Weeks before a final vote on Pittsburgh Mayor Ed Gainey’s proposed 2024 budget, multiple departments have met with City Council to discuss the city’s finances and specific plans for each department.

The $842.7 million proposed budget — $685 million in operating expenses and $157.7 million in capital spending — is about $39 million higher than the 2023 budget, without a proposed tax hike for city residents.

“In many ways, this budget is a continuation of investments that were made last year to ensure that we’re investing in rebuilding the city’s core capabilities to deliver services,” said Jake Pawlak, director of the Office of Management and Budget.

The 2024 budget includes no new capital projects, focusing instead on “filling funding gaps in existing projects to put them on a path to a successful and more timely completion,” Mr. Gainey said during his budget address this month.

Advertise with us

The proposed budget also doesn’t account for any future salary increases, despite upcoming contract negotiations with unions representing firefighters and EMS workers. Mr. Pawlak said he’s “confident” that the city has “adequately prepared” for any financial shortfalls.

But even though Mr. Gainey and his administration seem optimistic about the city’s fiscal future, others are more concerned.

Pittsburgh’s budget must meet three legal requirements: Revenues must be greater than expenses, the city’s debts can’t exceed more than 12% of the spending, and the reserve fund balance must be at least 10% of spending. The 2024 budget meets all those requirements, but officials warn that future years might not.

For the fund balance, “10% is the least we’re allowed, but 10% is not healthy,” said Peter McDevitt, City Council's budget director. The Government Finance Officers Association, an organization that represents public finance officials, recommends a fund balance of at least 16.7%.

Council budget hearings are scheduled to continue on Monday, with a final vote expected in mid-December.

Advertise with us

Here are some highlights from departments that have already met with Council.

Federal COVID-19 relief funding

Throughout budget discussions, concerns have been raised about the city’s federal pandemic relief funding. The city received $335 million from the federal government under the American Rescue Plan enacted in 2021.

There are no changes in the 2024 budget to the previous spending plan for the money. But 2024 is the last year that money can be used for regular operating expenses. All the money must be under contract by the end of 2024 and fully spent by the end of 2026.

Mr. Pawlak said all the funds have been allocated, but some of the spending is not yet under contract. About 50% has already been spent, he said. Whatever is not spent by the end of 2026 must be returned to the federal government, though Mr. Pawlak said he has “no fears” of that happening.

“In the not too distant future,” Mr. McDevitt said, “we’re going to have to take a hard look… and see what line items are not under contract and consider reallocating them to something we know we can spend money on.”

Advertise with us

Mr. McDevitt also warned that officials will have to start looking for new sources of revenue as the federal pandemic funding runs dry.

“We’re going to hear from the departments across the city and they’re going to tell us all the great things they did last year and all the great things they have planned for next year,” he said. “But a common theme is also going to be that they need more resources. Everyone is working under capacity.”

City Controller Michael Lamb also warned that after the pandemic-era money goes away, the city will have to find other sources of revenue to keep the budget balanced.

“The one source of revenue we have to get resolved is the nonprofit piece,” he said. “We got to get that deal done, and the sooner the better.”

Since before he took office, Mr. Gainey has emphasized getting the city’s five largest nonprofit organizations to “pay their fair share.” His administration has pursued challenges this year to the tax-exempt status of more than 20 parcels of land owned by nonprofit giants like UPMC.

Advertise with us

Mayor’s Office

After receiving a significant increase last year, the budget for the Mayor’s office has a minimal proposed increase for 2024.

In Mr. Gainey’s first budget last year, he increased allocations to his own office from about $878,000 to just over $3 million. He also consolidated numerous communications positions under his direct control.

The Mayor’s office would see an increase of about $74,000 in the proposed 2024 budget.

And after adding 34 positions to the mayor’s staff last year, more than any budget in the past decade, the office proposed a reduction of one employee for 2024.

In last year’s budget, the 311 call center, where residents can report problems from potholes to abandoned properties, was moved into the Mayor’s office. The call center would remain there under the 2024 budget, though two full-time positions would be removed and three part-time positions added.

Advertise with us

The budget also includes a 4% salary increase for employees in the Mayor’s office, including for Mr. Gainey himself.

“There haven’t been a lot of changes made from last year’s budget to this year’s budget,” Felicity Williams, the mayor’s deputy chief of staff, said during a budget hearing. “Largely the changes that were made were to account for what we’ve learned over the last year [and] to adjust for the expenses that we see going forward.”

DOMI

Even though there are no new capital projects in the 2024 budget, the Department of Mobility and Infrastructure will still be busy. Tasked with maintaining the city’s roadways, bridges, sidewalks, and more, the department received 54% of the capital budget and has the fourth largest overall budget in the city.

The budget proposes a $150,000 increase and five new positions. Some are for the city’s newly created bridge maintenance team, which expects to be fully operational by next fall, Acting Director Jeff Skalican said.

The department’s main focus points for 2024 will be on bridge maintenance and traffic calming. Construction on three major bridges — the Davis Avenue Pedestrian, the Charles Anderson Memorial, and the Panther Hollow Overpass — is slated to begin in 2024 and 13 others will begin design and engineering work.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gainey said more traffic calming measures were the most requested investment during budget conversations with city residents.

The total number of crashes in Pittsburgh are down, but serious and fatal crashes have increased, surpassing their pre-COVID levels, said Angie Martinez, DOMI’s assistant director.

There are plans for 25 new traffic calming projects in 2024.

In 2023, DOMI brought in about $17 million in grants to help fund projects, and Mr. Skalican said that if the department had someone dedicated to managing DOMI grants, it would help streamline the process and potentially bring in even more money.

Office of Management and Budget

Most of Council’s meeting with the Office of Management and Budget focused on the health of the city’s finances.

Advertise with us

In addition to the expiration of the federal COVID-19 funding, fixed debt service payments are scheduled to increase in 2025 and 2026. Projections show that revenue in those years will only exceed spending by about $3 million.

When the pandemic started in 2020, the city decided to “refinance debt payments to be paid out in the years after,” Mr. Pawlak said. That is “creating the cliff that we’re referring to now.”

“2025 and 2026 are the delayed fiscal consequences of that period,” he said. “But much less sharp of a blow than it would have been if we had experienced it at that time.”

He also said the city is starting to see “early but positive signs” of new revenue from its challenges of tax-exempt status for properties owned by nonprofits. 

The Office of Management and Budget would see its budget stay relatively flat compared to last year’s.

Advertise with us

City Controller’s Office

“The office is changing a little bit this year as noted in the budget,” Mr. Lamb said during a budget hearing.

The office is seeing a reduction of two employees and a budget that is about $44,000 lower than in 2023. That’s mainly due to the shift of what Mr. Lamb called “non-controller functions” to other departments.

Earlier this year, Mr. Gainey created the Office of Equal Protection, which will oversee enforcement of ordinances including Paid Sick Leave and Prevailing Wage — duties previously carried out by the controller.

The shift has “enabled us to do some reworking of the staff in our office,” Mr. Lamb said.

The Controller’s Office staff is still near the level it was when the city was under Act 47, the state law that helps local governments overcome financial distress. In the next few years, Mr. Lamb said, the budget will have to reflect an increase in staff for the office.

Advertise with us

Mr. Lamb, who is leaving office as the city’s independently elected fiscal watchdog after this year, also had more general concerns about Pittsburgh’s future fiscal health.

“While this budget may not be pushing the line, the next might,” he said. “As we get into these discussions about the budget, looking out over the next five years, we have real financial problems without new revenue.”

The city is going to get to a point where it has to “start questioning some of the standards” and spending, Mr. Lamb said. He called it “a little troublesome” that the city’s debt service is nearing the 12% limit.

He also said he has “some real disagreements” with the five-year projected revenue. The anticipated interest earned on the city’s money is “unreasonable,” he said, especially as spending continues and the federal funding expires.

Hallie Lauer: hlauer@post-gazette.com