On Twitter this past week, it seemed everyone was sharing communiqués from GPT-3, the artificial intelligence chatbot. I spent more time thinking about a distinctive human-to-human exchange on Twitter:

— @bernstein: Counting Crows, Blues Traveler, Hootie and the Blowfish, bands of that nature. I don’t think the vibe they were expressing exists anywhere in the world anymore. Not sure how I’d explain it to my kids if I had to.

— @davidgross_man: These were bands that expressed a joy at having reached the end of history. Throw DMB in there as well. Zero tension, zero need for spiritual exegesis. Fukuyama-core

As a white male child of the 1990s, I listened to these bands a lot in my formative late teenage and early college years. Is David Grossman correct? Is Hootie the soundtrack of the uncomplicated phase of Francis Fukuyama’s “end of history,” the peak of liberal confidence and American power and post-ideological relaxation?

Advertise with us

I’m not so sure, since I’m not sure there’s zero tension or spiritual disquiet in those kinds of songs. Still, something about Grossman’s analysis rings true. It’s not joy at the end of history, exactly, that defines the Hootie-DMB-Counting Crows aesthetic.

Maybe it’s what you might call a sense that ordinary life suffices. That you can have a rich human experience, full of joys and sorrows, without the extreme premodern or 20th-century stuff, war and God and utopia and all the rest. And without racial division, too: The multiracial makeup of the Dave Matthews Band and Hootie and the Blowfish is also important here.

That you can be a fulfilled human person just through the highs and lows of normal-seeming suburban American life. That tropes of early-adult male heterosexual experience such as “the yearning to be famous” or “the awesome girl who lets you down” or just “hanging out with your friends and feeling a little sorry for yourself” are all sufficient for the strong feelings that make up an interesting life. When those feelings get you down, you can be depressed in a way that’s personal rather than existential, that’s just about you rather than about everything that’s wrong with life under late capitalism or whatever.

In which case, the subsequent negative shift in American culture shouldn’t be understood simply as a shift from joy to angst, happiness to unhappiness. It’s been a shift away from the sense that the average American life in both its joys and its sorrows supplies enough meaning to be worth embracing and celebrating.

In its place is a new sense that American normalcy in any form — whether that normal means capitalism or liberalism or secularism or heterosexuality or whiteness or something else — is inadequate or destructive or foredoomed. Even in their sorrows, the singers of the 1990s weren’t awake to just how bleak things really are.

Advertise with us

Which 1990s movies count as “Fukuyama-core”? Not, interestingly, the best movies of the best late-modern year in movies, 1999.

We should have seen the bad days coming. The filmmakers of 1999 did. “Election,” “The Matrix,” “Fight Club,” “The Blair Witch Project,” “Office Space,” “The Talented Mr. Ripley,” even (God help us) “The Phantom Menace” … it’s all there, everything that followed, class anxiety and workplace alienation, end-of-history discontents and internet-fueled hoaxes, disputed elections and virtual-reality prisons, plus a tottering republic waiting for its Palpatine.

Which movies were end-of-history films? The Clinton-era spate of teen romances and sex comedies, definitely — from “Clueless” to “Can’t Hardly Wait” to “American Pie” — pure celebrations of affluent suburban folkways, with carnality and romantic sweetness walking hand in hand. “Forrest Gump,” arguably — maybe a little bit too right wing but basically a celebration of steering your way blithely through ideological storms and coming out rich and blessed on the other side.

“Austin Powers,” definitely — a romp through a post-Cold War world in which the revolutions of the past have yielded an ideal synthesis, freedom and responsibility, a very groovy combination.

And finally, the most Fukuyama-core, 1990s movie of them all: “You’ve Got Mail,” in which anonymous online romance, rapacious corporate capitalism and a fast-gentrifying New York City provide the terrain for an old-fashioned meet-cute romance and cozy domestic bliss. Yes, the movie contains a self-critique, a Cassandra figure — Greg Kinnear’s Luddite boyfriend, railing against the techno-future.

Advertise with us

But Meg Ryan’s character ends up with Tom Hanks’ corporate capitalist, not Kinnear’s internet alarmist, and the spirit of her quirky old-fashioned bookstore is presented as living on inside the Hanks character’s Barnes & Noble-like behemoth, in a children’s department run by her former employee.

As a distillation of the hopeful aspects of the end of history — the best of the eccentric past lovingly preserved inside the consumerism of the present — it’s hard to beat that sequence, all packaged in a movie that remains one of the best examples of the silver age of romantic comedy. Freedom and responsibility, consumer capitalism and eccentricity, internet dating and real courtship … what a time it was.

Never such innocence again.

Ross Douthat is a New York Times columnist. His previous article was “What medically assisted suicide has done to Canada.”