It’s been a wild few weeks for news, both local and international, yet somehow Pennsylvania Treasurer Stacy Garrity broke through all the noise with an interview on Face the State, broadcast on WHP CBS 21.

Answering a question about the status of her campaign for governor of the Keystone State, she replied with an impish smile, “well, we’re out there, talking to everybody, raising money, making sure that we get the message out there that Pennsylvania is mediocre — and it doesn’t have to be that way.”

“And I think we’ve been mediocre for so many years,” she added, emphasizing the word for good measure, “that people don’t even think about it.”

The comment raised a few eyebrows in social media, especially as Garrity is running for governor of Pennsylvania, and now that State Senator Doug Mastriano has bowed out of the race, she is the (though not endorsed by Mastriano) front-runner for the Republican nomination.

Advertise with us

This means that, unless another Republican steps up at the last minute, Garrity will be running in the general election to unseat a very popular Governor Josh Shapiro, a Democrat who touts the greatness of our commonwealth every chance he can.

I suppose that Garrity’s use of “mediocre” is an oblique critique of Shapiro’s administration. But it comes across less politically savvy than she intended. As one user on Facebook put it, “bold strategy to call the state you want to run ‘mediocre.’”

Or as another wrote, “is she purposely trying to lose?”

Ain’t seen nothin’ yet

“Mediocre” is not a kind word. It’s not a word that anyone wants to be called, despite its dictionary definition of “of moderate quality,” meaning not good but not bad either. Garrity seems to have meant the word this way. Pennsylvania’s okay, but it could be great.

But there’s a difference in tone and delivery between “the Commonwealth is middling, we can do better” and “Pennsylvania is mediocre.”

Advertise with us

I know this because well-over-a-decade ago, I called an ex-boyfriend “mediocre” to his face. I meant it the way Garrity did, in the sense that he had not been a good boyfriend, but not a bad one either. Just average.

To my surprise, he did not see that as a compliment. In fact, I must report, he took much umbrage with it.

No matter how it’s delivered — I understand this now — the word “mediocre” sounds like a rebuke. Maybe because we hear as a statement that we’re “not special,” without distinction, not good enough even to be bad.

Thus many people would rather be insulted than called “mediocre.” My ex-boyfriend would agree.

So is Pennsylvania mediocre? And do we want someone running for governor to publicly describe it that way?

Advertise with us

Need an education

Garrity has not backed down, stating in a podcast interview, a day after her first comments, that “basically Pennsylvania is mediocre, I mean…”

“Even less?” the interviewer asked.

“Yes, less than mediocre,” she replied.

Marketing and public relations are a tricky business. One never knows what campaign slogans will take flight, and which will doom a candidate. Maybe in a meeting, as people were spitballing ideas, political professionals talking to each other, “mediocre” seemed like a good bet.

It sounds like an insult without technically being one, and maybe the spitballers thought this would give Garrity “deniability.” They must have thought voters would take the word as criticism of the governor, not of themselves and their state. They were wrong, as political professionals so often are.

Advertise with us

And Josh Shapiro, and his ever-growing record war chest, will not be defeated by a single word. Garrity needs to bring more to the table if she wants to present herself as a credible challenge. Instead, she comes across as out of touch, disconnected from the issues her voters want her to champion.

Garrity is also in a pickle. She has to run as a MAGA Republican, not even endorsed by her mentor and friend Mastriano, in a national climate informed by unpopular MAGA policies. She has to get around the problem that many of the things that make Pennsylvania mediocre were caused by the party she represents — and that voters know this.

Ain’t been around

Shapiro, on the other hand, has cast himself as an antagonist to President Trump, fighting for Pennsylvanians as they lose health insurance, their savings, and face ever-growing inequality. He’s all about transformation through action. And he clearly loves Pennsylvania.

People know their state has issues. But we also take pride in our state. We think it’s special. It’s distinctive. And if Stacy Garrity doesn’t understand that, a lot of us won’t vote for her.

Pennsylvania is not mediocre. We rank highly for our diverse economy, both in agriculture and manufacturing, our gorgeous scenery as well as our extraordinary food, our diverse and creative people — and that doesn’t even include our amazing history.

Advertise with us

Things could be better. Our national rankings lag when it comes to education, infrastructure and environmental concerns. There are absolutely places we can improve.

Still, we also want a governor who can see the opportunity in our state, who has a vision that goes beyond reporting the negative. Who knows we’re special and wants to build on that in the highest office in the Commonwealth.

That’s the reason Garrity’s chances are looking, dare I say it, mediocre.

Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “The Steelers are the greatest show on television.”

Correction, posted Jan. 10, 2026: The headline has been corrected. It had a misspelling of the candidate’s name.