The first time Texas Governor Greg Abbott had his minions load up a bus with migrants and ship them from Texas to the East Coast, there was a certain bravado to it, a point to be had.

There has been a huge influx of migrants from around the world legally seeking asylum in the United States, it’s true. And most of them are coming through the southern border, also true.

Abbott’s point was that states like Texas bear a disproportionate burden in the processing and handling of migrants, both legal and undocumented. He’s not wrong. States that border Mexico spend more money on migrant services, including schooling, WIC benefits and SNAP benefits.

But Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California also benefit from their immigrant populations — and I don’t just mean the good Mexican food. The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities outlines all the economic benefits of immigration: Immigrants work harder, work longer, and are more likely and willing to move to places that need workers. Immigrants are younger, will take unpopular job, and have children that are able to rise in social class and contribute even more.

Advertise with us

Immigrants are good for the economy — and one only has to examine the economies of border states to see the difference a significant migrant population can make. Texas, Arizona, and California all rank in the top ten of strongest state economies, and immigrant labor is a huge factor. To say otherwise is to turn a blind eye to the very human capital that makes a strong economy possible.

So why is Greg Abbott busing them away? It’s not to protect the border, I can tell you that much.

I grew up on the US-Mexico border, in McAllen, Texas, a place that’s often in the news these days. I know that border communities have beautiful and complicated relationships with the communities on the other side of the political boundaries that define them — Americans cross over to Mexico and as much as Mexicans and folks from beyond cross over into America.

The McAllen-Reynosa bridge sees hundreds of thousands of people cross the border each day each way for employment, retail, and entertainment. One would think that a city like McAllen, a city full of immigrants, both documented and not, would be a hotspot for crime, if Republican rhetoric is to be believed.

After all, according to Greg Abbott and other like-minded folks, immigrants are criminals.

Advertise with us

McAllen had the second-lowest crime rate of any city in the state of Texas in 2021, a year that saw a record number of people crossing the border. The Rio Grande Valley has never been a violent place — despite being a place defined by its proximity to Mexico. I know this first-hand, and I still have to do a double-take when I read news that assumes criminality guides migration.

If immigrants are generally good for the economy, and if they’re generally not committing crimes, why is Abbott spending $12 million of taxpayer’s money in sending them away from Texas to Washington, D.C.?

I could argue racism. But I don’t think Abbott hates immigrants — after all, in 2005 he called immigrants people “with dreams” and “those simply wanting to call Texas home.” What people forget is that Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott was beloved by immigrants, supported by the Hispanic caucus, and generally considered to be a reasonable human being.

Governor Greg Abbott is simply scoring political points to appease an electorship at the expense of a community that’s already been through enough.

I cannot imagine walking hundreds of miles to escape violence only to end up being stripped of my humanity. Because that’s what Abbott has done. In turning real people, with real families and real struggles, into political pawns, Abbott has taken their personhood and turned them into a metaphor rooted in fear and ignorance.

Advertise with us

And I get it. Creating a mock crisis is great for political power — you never have to actually solve a crisis that doesn’t exist, but you can keep talking about it without consequences.

Meanwhile, money that could be spent actually helping people get resettled and contributing to the economy was instead spent on making a cheap political point.

This Christmas Eve, did Governor Abbott lean into the Christmas spirit? Was he charitable and kind? No. He sent a busload of migrants across the country into frigid temperatures without even providing coats. When they arrived in Washington, D.C., it was clear that they were utterly unprepared for weather in the teens; aid organizations handed out blankets.

When it backfired, who did he blame? The federal government. For not keeping the border “safe.”

But the only person endangering lives here is Greg Abbott.

Adriana E. Ramírez is a columnist for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: aramirez@post-gazette.com. Her previous article was “Beyond evil: A conversation with Patrick Radden Keefe.”