“Immigrants are a huge problem” a woman said to me in line at the convenience store this morning, after asking me if I spoke English. When I replied in the affirmative without an accent, only looking amused instead of offended, she felt the need to continue explaining.
“They don’t all speak English like you,” she offered again. “And they commit so many crimes.”
I said nothing and vaguely shifted my weight. I just wanted to pay for my caffeine.
“They say it on the news,” she said, unable to stop herself. “They’re killing American citizens, the immigrants. Not you. I don’t mean you.”
Exhaustion and frustration
There is a problem with using “immigrants” as shorthand for potentially criminal noncitizens. By using the umbrella term “immigrants,” that includes people like me, people who arrived in this country legally as infants and became U.S. citizens during their childhood.
I have never been undocumented. But even if I had been, even if that had been the only path available to my parents, who wanted a chance at something better, that would not increase my chances of being a criminal. In fact, it would decrease them.
The CATO Institute, a libertarian think-tank, found in 2019 that undocumented immigrants were 37.1% less likely to be convicted of a crime than U.S. citizens. There has been absolutely no credible link established between immigration surges and rising crime or incarceration. Yet, this woman will tell me three more times before I get to the register, “they’re killing Americans.”
I can only sigh in exhaustion and frustration. I could argue back, but I only do so in my head. There are only individual cases. There is no wave. There is no pattern. There are bad actors in bad situations, and overall there are proportionally fewer than the bad actors in bad situations who happen to have their paperwork in order.
There is one clear reason undocumented immigrants prefer to stay quiet and under the radar: Non-citizens risk deportation in addition to incarceration. Most fled their home countries, and the last thing they want is a negative encounter with law enforcement. Why would anyone escape to America, endure the dangerous and expensive journey, only to commit crimes that would get them sent back?
Irrelevant facts
But logic won’t matter. Every day there are more and more people who believe that immigrants, in this country legally or illegally, are the problem. Most of those people live far away from the southern border, have never been to the border, and cannot tell the difference between Afghanistan and Arizona on YouTube.
In the parking lot outside, the woman approached me again. I grabbed my keys tightly and did my best to hurry to my vehicle.
“I’m not racist,” she said, following me. “I’m just worried about my country.”
“Have a nice day,” I replied. “I wish you the absolute best.” And I did. I still do. She kept talking.
I’m glad I don’t have to live with her fear. I believe in border control, but I also believe in legal pathways to citizenship for good people. I think immigrants bring diverse viewpoints and diverse political beliefs, to our benefit. I also know that a few years in, most immigrants have assimilated and become as proud to be an American as anyone with roots dating back to the Mayflower.
I say this because I am proud to be an American, and I’m raising my children to be even prouder.
Harmless and wildly patriotic
I also know that cities like Pittsburgh are dying, and new immigration can solve that. Immigrants are more likely to be language teachers, nurses, translators and to do other work crucial to making a city function. Immigrants, both legal and otherwise, are not here to take anyone’s jobs; they’re here to do the jobs that no one else is doing as we face shortages across essential fields.
Most people in this city are descendants of people who were once unwelcome, even as they did their part. A kind man in the parking lot of the convenience store reminded the woman of this, as she persisted in trying to speak to me.
“My grandpa was Irish,” he said. “No one wanted him here. They called him a criminal. They told him to go back. And he didn’t.”
“That was legal,” the woman replied. “They weren’t doing it illegally then. We can’t just let everyone in.”
“My grandfather snuck over in a ship as a stowaway and then jumped into Boston harbor and swam ashore without a dollar or a paper in his pocket. Ain’t nothing legal about that.”
I love this city. I love this strange man who chimed in. I even love this woman, who I think wanted me to tell her that it was okay to be afraid, something I could never do. I will always look to facts before fear. And the facts are that most immigrants are not criminals. Most of them are exactly like me: harmless and wildly patriotic about their adopted homeland.
I believe in America, but to me, that also means believing in the immigrants who made it, and who will keep doing so.
Previous column: “A tale of two conventions.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.