Last week, the national average price of gas dipped below $3 for the first time in four years. The median rent for U.S. apartments has dropped for four straight months. A closely watched national consumer sentiment index recently ticked upward for the first time since July.
These are among the “emerging trend of strong economic news” the White House cited Monday as Republicans, including state Treasurer Stacy Garrity and Rep. Rob Bresnahan, geared up for President Donald Trump’s visit Tuesday night to northeastern Pennsylvania.
But several metrics suggest it’s not all good news for the president and Republicans: Pennsylvanians are facing higher electricity prices this winter; the median age for first-time homebuyers is now the highest on record due to costs and limited supply, according to the National Association of Realtors; and voters remain concerned with the administration’s tariff policies, high costs of living, cuts to Medicaid and rising health care premiums, according to polls and Trump’s lagging approval ratings.
By Monday afternoon, Trump’s visit to Mount Pocono was already shaping up to become a partisan battle building up to the 2026 governor’s race and midterm elections — even though it’s an official White House event, not a Trump campaign rally.
The White House blamed former President Joe Biden for driving inflation “through the roof” with “reckless spending, open borders and anti-energy policies.” But the administration said “momentum is now unmistakably in the right direction” thanks to Trump’s actions.
The Garrity campaign told the Post-Gazette that the state is “struggling under Josh Shapiro’s failed administration.”
“We are sick of the mediocrity that Josh Shapiro has brought us,” campaign spokesman Matt Benyon said. “Josh Shapiro has taken his eye off the ball because he’s more focused on his 2028 presidential campaign than the problems facing Pennsylvanians in 2025. The treasurer is looking forward to being a partner with President Trump, and not a courtroom opponent like Josh Shapiro.”
James Markley, the state GOP spokesman, told the Post-Gazette that Trump has “done nothing but deliver on many of the major themes of his campaign.”
The president has fortified the southern border, targeted deadly drugs, crime and safety, and, “with this visit in mind, he's doing everything he can to lower prices for working families,” Mr. Markley said.
Vince Galko, a Republican strategist based in northeastern Pennsylvania, said Monroe County was a wise choice for an event “in the nexus of the political universe” in the country’s most important swing state. It’s not only home to Tobyhanna Army Depot, the region’s largest employer, but it’s the heart of the region’s tourism center and borders both Mr. Bresnahan’s and Rep. Ryan Mackenzie’s districts, he said.
Democrats implemented a full-court press ahead of Trump’s arrival.
Mr. Shapiro, who has not yet announced a re-election bid, is appearing on MSNBC Monday night.
An advocacy group, Defend America Action, announced that Lt. Gov. Austin Davis, state lawmakers and advocates would hold a press call ahead of Trump’s Poconos stop. The call will focus on the president’s “failed policies and broken promises” leading to skyrocketing costs for families, farmers and small business owners, the group said.
The Pennsylvania Democrats also issued a news released focused on Ms. Garrity, which amounted to a blow-by-blow of views linking the treasurer to the polarizing president.
“Trump’s visit to Pennsylvania will serve as a reminder of the disastrous policies Stacy Garrity is in complete support of — from the irrational tariffs that are raising our costs and killing jobs, to the drastic health care cuts and threats to rural hospitals across the commonwealth,” the Democrats said.
Choosing Pennsylvania to deliver Trump’s message is like returning to “the scene of the crime” one year after he barnstormed the critical swing state with a campaign that promised to deliver on affordability, U.S. Rep. Brendan Boyle, D-Philadelphia, said Monday.
“From northeastern Pennsylvania to southwestern Pennsylvania to my area in the Philadelphia area, up to Erie and every county in between, Donald Trump said he would lower costs for Pennsylvanians and for Americans,” Mr. Boyle said. “Well, in office, not only has he failed to do that, he's done the exact opposite.”
The congressman cited Trump’s aggressive tariff agenda and inaction on addressing health care costs as reasons for spiking prices across the country.
Michael Berman, Pennsylvania state director for the advocacy group Protect Our Care, also highlighted the looming increase in premiums for individuals who get their health insurance under the Affordable Care Act.
Pennie, the public marketplace for Pennsylvania, has said costs will go up by an average of 102% across the state if Congress does not extend tax credits by the end of the month.
“The president is coming to our state to sort of cover up what he’s been doing in Washington and hide the fact that he’s been making costs harder for average Pennsylvanians,” Mr. Berman said.
Tori Baggot, a Pittsburgh resident who recently spoke on Capitol Hill, said her monthly payments are set to spike from $197 to $365, which could force her to pull back on growing her small letterpress printing business and potentially delay her plans for starting a family.
“I would like the president to consider the fact that without health care, we can't have a healthy workforce,” Ms. Baggot said Monday when asked about her message to Trump ahead of the Pennsylvania visit. “There's no point in talking about the economy unless we fix this health care dilemma that we are in currently.”
Both parties have acknowledged those pain points while diverging on the larger affordability issue and Trump’s record of tackling it.
During a Cabinet meeting last week, Trump characterized the issue of affordability as a “con job” by Democrats.
“They just say the word,” he said. “It doesn’t mean anything to anybody. I inherited the worst inflation in history. There was no affordability. Nobody could afford anything.”
Republican U.S. Sen. Dave McCormick has sympathized with lower- and middle-income individuals who get their insurance through the marketplace and said he wants to extend the subsidies that keep costs low — although with reforms.
He’s also routinely praised the president for his economic agenda and claimed it is already having tangible benefits by lowering inflation and raising wages.
In a Fox News interview on Sunday, he previewed Tuesday’s event by pointing to changes to the child care tax credit — which increased the payment but also made changes to eligibility requirements — and to eliminating taxes on tips and overtime pay as ways Republicans are “putting money in the pockets of working families.”
“We’ve made a lot of progress, but there’s a lot more work to do,” Mr. McCormick said. “I think the president will lay out that agenda and how all the policies that he’s put in place are going to help working families. And there’s more to come.”
On top of the governor’s race, the region is facing potentially competitive U.S. House races. Mr. Bresnahan last year won a seat long held by Democrats, and Scranton Mayor Paige Cognetti and attorney Francis McHale have announced bids to flip the seat blue.
J.J. Balaban, a Philadelphia-based Democratic strategist and admaker, said Republicans in tough campaigns in 2026 such as Mr. Bresnahan face a “fundamental challenge” that Republicans consistently underperform when Trump is not on the ballot.
“Presumably, Bresnahan is calculating that Trump’s visit will raise Republican enthusiasm,” he said. “The problem is that it is unlikely to help Bresnahan appeal to swing voters.”
Mr. Mackenzie’s re-election race in the 7th District is seen as a toss-up by multiple political trackers. Several Democrats have lined up trying to flip the seat, including Pennsylvania Professional Firefighters Association President Bob Brooks, Ryan Crosswell, Northampton County Executive Lamont McClure, former PPL Executive Carol Obando-Derstine and Lehigh County Controller Mark Pinsley.
Christopher Nicholas, a Republican consultant based in Harrisburg, said it was smart for Trump to come to Pennsylvania, particularly to talk about the economy — which helped send Trump back to the White House.
“I think it's fine that he’s been spending time on foreign policy, but the elections from November made it clear that Republicans need to spend more time talking about domestic issues,” he said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.