The pop star, now forty-one years old and still one of the best-selling musicians in the world, is going through another divorce. And once again, social media and news outlets are examining Britney Spears’ actions like she’s a criminal in an episode of CSI: Hollywood.
Britney Spears was the first celebrity of my generation to fall apart — publicly, riotously, dangerously. She paid the price for it, too, losing autonomy for thirteen years. But she emerged, free to make her own mistakes again. She flirted with losing it all and survived, despite the world thinking her pretty much insane.
“Britney,” as so many women my age call her, matters to us. She’s still able to sell magazine covers, and the paparazzi still find her a worthwhile “get.” Even though most folks cannot remember the last time she debuted an original song on the radio, her split from an irrelevant backup dancer still dominates headlines.
Never a big fan
I was never a big Britney Spears fan, but I relate to her more than I care to admit, and I can sing more of her hits than I should dare admit in a public forum. I even went to see her in concert once.
My best friend from college and I trekked over to watch her perform during her residency at Planet Hollywood in Las Vegas, back in January of 2017, when the world seemed only slightly doomed. We dressed in our best late-1990s gear and too-much eyeliner, had dinner at a too-expensive restaurant, and took to our seats with too-girlish screams in our throats.
Read More
I bought an overpriced wand that changed colors. I waved it around like a manic conductor as I belted out almost every song along with every other person in the audience. It was joyous and pure — like being in a cult that worships glitter and corsets.
The songs are good, catchy even, but they aren’t transcendentally amazing, and neither are the lyrics. The sexual politics of her 1998 smash debut hit, “... Baby One More Time,” were more about Britney Spears in a schoolgirl outfit in the music video than they were about any of the sadomasochistic words she sang. The phrase “hit me, baby, one more time” is more “yikes” than empowering.
Very human flaws
But Britney remains an entertainment and tabloid juggernaut. Why are we so obsessed with her? Why can’t we leave her alone — and why can't she leave us either?
Perhaps the thing that keeps so many of us interested in the minutia of her existence, are her very human flaws, as well as her descent from “girl next door” to “cautionary tale.” In most interviews, Ms. Spears is wearing sweatpants, pajamas, or cheerleading shorts. She speaks in a Southern drawl and occasionally, and proudly, declares that she’s a little backwoods.
She experienced her first major heartbreak in front of the whole world (who can forget Justin Timberlake’s “Cry Me a River”), she married some boy from her childhood for fifty-five hours before it was annulled, and then promptly turned and married the first of two backup dancers.
She stumbled through a performance at the Video Music Awards, incited speculation that she was a lesbian, and flashed her lack of underwear to the world. In the late aughts, a crazy, umbrella-wielding and bald Britney Spears had a meltdown in front of TMZ.
Too many people see themselves in her struggles. No, we haven’t all been in a conservatorship, stripped of our rights and income by an abusive parent, but so many people I know have felt out of control, and with the rise of social media coinciding with our nascent adulthood, so many of us know the feeling of being suddenly watched after a childhood of shameless freedom from scrutiny.
Taking control
Ms. Spears has an active social media presence and a memoir coming out soon. She’s not choosing to hide. In posting her own photographs and in telling her own story, she’s retaking control of her narrative.
Artists like Madonna and Beyoncé elevate their lives into art. There is a distance there, a disconnect between the artist and what she owes her audience. People don’t worry about Madonna or Beyoncé the way they worry about Britney Spears — both artists seem to be fully aware and in charge of their careers and trajectories, unlike Britney who seems forever fragile and in need of our care.
Britney’s might not be the story we want, of a pretty girl from Louisiana who sings “real good" and finds redemption. It might be messy. We might not understand it. But our own stories aren’t exactly the stories we want. They’re messy and we can’t say we completely understand them. Few pop stars will embody the dreams, failures, and ambitions of a generation the way that Britney Spears still does.
Adriana E. Ramírez, author of “Dead Boys,” is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.