One of the problems with living in the age of rampant misinformation is that it’s hard to know which news sources to trust, especially when it pertains to events still unfolding. Social media, which is highly subjective by nature, can provide the most immediate information, but it’s up to individuals to decode the various biases inherent to each observer. And in the age of amateur, and thus untrained, journalists on the ground, it’s easy for anyone to get it wrong.
Take the Pittsburgh Palestine Solidarity encampment that formed at the University of Pittsburgh last weekend. As reported by the Pittsburgh Scanner account on X on Monday, a police officer on the scene at the Cathedral of Learning on campus called into the emergency radio channels that “the protesters are attempting to break down the doors of cathedral [sic] with a battering ram.”
The tweet, which was seen by roughly a quarter million people, generated outrage at first. People called for the agitators to be arrested, made wry comments about “peaceful” protests and complained about Kids Today. But then, something curious happened. No images of a battering ram ever emerged.
Lacking evidence
Videos and images of the protest certainly existed. Many depicted protesters pushing back against the police as they were hemmed in.
I saw police preventing the delivery of food and water to the encampment. I saw grown adults yelling expletives at officers, who cavalierly flashed weapons and batons. I saw acts of violence on both sides. I also saw images of people praying and of officers trying to be reasonable in the face of vitriol incarnate.
But, even though dozens of cameras were on at any given time, there was no documented moment this writer could find that showed anyone “attempting to break down the doors.”
Speaking of those doors, there are four doors at that ingress, two of which only open from the inside and swing outward, with no possibility of being rammed in. The third is a revolving glass door, and how would you ram a revolving door? The fourth is a wheelchair entrance, also opening outward – but were the protesters really going to smash that one?
As the lack of evidence became apparent, commenters underneath Pittsburgh Scanner’s post began to sing a different song. One sensible user noted that “I’m a scanner listener at home, and while I understand that what you’re reporting is *what they’re saying on the scanner* not *an actual account of what is occurring* I don’t really think most of your audience understands that.”
The rest began to accuse Pittsburgh Scanner of purposely spreading misinformation, of being a mouthpiece for the police and of lacking integrity. “Why are you spreading these lies,” one person wrote. “Do you really hate people this much?”
Spreading lies
Keats once wrote that “beauty is truth,” and in this case, both are in the eye of the beholder.
A local talking head posted a video online, declaring that it showed “police square off with protesters after several try to force their way into Cathedral of Learning using a barricade as battering ram.”
The video actually shows police blocking students from getting bottles of water as well as students pushing back against the barricades the police erected to keep the protest contained.
The same video has been posted to various accounts, in some cases to support the accusation of the Battering Ram Theory and in some cases to debunk it. Local amateur internet detectives cannot enhance it enough to prove anything definitively.
Still — as I grabbed a coffee in East Liberty yesterday, I overheard two people behind me talking about the battering ram.
“You have to admit, there’s something awesome about those protesters going medieval on the Cathedral of Learning. It already looks like a castle!”
Confirmation bias
As the reasonable person mentioned above, Pittsburgh Scanner does nothing but repeat what the police report. I follow the account, because I enjoy reading about the silly things that happen in Pittsburgh, although someone recently brought to my attention that I might be laughing at people with serious mental health issues, and now I’m rethinking everything.
We’re allowed to rethink, to change our minds, to do our best to cut through all the misinformation and bias while still staying informed. For a few hours last Monday, I also believed that protesters used a battering ram in an attempt to breach the Cathedral of Learning.
But the more I considered it, as well as the many entrances and exits of the building, and the impossibility of holding it, I realized that it’s simply a story that the police told to best describe how it felt to be there in the moment.
It was never meant to be news.
I’ll probably keep following Pittsburgh Scanner, but I’m certainly more aware of its sources and subjectivity. And, if that video emerges showing a barricade being used to shatter a revolving door, I’ll be the first to reconsider my position.
We live in an era of extreme confirmation bias, where everyone is simply looking to validate their worldview. But we have to be open to the possibility that we were wrong the whole time.
Or else it just becomes battering rams, all the way down.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Her previous column was “Convict Trump’s obsession with Hillary Clinton.” Find her on X @zadri.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.