In 2004, Mexican film director Serio Arau released his first film, the English-language “A Day Without a Mexican.” The mockumentary is a little heavy-handed, but it chronicles what happens in California after a deep mist surrounds the state, causing all 13 million Hispanic people to disappear into thin air.
The predictable happens: lovers awaken to half-empty beds, a rich Senator must make his own breakfast and oranges begin to rot without workers to pick the fruit. The state descends into chaos.
Mr. Arau, famous for being the son of Alfonso Arau (director of “Like Water for Chocolate” and the actor who portrayed the infamous El Guapo in “Three Amigos”), cares deeply about legacy, and the question at the heart of the film is simple: Why don’t Americans love undocumented immigrants, when these exact same people do so much for Americans?
A scene in the film makes this point clearly. A talking-head type points out that undocumented Latinos cost the state of California $3 billion a year. He repeats how big the amount is and how that affects the California tax payer, and then he notes that undocumented Latinos contribute $100 billion a year to the state’s GDP. He then looks directly at the camera and says something like “$97 billion profit on undocumented labor is pretty good, don’t you think?”
This remains true. PBS confirmed it in 2018: “Fact: Immigrants contribute more in tax revenue than they take in government benefits.” The Federation for American Immigration Reform calculates that undocumented immigrants cost the U.S. taxpayer $151 billion a year. But, according to the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine, they added $2 trillion to the country’s GDP in 2016, with the number only increasing every year.
A $1.849 trillion profit on undocumented labor is pretty good, don’t you think?
Read More
Undocumented immigrants — mostly Latinos but increasingly from other parts of the world too — come to the United States to work. They come for jobs, not handouts. They contribute to the economy.
And they’re less dangerous than other groups. According to a study by University of Wisconsin-Madison researchers, “compared to undocumented immigrants, U.S. citizens were twice as likely to be arrested for violent felonies in Texas from 2012 to 2018, two-and-a-half times more likely to be arrested for felony drug crimes, and over four times more likely to be arrested for felony property crimes.”
But undocumented immigrants are an easy scapegoat. They are the “other,” a bogeyman, people who push their way into our country to replace good, hard-working Americans. It’s easier for politicians to blame “the invasion” of undocumented immigrants than to be held accountable for not solving the real problems that affect their constituents.
And they play upon ignorance. Research indicates that worry about the border in this country is inversely proportional to proximity — which is to say, the further you are from the southern border, the more likely you are to be afraid of what’s happening there.
In Florida right now, Gov. Ron DeSantis is playing with fire. He recently signed legislation forcing business-owners who hire large crews to provide electronically verified documentation. Social media is already full of videos of empty fields with unpicked food, desolate corporate construction sites, and half-finished housing developments. It’s almost like a mist descended over Florida and suddenly, poof, the undocumented, mostly Latinos, disappeared overnight.
The economic impacts will be huge. Most Americans were content to use the undocumented as hypothetical villains, pretending a wall was enough to defeat someone with a ladder and that hiring more border patrol agents would keep out all the people who want to come in.
The truth is that “the crisis at the border” is nonexistent and manufactured by political figures to scare people into voting for them, by making them fear people they should not fear. The problems in our country were not caused by immigrants and getting rid of them will not solve them — sealing the border will cause more problems than most people realize.
We need the undocumented. Our economy depends on them, and they can’t be replaced. I’m not suggesting an open-door policy, but I am suggesting we stop villainizing people who contribute more than their fair share.
Right now, the state of Florida should be preparing for an economic crisis. Yes, the state will stop providing services to undocumented Latinos and will save taxpayers’ money. But the dearth of workers will cause produce prices, especially oranges, to skyrocket. Labor costs on all construction sites and housing developments will also escalate brutally. Restaurants and tourism will also suffer without undocumented workers. Taxpayers will pay in other ways than taxes.
Sergio Arau’s mockumentary was meant to be a playful warning, not a harbinger of what’s to come. Maybe we should start loving the people who actually allow this country to be great? At the very least, we should be trying to keep orange juice more affordable!
Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist and InReview editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous article was “To address gun violence, we first have to agree that something is wrong.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.