Residents of Greenfield knew that something needed to be done about the way people were driving on the neighborhood’s main roadway.
So when Pittsburgh’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure approached the community about installing traffic-calming measures on Greenfield Avenue, in an effort to make the roads safe for cyclists and pedestrians, people were happy to see changes implemented.
But soon after bollard poles were installed at the intersection of Greenfield Avenue and Ronald Street, many became worried that it actually did more harm than good.
“The speed bumps were welcomed by most people, but then the poles were put in,” said Joe Pegher, 60, lifelong Greenfield resident and former board member of the Greenfield Community Association. “The poles force you to go into oncoming traffic and it's a slight downhill. So besides the danger of being in a head-on collision, if there's ice or snow it could cause cars to slide into one another.
“My wife and a few of my friends saw it and said we should do something about this.”
So they did.
Read More
On Oct. 6, Mr. Pegher created a petition asking city officials to address the bollard poles at the intersection of Greenfield Avenue and Ronald Street, claiming that they have created dangerous driving conditions after being installed in August. The petition had just over 600 signatures in support as of Oct. 25.
“The introduction of bollard poles has forced drivers to swerve into oncoming traffic just to navigate around them, heightening the risks of head-on collisions, especially during adverse weather conditions,” Mr. Pegher said in the petition. “The residents of Greenfield were not adequately notified or consulted in this initiative. We insist that the City of Pittsburgh address this issue urgently, incorporating genuine and comprehensive feedback from the residents.”
After multiple attempts to talk to local officials about it, including District 5 City Councilwoman Barbara Warwick, the petition was created. Mr. Pegher said that he has tried speaking with Ms. Warwick, along with other officials, about removing the poles multiple times, but was met with resistance.
“Her [Ms. Warwick’s] take on it was that people are resistant to traffic calming and after some time, they’d adjust to it,” Mr. Pegher said. “I said, ‘Well, I understand that, but that's not the case here. We've taken a relatively minor problem and we've turned it into a dangerous situation.’ She told me that they had a traffic engineer look at it, and those are the people responsible for the design. I said, ‘Well, I think they made a mistake.’”
Ms. Warwick declined to comment.
Traffic-calming measures on Greenfield Avenue were drafted by the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure (DOMI) in June, according to the Neighborhood Traffic Calming Program’s website.

The draft outlined installing speed tables and raised crosswalks at certain points along the road, among other measures, which were completed on Aug. 27.
Catherine Adams, 45, resident of Greenfield and co-chair of the Greenfield Community Association’s planning and transportation committee, said that city officials, including Ms. Warwick, members of Mayor Ed Gainey’s office and engineers with DOMI, met with her and other stakeholders when the plans were being drafted.
Conducting a walk through on Greenfield Avenue, officials quickly identified that traffic calming measures needed to be taken, especially at the intersection of Greenfield Avenue and Ronald Street, she said.
“If you're a pedestrian, it's kind of treacherous at times, especially when it's dark,” she said. “As a cyclist, the same thing, Greenfield Avenue is shared with bikes and it can be a little scary sometimes. Even as a driver, there's pinch points in the neighborhood that I've almost gotten into accidents myself a number of times as a very defensive driver. So the experience is not good.”
The Department of Mobility and Infrastructure and Mr. Gainey’s office declined to comment.
Greenfield Avenue sees around 5,600 cars per day, with 50% going over the 25 mph speed limit, according to the street’s traffic summary.
The Greenfield Community Association, city officials and some residents had a meeting to discuss the drafted measures, along with it being posted online for public comment, Ms. Adams said. Initially there were minimal complaints.
Additionally, the city told the association that these measures were a “first version” of what it would look like in the area. Ms. Adams said there is currently no timeline for when the second phase will be initiated.
After dealing with the poles for several months, Ms. Adams and the Greenfield Community Association agree that action needs to be taken to address the bollard poles, finding the intersection to be “less than ideal.”
“As a resident, I don't think it's great,” she said. “I am happy that there's some kind of [traffic calming] treatment. I think it makes it safer for kids walking to school crossing that intersection, but I do think and hope to engage with DOMI on whatever version two is for the traffic calming at the intersection, and that's actually exactly what we [The GCA] plan to do.”
Ms. Adams did not sign the petition, as she feels there are more community-focused ways to make progress on the issue, but she does agree with what it stands for, she said.
Mike Terlecki, 46, of Hazelwood, is the president of the Greenfield Baseball Association, which plays on Magee Field next to the intersection, he said.
While he supports most of the traffic calming measures, and protecting kids in the neighborhood, he quickly realized that the bollard poles are “a recipe for disaster.”
“I actually run a collision shop and I see the bad side of accidents, that's exactly what the whole neighborhood's concern is,” he said. “We're going to have a really bad accident there. The community is frustrated and fed up.”
Mr. Terlecki said that when he tried to speak with Ms. Warwick about the poles he was met with immediate resistance. Once a supporter of the councilwoman, he said the two are now “at complete odds.”
He said that he signed the petition in hopes of finding some solution.
“The public is going to support doing away with the changes they [the city] made there,” he said. “I think they [the city] definitely should open up some discussion and try to figure out something better, changing that traffic pattern. It's just going to lead to a very bad accident.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.