I’ve long thought that Fred Rogers was the last great liberal in America. I don’t mean that he was a man of the left or even a supporter of the Democratic Party: I mean that he taught certain values — tolerance, respect, love — that are essential to a thriving democratic society, and managed to do so in a way that crossed all boundaries of religion and ideology, race and class.

In fact, I would say he was the last public figure who really believed — and could convince others to believe — that if everyone lived by these values, we could all live together in peace and justice. He believed and taught that all our differences could be overcome if we just loved each other enough.

That belief, or at least the last person trustworthy enough to make that belief credible, passed away on February 27, 2003.

If Fred Rogers was the last liberal, David McCullough may have been the last American optimist. I don’t mean that he regarded the ambiguous glass as half-full or that he believed this country’s best days were still to come, though both of these were true; I mean that he had an apparently unshakeable confidence that we could take in the entire scope of the American past — its cruelty and its heroism, its injustice and its progress — and remain hopeful about the American future.

Advertise with us

And not only did he believe it; he, like Fred Rogers, could convince others to believe it, too. Republicans and Democrats; men and women; academics and enthusiasts and the merely curious — anyone could pick up a McCullough book or watch a McCullough documentary or listen to a McCullough speech and come away both knowing more about America and loving her more.

That optimism, or at least the last person trustworthy enough to make it credible, passed away on August 7, 2022.

Forgive me for being grim, but you know it’s true. No one talks about love as a unifying value anymore, at least without irony or cynicism. No one talks about “the American spirit” — the title of Mr. McCullough’s recent volume of collected speeches — except as a get-a-load-of-this-guy punchline.

No one thinks Trumpists and woke-ists and LGBTQ activists and America-first evangelicals can all get along if they just respect each other hard enough. No one thinks there’s a Lincoln or a Roosevelt, or even a Kennedy or a Reagan, waiting just offstage, ready to put this humpty-dumpty country back together again.

Of course, just mentioning those names is likely to bring cackles from readers on different sides of contemporary politics. Roosevelt? The man who put America on the road to socialism? Reagan? The man who unleashed the worst of capitalism and consolidated Nixon’s racist Southern strategy? What kind of a drooling idiot thinks these men are worthy, unifying American icons?

Advertise with us

Maybe they are, and maybe they aren’t. You don’t have to agree. The point isn’t to name men who are above reproach — no one is. The point is that every society needs figures and events and ideas it’s considered broadly acceptable to respect, and transgressive to tear down. If there’s nothing and no one it’s safe to believe in, nothing and no one to trust that won’t expose you to mockery, then there’s no foundation for Mr. Rogers’ liberalism or Mr. McCullough’s optimism.

To be sure, these men had their critics, as well: Mr. Rogers was accused of coddling a generation of weaklings by some on the right, Mr. McCullough of whitewashing American sins by some on the left. But that criticism was seen as fringe and, often, performative.

And even if you suspected the critics might not be completely wrong, you knew there was no need to shout it from the rooftops. Harboring doubts about myths and icons is perfectly healthy; so is keeping them to yourself, or sharing them in a way that respects the values those myths and icons convey, and the value they hold for others.

Is it a coincidence that these last two icons of American liberality and optimism came from Pittsburgh? It probably is. But if it isn’t — if there is something distinctive about this part of the world that raises up men like this, men who believe in their bones that with the right application of liberal virtues and learning America really can be great again — it’s precisely because Pittsburgh is always behind the times, always late to adopt new trends and drop old ones.

And, crucially, always convinced that Xanadu is just beyond the horizon, but looking backwards. That may seem like a paradox, but the truth is that if you’re on the cutting edge, there’s nothing to look forward to. There’s only the perpetual dawn of the right now that immediately becomes the benighted past.

Advertise with us

To have an honest optimism, you need to be a little bit behind to take in the entire view, to see what’s good and bad about the past, and what’s good and bad about the proposed future. And there must be real goodness in history, and real goodness in each person, that can be the foundation for that future.

That’s what Fred Rogers and David McCullough, each in their own way, taught millions of Americans. Because if America, and every American, is damned or saved from the beginning, there can be only decline: further wallowing in depravity or further descent from grace. The last two Americans who could convince us otherwise are now gone, and there is no one to replace them.

Brandon McGinley is the deputy editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: bmcginley@post-gazette.com.