After his visit with just-about-to-be president Donald Trump in Mar-a-Lago, many members of Pennsylvania Sen. John Fetterman’s base are confused. Why would a Democrat who relied on progressives to be elected be making nice with Trump?
He recently signaled his support for some of Trump’s Cabinet picks (for Ambassador to the United Nations and Secretary of Agriculture) when Democrats are reflexively voting against anyone the incoming administration supports. Combine this with his distinctly more conservative stances on immigration and Israel, and many of his supporters are feeling betrayed. The most charitable reading I’ve heard from my liberal friends is “perplexed.”
But perhaps Fetterman is playing a different game altogether. As he has stated repeatedly, he represents all Pennsylvanians, not just the liberal faction that launched his political career. And assuming that he isn’t going full Independent, or, dare I say it, Republican, he might be modeling a new strategy for dealing with Trump in the next four years.
Instead of imagining that Fetterman is being pushed to the right, let’s imagine a world where Fetterman is the one doing the pushing. Why not have someone who cares deeply about workers and farmers in the president’s ear, countering all those billionaires who already have it?
Maybe, just maybe, something incredible is afoot. That’s right, Dems. It might be time to invite El Jefe to the cool kids table.
You’re simply the best
Legacy matters to Donald Trump. He wants to be remembered as the best — he wants to be beloved, and not just by the MAGA faithful. Otherwise, he wouldn’t lie about his crowd sizes, he wouldn’t rewrite history about Jan. 6, and he wouldn’t couch everything he says and does in superlatives.
In 2022, CBS published a ranking of all U.S. presidents, based on a “sweeping survey of historians, political scientists and presidential scholars maintained by Siena College Research Institute.” Trump ranked 43rd, just ahead of Andrew Johnson (first president to be impeached) and James Buchanan (who helped cause the Civil War).
The best Trump has done in any historian-driven ranking is 41st (C-SPAN). Meanwhile, Obama’s worst rank is 18, with Biden’s at 19. So while winning the presidency might have been the only way for Trump to avoid jail time, it’s also a second chance for him to do a better job as president in the eyes of historians.
And here’s the thing, no matter how much people want to hate on Vice President Kamala Harris as a candidate, her policy ideas polled well across the political spectrum. Raising the minimum wage, working towards single-payer healthcare and ensuring protections for farmers and workers are popular policies with all Americans.
Trump, a man with a concept of a plan, might as well steal those and say they were his all along. Why not? He’s a master at rewriting history.
And if he’s going to follow the advice of the last person in his company, the nation needs advocates for working Americans instead of endless Tech Bros in his inner orbit.
Give me a lifetime of promises
Some Democrats want The Donald to fail. It serves their reelection efforts and future campaigns if Trump remains one of the worst presidents in history and if his policies hurt average Americans. But it might be time to put aside their egos and seize the day, fight for democracy and help our country and, yes, our president win.
As the inauguration approaches, everyone will want to figure out What It All Means. But Trump has always demonstrated himself to be more of a changeable chimera than an intractable goat. And because he cannot run for reelection, he has no need to fulfill any of his promises. Also, there’s no reason to assume any Republicans will fight against his desires, whatever they may be.
As the Pete Hegseth nomination for Secretary of Defense has demonstrated, Republicans refuse to oppose Trump, no matter what insane idea he has. For example, let’s put someone in charge of a massive bureaucracy who has never successfully run a small bureaucracy.
Why not take advantage? No matter how leftist a policy might seem, I cannot imagine a world where Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Tx.) votes against Trump’s agenda, even if it’s Healthcare For All (Trumpcare, anyone?).
Better than all the rest
Look, I’m not imagining Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Ma.) sitting down for tea with Trump anytime soon. But I think little inroads help: A good laugh with Barack Obama, a hangout with Fetterman. Maybe AOC could include him in a group chat?
Trump opened a door by requesting a meeting with Fetterman. For all I know, this might be about offering Fetterman a sweet appointment in the new administration. The senator might be courting a new base, after disappointing his own, in order to ensure reelection in 2028. This could be the beginning of Fetterman’s rightward ascent in the MAGA universe.
But, knowing Fetterman’s values over the years, and his votes in Congress, I still believe otherwise.
Trump recently called Fetterman “a commonsense person,” praising the Senator as “not liberal or conservative.” Maybe, just maybe, a version of Trump that hangs with the opposition could become a little more commonsense himself, a little less a creature of politics, and the president that historians, and all Americans, can finally praise as “the best.”
Adriana E. Ramírez’s previous column was “Let’s talk about debt, baby.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.