The price of Florida orange juice reached an all-time high last month, up about 33% from the beginning of the year. Supply is simply not meeting the demand — Florida, which at one point produced almost 250 million boxes of oranges each year, can now barely pack up 45 million.
Florida weather in the anthropocene, including some unprecedented cold freezes, and “citrus greening,” a plant disease that destroys citrus crops, are the main culprits. Corporate consolidation and residential land development also play a part.
And, thanks to Florida’s harsh immigration laws, there also simply aren’t enough workers to pick the fruit.
Penalizing workers
In 2023, Gov. Ron DeSantis championed SB1718, which, among other draconian measures, penalizes businesses that hire more than 25 undocumented workers.
Most of these businesses are in construction and agriculture, but hotels and restaurants and others have been affected. In the law’s first year, the state has lost an estimated $12.6 billion in income, as thousands of immigrants, including farmworkers, have been forced to leave.
“About 42% of Florida’s agricultural workers are undocumented,” Elizabeth Ricci, a Florida-based immigration attorney, told News4JAX in Jacksonville. “So when those workers leave the state, then there are fewer workers to harvest those crops, which is going to make those prices increase.”
“A lot of people are scared,” says Fidel Sanchez, a Florida berry farmer quoted by NPR. “A lot of people went north and never came back.” Some left as soon as the law passed. “The government doesn’t seem to care. Maybe they think the crops are gonna pick themselves.”
So who do we get to pick our fruit? (And fix our roofs – a big need in Florida, thanks to the hurricanes – along with other difficult jobs?)
According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, in 2020, only “30 percent of crop farmworkers were U.S. born, 6 percent were immigrants who had obtained U.S. citizenship, 23 percent were other authorized immigrants (primarily permanent residents or green-card holders), and the remaining 41 percent held no work authorization.”
“Authorized immigrants” also includes workers with H-2A visas, temporarily importing workers from abroad in picking season. This program requires a costly and time-consuming application process, which many smaller farmers can’t afford. It also raises the costs of harvesting the oranges, which raises the price when the juice finally gets to us.
Not good enough
Florida employs well over 50,000 guest workers annually, and while these workers have helped alleviate — though not eliminate — the personnel shortages, new problems have emerged.
“It’s like I’m good enough to come pick your fruit, to pay taxes and to break my body — but I’m not good enough to be your neighbor,” Juan Zamora, a legal and seasonal worker currently in Florida, told me in an interview in Spanish.
His boss, an American named Michael, who asked for his last name to be withheld, told me he knew other farmers who abuse their workers, often factoring in the built-in penalties.
“Some growers would rather break the rules — underpay and overwork, not house properly, or give promised water breaks. [They don’t] care for their workers and treat their staff like [expletive] slaves,” Michael said, quoting the very-true statistics that overcrowding violations and fatalities are increasing.
“When [farmers] get caught, they don’t change. [They] just pay the fines to keep those boxes moving out,” he said. “We do things differently here, but it’s more expensive to do things the right way.” The juice companies he sells to complain constantly about his prices.
Some Florida farmers are taking advantage of child labor laws, which allow children as young as 12 to work legally on farms. Some orange juice companies are considering switching to imported fruits from Mexico, China and Brazil.
There’s also the issue that mandarin oranges grown abroad don’t taste like our Florida-grown Valencia and Navel oranges. Are we prepared to forget the taste of American orange juice?
Or, if we want to do things right and according to the letter of the law, are we prepared for oranges, as well as blueberries, strawberries, mushrooms and tomatoes, to become luxury goods? Or should we subsidize all agriculture?
We cannot help the weather or disease. But we can do something about immigration laws.
Expensive principles
And as orange juice prices continue to soar, we have to ask ourselves: how much are we willing to pay for our xenophobia? What does a fair and lawful world look like, and how much will it cost us to remain true to our stated values?
Florida was a test-case, an answer to the question, and the result is clear: it will cost more than we realize.
The dirty secret of the discourse around undocumented immigration today is that we want to reap the benefits while labeling necessary workers as “invaders” and “terrorists.” In the case of many Floridians, who continue to blame the federal administration for the rising cost of orange juice, this is exactly and precisely what they voted for. Drink up before it’s gone.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “The battering ram that never was.” Find her on X: @zadri.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.