I’m not one to run a red light, or even speed through a yellow, but sometimes, it’s inevitable. Take an impossible, unprotected left turn on a too-short light cycle, where a car — and the increasing number of cars behind them — may remain stuck at a light for several cycles.
The time between when a light turns yellow and subsequently red, a time I affectionately call “orange time,” is meant to be flexible for a reason. But that doesn’t always make it safe. Accidents occur, and drivers who are not paying attention, or are desperately running red lights when intersecting cars have already started movement, bear the blame.
Many people have lost their lives at dangerous interchanges, pedestrians as well as those in their vehicles. According to Accident Analysis and Prevention, each year in this country running a red light causes roughly 260,000 impacts and 750 deaths.
In an attempt to catch and punish people who run red lights, states and municipalities have turned to red light cameras, often subcontracted to companies who issue citations to anyone caught in an intersection when it’s red.
City Council first voted to install red light cameras in 2013, but it’s not until now, as a part of Mayor Ed Gainey’s “Vision Zero” strategy to eliminate traffic fatalities, that the cameras are going up all over town.
The problem? No one is actually sure if red light cameras actually help.
Going the distance
Automated traffic enforcement seems like a good solution to the problem, a way to deter bad drivers from bad behavior. But like all solutions, there are trade-offs.
The cameras are expensive, but the corresponding citations, capped at $100, should minimize the overhead, with further proceeds sent to PennDOT’s Motor License Fund. According to the City of Pittsburgh’s website, police officers will be reviewing each violation and “validating” it before sending it to the address of the vehicle’s owner.
This makes citations difficult to appeal, but might be worth it, as according to a study out of Virginia, red light cameras reduce light-running violations by up to 67%.
Still — those reductions do require a bargain with the surveillance state, possibly giving the government yet more information about our movements. It can also be a money-generating scheme, that cities believe works because they make money on it.
Lon Anderson, a former spokesman for AAA Mid-Atlantic, told the Washington Post that red-light cameras generate more revenue for cities than they care to admit: “They are making a heck of a lot of money, and they are picking the motorists' pockets on the pretense of safety,” he said.
It doesn’t help that the primary evidence of a violation is a pixelated photograph of a license plate on the back of the vehicle. There’s a lot those photographs do not show, including the face of the driver, traffic conditions, and weather. One could be unsure if there’s something blocking a vehicle, or if the car began going through the intersection while the light was still green.
Wilmington, N.C., shut down its red light camera program after protests brought into question the legal authority of enforcing such fines, given that the images never captured the driver. So did Suffolk County in New York, despite local claims that the cameras caused a significant reduction in fatalities.
Going for speed
But as Justin Gallagher, an Assistant Professor of Economics at Case Western Reserve University, pointed out in his Scientific American article, “Red Light Cameras May Not Make Streets Safer,” a decrease in people running red lights is not necessarily a decrease in accidents.
He referred to a study he did with another that looked at all police-recorded traffic accidents for three large Texas cities over a 12-year period – hundreds of thousands of accidents,” Gallagher writes.
“We found no evidence that red light cameras improve public safety. They don’t reduce the total number of vehicle accidents, the total number of individuals injured in accidents or the total number of incapacitating injuries that involve ambulance transport to a hospital,” he continues.
The initial reduction in t-bone accidents is offset by an increase in rear-ending accidents. People trying to avoid a citation end up causing more damage than if they’d simply sped on through the orange light.
“The elevated number of traffic accidents at urban intersections is a serious public health issue,” Gallagher goes on to say. “But our study shows that Houston’s camera program was ineffective in improving traffic safety. Electronic monitoring is not the solution.”
Hugging the turns
But more and more cities are installing these cameras, claiming the opposite. So which is it? How do we know who to trust on this?
As reported by Spotlight PA, a 2016 study of programs in 79 U.S. cities including Philadelphia by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, “found the cameras reduced the rate of all types of fatal crashes at intersections with signals by 14%.”
I hope that these statistics carry over to Pittsburgh. Because, as Councilwoman Erika Strassburger, D-Squirrel Hill, told TribLive in August, “we have to take strong measures like this that will, for some people, feel unpopular.”
“But this is about saving lives.”
Okay. But only as long as it actually works.
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “What happened to Democrats?”.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.