Pennsylvania Republicans are taking stock of sweeping Democratic wins up and down the ballot Tuesday, including a pivotal state Supreme Court campaign focused on contentious state and national issues, while Gov. Josh Shapiro and other Democrats across the country celebrate a dominant showing ahead of midterm elections in 2026.
Voters Tuesday retained Justices Christine Donohue, Kevin Dougherty and David Wecht for another 10-year term, holding the court’s Democratic 5-2 majority. Conservatives will have another chance to slightly shake up the court after Justice Donohue retires in 2027, when she reaches the age of 75.
The retention elections — coming in what’s typically a quiet off-year contest — spurred unprecedented attention and outside spending, with abortion, election law, pandemic measures, redistricting and other issues highlighted in persistent back-and-forth advertising. Democrats cited the Supreme Court wins as part of a nationwide wave that rebuked President Donald Trump’s agenda and galvanized various factions of the Democratic Party and independent voters ahead of 2026 and the 2028 race for the White House.
Almost exactly a year after Trump carried swing states like Pennsylvania to win back the presidency, Republican strategists and even the conservative network tied to billionaire GOP megadonor Jeffrey Yass — which invested in the fight against retention of the Supreme Court justices — suggested the party has some work to do to avoid a repeat of Democrats’ victories Tuesday.
“It was a good day to have a D after your name,” Christopher Nicholas, a Republican consultant based in Harrisburg, told the Post-Gazette Wednesday. “We need to govern better so we can do better at the polls.”
Progressive and conservative groups spent at least $16.5 million combined on political advertising in the retention election, according to AdImpact, with the left outspending conservatives by almost five to one.
Read More
“Unfortunately, out-of-state special interests, unions, and trial lawyers were the big winners on Tuesday — not the people of Pennsylvania,” Matthew Brouillette, president and CEO of the Yass-associated Commonwealth Partners Chamber of Entrepreneurs, told the Post-Gazette in a statement. “While those who support the rule of law came up short in our historic effort to unseat sitting justices, judges across Pennsylvania should take note that they won't get a pass on retention elections when they choose to legislate from the bench rather than interpret the law.”
Asked about losing momentum after conservatives built a “vote no” effort that conservatives and progressives alike said was robust earlier this year, Mr. Brouillette added that, “It was unfortunate that while the left was able to rally more than 40 groups to fund and fight for [Pennsylvania’s] progressive justices, the right clearly lacked the motivation to get engaged like we hoped.”
Douglas Keith, of the Brennan Center for Justice, told the Post-Gazette last month that the race was already shaping up to be the most expensive fight over retention in Pennsylvania history.
He estimated that roughly $15 million was spent on efforts to retain the justices, with about $5.5 million spent on the “no” side, the New York Times reported.
AdImpact listed the retention battle among the five most expensive statewide contests across the country in the last week of the campaign. But there appeared to be a big dropoff on the conservative side.
Over the final six days, “yes” vote supporters reserved $982,000 in future ads, compared to just $27,000 for groups against the justices, according to AdImpact.
That tracks with Democratic-aligned groups outspending the right in New Jersey and California races in the home stretch, though conservatives spent more reserving ads in gubernatorial and attorney general races in Virginia in the run up to Election Day.
“The forces of [the ‘no’ vote] basically pulled the plug,” Larry Ceisler, a Pennsylvania public affairs executive and a Democrat, told the Post-Gazette. “It’s counterintuitive to how you run a campaign.”
What’s more, Mr. Ceisler said, the initial steam gained by conservatives early on in the retention elections may have been a key factor in what led to “a Democratic blowout” across the state. When fewer ads against retention showed up on the air, it helped embolden progressive groups such as Planned Parenthood, the ACLU, Reproductive Freedom for All and others pouring money and resources into the “yes” campaign, he said.
“The people who designed and supported the ‘no’ campaign not only undermined their own effort, they undermined every Republican candidate from school board to county row offices,” Mr. Ceisler said.
Republican political experts were quick to point out that opening the door to flip the court was always going to be an uphill battle.
Republicans emphasized Wednesday that while Democrats clearly swept races small and large in Pennsylvania and other states — ranging from local elections to gubernatorial contests in Virginia and New Jersey and a redistricting proposition in California — retention elections have only led to one justice being ousted since Pennsylvania implemented the process more than 50 years ago.
And Mr. Nicholas said it was “hard to extrapolate a retention vote” to what may happen in 2026 or 2028, as retention elections are unique compared to a traditional race with opposing candidates.
“Historical precedent showed it was going to be a difficult year for Republicans regardless,” Vince Galko, a GOP strategist based in Northeastern Pennsylvania, told the Post-Gazette. “The Republican party deserves credit for going after an opportunity. But it was a Herculean task. The other side had too much firepower.”
Mr. Galko said Republicans have to review what can be changed to boost turnout — “whether messaging or tactics, or a little bit of both.”
“A year ago we had probably the greatest night in Pennsylvania Republican history,” he added. “But you can't be complacent. It's a nonstop battle. Republicans will lick their wounds for a few days, but only have to look back 365 days and realize greatness is possible in this state. You have to keep fighting.”
That echoed the message from state Sen. Greg Rothman, the Pennsylvania GOP chairman. He told the Post-Gazette in a statement that just last year, the party was “celebrating tremendous victories.”
He said the Republicans must do a better job of communicating core principles of freedom, security, prosperity and opportunity for all, and a vision for the state and country’s future.
“Last night the Republican Party sustained losses in Pennsylvania and across the nation,” he said. “We knew this would be a tough election cycle, but if the choice is to fight or run, we will always choose to stand and fight.”
Lew Irwin, a political scientist at Duquesne University, said Supreme Court retention races are “quirky” and historically predictable.
“In this case, voters were savvy,” he said. “They don’t always get the details or concern themselves with all the inside baseball but this energized Democrats who have lived through a pretty rough year, where they haven't had leverage over anything.”
He said Democrats have had to grapple with a Republican “quadfecta” — control over the White House, the U.S. Senate and House, and the U.S. Supreme Court.
“They have just watched the president and administration do whatever they want, with no ability to push back,” he said.
But races like the retention election and California’s Proposition 50 — a successful move by Gov. Gavin Newsom to blunt Trump-led efforts to reshuffle Texas congressional maps in Republicans’ favor — marked the “first opportunity other than niche special elections to really push back and strengthen the guardrails in anticipation of 2026 and 2028.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.