It’s the first week of school, and my first-grader has already come home for a half-day due to the weather. Old infrastructure, dwindling funds and a lack of imagination have created this utterly predictable situation that disrupts students, teachers, parents and their places of employment for no good reason.

And as the district considers proposals from consultants who are getting paid a quarter million dollars to point out the obvious, while calling it an “equity study,” I’ve decided to propose some solutions of my own.

BNY Mellon Wayside

The BNY Mellon Center downtown will likely be empty and available in the near future. It’s a 54-story building that is difficult to convert to non-commercial use (consider that it only has plumbing for two large bathrooms on any given floor). Retrofitting it into apartments in infeasible — but it wouldn’t be that hard to turn it into a school, for a year or so, while PPS figures out how to renovate, reallocate or re-envision the district.

Why not a massive tower of education to rival the Cathedral of Learning? It’s ridiculous, but it could actually work. Buses from every neighborhood in the city go into Downtown, so older kids could take advantage of public transportation. An efficient school bussing plan to different neighborhoods for younger students would be easy to implement, as the tower already has loading docks and garages.

Advertise with us

Specialty classrooms and stages can be assembled within the tower. Athletes and sports teams can be transported to fields, tracks and courts when necessary, and there are enough parks Downtown that physical fitness classes would not be too difficult to arrange. Security is easily handled. There are corporate kitchens downstairs and ample parking for all faculty and staff.

Harper Collins

Some readers might recall the Wayside School books by Louis Sachar, which took place in a building that was accidentally built tall instead of wide, so ended up with 30 stories of hijinks and hilarity. BNY Mellon Wayside could be an act of great imagination brought to life. It could help revitalize Downtown and take advantage of the infrastructure we already have.

And the BNY Mellon tower is air-conditioned.

Cooling heads

The heat isn’t the biggest problem that the district faces. But how the district has dealt with the lack of air conditioning at dozens of its schools is emblematic of other concerns. I know for a fact that many people have presented ideas about shortening the school year, from Labor Day to Memorial Day, as well as moving students to portable, outdoor classrooms on hot days. All suggestions have seemingly gone ignored.

Hot days are predictable. As a PPS parent, I received information about this possible closure well in advance. And while I appreciate this, as it allows me to plan better, there will only be more hot days. Which is to say: Most of PPS’s problems have been easier to predict than the weather.

Advertise with us

I do agree with the district on one thing: Change has to happen. It will be painful. But it should be done in a way that is mindful of the advantages we do have. Small classroom sizes are not a bad thing — with a little imagination, PPS could take an example from its most popular K-5 magnet, Pittsburgh Montessori, and create more neighborhood schools that use the Montessori method.

But siloing off the only school that has a 77% reading success rate in a district that hovers in the mid-30s is not the solution. Instead, its wins should be replicated. Our magnet schools might not be providing the intended equity, and they might be creating transportation nightmares, but that’s not a reason to end the programs. It’s a reason to bring these kinds of programs to every school.

A city without children

Bar charts of Pittsburgh’s dwindling child population have been circulating on social media this week. Some neighborhoods are down 90% from the 1960s, when suburban flight began in earnest. Since then, people who live in the city have often moved to the suburbs when they have children. They want bigger houses with lawns and garages — and access to better schools.

It’s a vicious cycle: People leave, which worsens the schools, which makes people leave. Couple that with the fact that fewer people are having children, and that those who do and stay in the city often choose home, charter and private schools instead, and we’ve ended up with a perfect storm: more schools than children to fill them, plus the schools are falling apart and there’s not enough money to fix them.

Condensing to one giant school doesn’t sound so bad right now, does it?

Advertise with us

The BNY Mellon Wayside School for All Students might be a silly idea. But it’s an idea — and right now, it feels like there’s a shortage in the idea supply. The consulting firm did a good job of coating the obvious in a veneer of social justice jargon, but it offered no creative solutions. School closures and consolidations will only create more equity issues if they continue as planned, something passionately pointed out by many parents at last Monday’s meeting.

Underneath all the duress, there’s a real opportunity. But I’m worried PPS is more focused on avoiding failure than it is on replicating success. Poorly thought-out closures and consolidations will only exacerbate the issues that created these problems in the first place.

It’s time to listen to parents. Who knows? The craziest idea might not be as crazy as it first seems.

Previous column: “Don’t fear: Immigrants love America and want to make it better.”