Pittsburgh drivers can look forward to the arrival of red light cameras at some intersections, now that City Council has voted to join a growing list of places across the state ushering in the technology meant to reduce accidents at collision-prone intersections.
The city has not yet identified the intersections where automated cameras will be installed, although Tuesday’s vote is the latest step in what local lawmakers, experts and other Pennsylvania police departments have highlighted as an important tool to improve road safety.
Pittsburgh’s plan, which calls for fines of up $100 per violation, comes as the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure reports nearly 40% of crashes in recent years occurred because of vehicles running red lights.
And an official from Abington Township, a Montgomery County community that has helped pioneer the use of such camera systems among Pennsylvania smaller communities, said the program might have a side benefit of easing police staffing demands.
“I think it's a way to supplement when you do have staffing issues, or supplement traffic enforcement, because we can't be everywhere,” said Christopher Posey, a police officer who heads the program for the Abington department. “So this is a tool, just one of the many tools that we use to assist us in trying to make the community safer.”
The automated red light enforcement program — funded by PennDOT — has slowly grown in popularity across the state since it was established in 2010, while states like California, Illinois and Texas have been using the technology in dozens of communities for decades.
Read More
The program allows cities and municipalities to be reimbursed by PennDOT for spending on the enforcement systems, with about $14 million earmarked for reimbursement grants this fiscal year. It remains unclear how much Pittsburgh plans to spend on the program.
Across the state
In Pennsylvania, red light camera systems have been implemented at 40 intersections across Philadelphia, as well as in smaller communities like Warrington Township and Bensalem Township in Bucks County — both of which instituted the program this year.
Aside from Philadelphia, which began using the program in 2006, Abington has pioneered the program among smaller departments, implementing it at three intersections in 2010.
Since the cameras were installed, the township has seen a drop in the number of crashes, including rear end collisions, as well as angled crashes, which tend to be the most dangerous for drivers, Officer Posey told the Post-Gazette.
In the seven years following the implementation of the red light enforcement system, compared to the seven years prior, total crashes at the three intersections where the automated cameras were installed decreased by 28%, he said.
Broken down further, angled crashes — which include t-bone collisions, for example — dropped 25%, and crashes that resulted in injury fell by 34%.
According to Officer Posey, who has been guiding other police departments in their use of the state’s program, rear-end crashes sometimes spike shortly after the cameras are installed.
That’s a result of drivers braking harder in an attempt to avoid citations. He said things soon return to normal levels.
Abington saw a 22% decrease in rear-end crashes after the program began.
The cameras led to nearly 4,400 citations between January and June of this year, an average of about 730 a month. The vast majority were issued to non-residents of the township, drivers who were less likely to be aware of the locations of the cameras.
For cities like Pittsburgh that are in the fledgling stages, Officer Posey said informing people about the program is paramount.
“Knowing that the cameras are there, in itself, deters some people from red light running,” he said. “Our ultimate goal is, it would be great to have no red light camera violations and no crashes. I don't think that's ever realistic, but that's the ultimate goal.
Last month, the union representing Pittsburgh police officers claimed staffing levels in the department were “dangerously low,” and departments nationwide have grappled with the issues.
Officer Posey suggested the red light enforcement system, once installed, could help reduce some of that pressure.
Officials from Philadelphia have lauded the program’s results there. It was put into use nearly 20 years ago after a report named certain intersections along Roosevelt Boulevard — a major artery that runs through north and northeast portions of the city — among the most dangerous in the country.
“The red light camera program, since its inception in 2005, has demonstrated substantial effectiveness in improving traffic safety and compliance,” Corinne O’Connor, deputy executive director of the Philadelphia Parking Authority, said in the city’s latest annual red light camera report.
“While not without challenges, the overall benefits, such as reduced fatal and injury crashes and enhanced driver awareness, has underscored the program's value.”
Last fiscal year, red light cameras in Philadelphia, which has a population approximately five times as large as Pittsburgh, led to the issuance of more than 374,000 violations. That was a nearly 40% spike from the previous year, which Ms. O’Connor said could be due, in part, to the recent installation of better equipment.
“Newer cameras often come with improved detection and imaging capabilities, which can more accurately and reliably capture violations,” she said in the report. “Advanced radar systems, better image resolution, and enhanced data processing can result in more violations being recorded.”
Red light camera programs also have been met with some pushback over the years and have been at the center of legal fights around the country that have focused on oversight.
For example, opponents have questions whether a driver should be presumed to be a registered owner of a vehicle, and whether it is improper delegation of police powers to have a contractor review and process red light camera photos, which a Tennessee judge ultimately allowed in a ruling in 2009.
The Pittsburgh rollout
In Pittsburgh, while a concrete plan on the use of red light cameras has yet to materialize, lawmakers said Tuesday that warnings will be posted at intersections identified as future red light camera locations. Fines will be capped at $100 and an officer or other city employee will review video from each violation to ensure its accuracy before a citation is mailed.
It is unclear when red light cameras will be operational, although there will be a grace period for drivers during the first 60 days at the first intersection where cameras are installed. There will be a 30-day period at all added intersections, during which warning will be issued instead of citations.
At least 107 people have been killed and nearly 600 have been severely injured in crashes between 2019 and 2023, according to city data. A report from the Pittsburgh Department of Mobility and Infrastructure released earlier this year found that 39% of crashes occurred because of red light running.
A small group — just 10% — of the city’s streets see 62% of crashes, including 76% of fatal crashes, according to the city bill approved this week.
Since the COVID-19 pandemic, speed bumps have been installed across the city as a part of the department’s Neighborhood Traffic Calming Program, although city council members said more needed to be done to bolster road safety.
“I’m glad that we’re looking at something different because I’m seeing the city of Pittsburgh turn into speed bumps all over the place and they’re now not not working everywhere, either,” Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith said during Tuesday’s meeting.
“I do think enforcement has to be a part of every component, because it's just not working the way it is.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.