its first notable electoral victory.

It would be a comforting story to tell that anti-Indian fearmongering was sequestered to Republican intraparty politics, and that Pittsburgh is beyond all that now. This would be historically inaccurate: Mr. Raja’s general election bids were also marked by xenophobia, though more as a quiet undercurrent than a visible wave.

Advertise with us

But more importantly, it would be naive about what’s already happening to Democratic Congressional candidate Bhavini Patel.

Foreign influences

The primary campaign for the 12th Congressional District seat, currently held by U.S. Rep. Summer Lee, will be a study in political irony. For instance, after establishing her career by boldly challenging Democratic incumbents and party-endorsed candidates — and then salting the earth after her triumphs — Ms. Lee and her surrogates are quick to charge Ms. Patel with disloyalty for daring to run against an elected Democrat.

But the most troubling irony of all is how progressives are winding up to deploy tactics typically associated with the political right — specifically, insinuations about foreign influences used against a second-generation non-white American.

The playbook was laid out neatly this week in a hit piece on Ms. Patel’s campaign in the Pittsburgh City Paper: “Bhavini Patel courts out-of-state donors with Hindu nationalist ties and pro-Israel agendas.” The article trades on the idea that solidarity among an immigrant community is politically suspicious, and treats Hindu spirituality as exotic and threatening.

“The call ended with [donor Mihir] Meghani and others saying ‘Jai Shri Ram’ (or ‘hail Lord Ram’) in farewell — this traditional Hindu phrase has more recently been chanted by lynch mobs attacking Muslim Indians,” the City Paper reports.

Advertise with us

This is rather like saying that the takbir — the Arabic words allahu akbar, or “God is greater” — is a traditional Muslim phrase that has more recently been chanted by suicide bombers: It’s true, but the only reason to put it that way is to make its regular use by everyday Muslims seem menacing.

The rise of Hindutva, or Hindu nationalist, ideology in India is certainly troubling, but the alleged connections to Ms. Patel are skimpy and it is hardly an issue in Pittsburgh. The point of the article is clear (it’s right in the headline): Ms. Patel is beholden to her own foreign religious-national community, plus the shadowy influences of another foreign country, Israel.

Strategic xenophobia

You don’t have to take my word for it: That’s exactly how Pittsburgh’s progressive politicos took the piece, too, and they were very pleased with it.

“We should be concerned any time a political candidate cozies up to groups with nationalistic ties and agendas,” wrote Pittsburgh Black Lives Matter founder and Abolitionist Law Center organizer Tanisha Long on X. “[I don’t know] how Bhavini Patel plans to represent voters of PA 12 when she [is] bought and paid for by someone with ties to multiple foreign nationalist groups.”

Ms. Long’s commentary was boosted by Sam Wasserman, former communications manager in the Office of Mayor Ed Gainey and director of communications for Sara Innamorato’s county executive campaign, who now spends his time posting Ms. Lee’s campaign talking points. And the City Paper story was shared by Ms. Lee’s campaign spokeswoman.

Advertise with us

First of all, if this kind of rhetoric were deployed by a Republican — or, for that matter, a moderate Democrat against a progressive opponent — it would be condemned as classic xenophobia. The line of attack clearly plays on the idea that Ms. Patel is insufficiently American to represent Pittsburgh in Congress.

Second, in another irony, this comes the same week video circulated of one of Ms. Lee’s closest allies in Congress, the Somali-American Rep. Ilhan Omar of Minnesota, expressing her allegiance to her home country. This would certainly violate Ms. Long’s test for holding public office, but I doubt she will be joining U.S. Rep. Marjorie Taylor-Greene in calling for Ms. Omar’s ouster.

Because, of course, this is strategic xenophobia, being deployed by progressives who feel immune to criticism and against a successful immigrant community that’s considered fair game.

The need for an enemy

It would be unfair to say that the success of Ms. Patel’s campaign is a litmus test for Pittsburgh’s acceptance of Indian-Americans: There are many reasons Ms. Lee might prevail besides anti-immigrant animus.

But the conduct of the campaign will certainly communicate to the region’s Indian-Americans just how welcome they are here, especially in the new progressive dispensation — and what, if anything, has really changed since the Mustio-Raja ugliness a dozen years prior.

Advertise with us

In the early stages of the primary, the groundwork is clearly being laid for an ugly campaign: Ms. Lee’s homegrown progressivism versus Ms. Patel as a foreign interloper beholden to shadowy Hindu (and Jewish) interests. And, on the other side, Ms. Patel’s more pragmatic progressivism versus Ms. Lee as an out-of-touch radical who cares more about Palestine than Pittsburgh.

It’s a reminder of the immutable nature of politics: It brings out the worst in everyone, and forces loyal partisans into rhetorical positions they would never have previously countenanced.

But perhaps more tellingly, it highlights something that’s always been shared between the fringes of the left and right: the need for a frightening other to serve as the enemy of the good people.

Ms. Patel understood when she decided to run that she was volunteering to be that enemy. What she may not have understood was that she was volunteering her entire community, as well.

Brandon McGinley is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.