At Pennsylvania’s minimum wage of $7.25 per hour, someone working 40 hours a week will take home about $1,024 a month after taxes but before deductions like health insurance. Given the common wisdom that one should spend no more than 30% of their income on rent, a person making minimum wage here should be looking for an apartment that rents for about $310.
There is nowhere in the Pittsburgh area that offers a studio apartment for that amount of money. I know because I looked. The most promising place I found, listed on Zillow for under $400 a month, turned out to be a detached garage that wasn’t fit for human habitation.
It doesn’t get much better for a family with two minimum wage earners. There were a grand total of nine possible matches (under $650 a month) on the several apartment rental websites I searched. The largest one, a 500-square foot studio in Ambridge, had a wait-list of applicants when I called to ask about the listing.
The average rent in Pittsburgh? According to Apartments.com, someone renting a place to live can expect to pay about $1,204 for a studio, $1,392 for a one-bedroom, and a whopping $1,647 for a two-bedroom unit.
And for an hourly employee, like a food preparer or a warehouse worker, who gets $20 an hour and takes home about $2,650 (again minus taxes but before deductions)? They will pay 45% of their income for a studio.
Life used to be so hard
Despite all this, people make it work. Ashleigh in Wilkinsburg has three roommates to share costs, but she lives in “a rat trap with windows.” (Ashleigh asked that I withhold her last name in order for her to stay on good terms with her landlord).
“I hustle. I do some sewing and tailoring on the side and that, along with my job [at a fast food place], let me get by. But I don’t have kids. Or a husband,” she said. “I’m single and looking, though. I had to write ‘Basically Broke’ on my dating profile — being upfront and honest and all that.”
Ashleigh has been trying to get a better job for three years now. She sends dozens of applications every month and hears nothing back. She only got the job she has because she knew someone who worked there.
“If you don’t know nobody, I have no idea how you get a job in Pittsburgh,” she said. “I’m a good worker. I got no complaints from no one and all these references. But that means nothing without a call back.”
“I’m scared that I’ll be stuck at minimum wage forever. That I won’t be able to get married or have kids. Or afford to buy, or even rent, my own place. I’ll be stuck with my roommates till we die,” she said.
“Good thing we all get along. For now.”
Very, very, very fine house
According to data released by Realtor.com and reported by the New York Post, Pittsburgh rents have increased by almost half since 2019, more than any other major city.
This increase “can be traced back to the pandemic, when Pittsburgh’s relatively affordable housing began attracting renters in search of lower costs and more space — particularly from nearby, high-cost metros like New York City,” Realtor.com Economist Jiayi Xu told the New York Post. “This shift in demand contributed to rising rental prices.”
In a city that has struggled to permit new housing, the surge in rental demand has created competition for all available units and a market favorable to landlords. Especially at a time when affordability issues mean that fewer and fewer people are making the jump from renters to home owners. Apartments, once occupied, tend to stay occupied.
I spoke to an associate at one of the big property management firms in Pittsburgh who told me that 95% of the apartments they manage are currently occupied and over 65% renew their leases. The remaining units are subject to fierce competition and waiting lists.
“We’re not desperate to fill units,” the property manager told me. They have the luxury of weeding out possible bad tenants, using credit reports, background checks, letters of reference, and other tools to make sure they rent to the people most likely to meet their financial obligations. But where does that leave the people who simply cannot afford even the cheapest rent in the worst apartment?
Everything is done
The facts are that most people earning minimum wage in Pennsylvania cannot afford to rent here.
One solution is raising the minimum wage, but in Pennsylvania, that would mean paying people at least $21 an hour, so that they may afford a studio apartment. Another is increasing apartments and housing stock, so that more units are available, decreasing competition.
City and state-wide, there are discussions happening about increasing permitting and construction. There are discussions about increasing the number of below-market-rate units available. There are discussions about increasing the minimum wage to $15. There are discussions about making Housing Choice Vouchers, also known as Section 8 housing, more available to people like Ashleigh. But to renters like her, the discussions all seem to lead nowhere.
“I don’t want subsidized housing. I don’t want affordable housing debates. I want a place to live,” Ashleigh said. “I make minimum wage — why isn’t that enough for me to live on my own? What does ‘minimum’ even mean?”
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Is Pennsylvania a mediocre state or Stacy Garrity a mediocre candidate?”.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.